The Mets have plenty of moving parts this offseason, but one need stands out: they have to find a way to get more production against left-handed pitching. That’s where Coby Mayo starts to look like a real fit.
The Baltimore Orioles infielder is not a perfect player, and that’s exactly why he makes sense as a target. At 24, Mayo still has flaws, but the things he does well are loud. He has a 1.112 OPS against lefties this season with 16 home runs, and that kind of damage is hard to ignore for a Mets team that kept chasing the same answer all year without finding a reliable one.
New York spent the 2026 campaign trying to patch that hole beyond Mark Vientos, and none of the options really stuck. Austin Slater, Tommy Pham, Eric Wagaman and others got their chances. The production never settled in.
Mayo also brings a different shape than Vientos. The comparison is obvious: both are limited right now, both have work to do, and both can punish mistakes.
But Mayo’s best traits show up at a higher level. He’s already at 24 home runs this season after his dash around the bases earlier this week against the Mets, and he pairs that power with a little more speed.
Mayo sits in the 63rd percentile in sprint speed, while Vientos is 14th.
Defensively, neither player is a gold standard, but Mayo’s numbers are the better bet. At third base this year, he has posted -3 OAA, which is cleaner than what Vientos produced there in his time at the position.
Vientos finished at -6 in 2024 and -7 in 2025. At first base, the gap holds too: Vientos is at -10 OAA, while Mayo was at -2 in 2025 during about half a season at the position.
That matters because the Mets don’t have a simple place to hide another bat. Pete Alonso is still around, and he is not the full-time DH, so moving Mayo across the diamond to first base is not an easy solution. Third base is where the conversation really lives.
The cost would not be small. Mayo entered the 2025 season as the 14th-best prospect in the sport, so Baltimore would not be expected to move him cheaply, even with his shortcomings known.
That means the Mets would have to get creative with what they offer. They have pitching depth that could be moved, and names like Jonah Tong, Gary Gill Hill, Chris Suero and Jacob Reimer could draw interest because of their paths - or lack of paths - to the majors. Brett Baty could also make sense if the Orioles have any appetite for him, especially since Mayo’s value comes more from his bat than his glove and Baty still carries upside of his own.
There are other ways this could go, too. A starting pitcher or another third base option might end up being the better target for Baltimore. The Mets do have plenty of arms and infielders after restocking the farm system at the trade deadline, and players such as Emilien Pitre, Sammy Stafura and even Bruin Agbayani could get pushed into the odd-man-out category quickly if Jefferson Rojas is at third base and Mitch Voit is at second.
In Other News...
Mets Just Got The Kind Of Win Fans Needed Against Philly
The Mets got the kind of much-needed night at home they had been searching for, jumping on the Phillies early and then doing enough on the mound to protect the lead in a 6-3 win. Zac Thornton gave them a steady start, working six innings and allowing two runs, while the offense built a cushion that let New York play from ahead for most of the game.
Juan Sotos three-run home run gave Philadelphia a real jolt, but the Mets answered with enough scoring plays and pitching changes to keep the game on their terms. It was the sort of win that does more than add one in the standings, because against a division opponent like Philly, especially in a game with some back-and-forth tension, New York needed to show it could absorb a punch and still finish the job. [Read more 🡒]
Mets Face A Tough Bullpen Decision With Tobias Myers
The Mets bullpen picture is still taking shape, and the competition between Jonathan Pintaro and Tobias Myers has become one of the more interesting roster questions heading into the next round of decisions. Myers has flashed enough early to keep himself in the conversation, while Pintaro has quietly put together a steadier run in relief, giving the club two different looks for the same multi-inning job.
What makes the choice tricky is the roster math behind it. Myers is in line for a non-tender decision because his minor league options are used up, while Pintaro still has a minor league option available for 2027. For a bullpen that values flexibility, that kind of edge matters, and it leaves the Mets weighing upside against practicality as they shape the staff. [Read more 🡒]
Phillies Rotation Trouble Just Got More Interesting For Mets Fans
Jess Luzardo landing on the injured list with stiffness in his left shoulder only added another layer to a Phillies rotation that has already needed some patchwork work. Philadelphia responded by claiming Jos Urquidy off waivers from the White Sox, a move that gave the club another experienced arm to lean on as it tries to keep the pitching staff afloat through a tricky stretch.
Urquidy was thrown right into the mix in relief and gave the Phillies exactly the kind of length they needed, working 4.2 innings, allowing five hits and striking out six while helping spare the bullpen. Even so, the night still ended in a loss, and the roster shuffle continued with Kyle Backhus being optioned to Triple-A to clear a spot, leaving the Phillies with more questions than answers as they wait to see how long Luzardo is sidelined. [Read more 🡒]