The Mets are headed into the offseason with a clear need at first base, and the most practical answer might not be the biggest name on the market.
After moving on from Pete Alonso last winter, President of Baseball Operations David Stearns got a harsh reminder of what that position looks like without a true everyday anchor. Jorge Polanco filled in as Alonso’s replacement, but an injury-marred 2026 season likely leaves him limited to designated hitter work next year. That opened the door for Jared Young, who made the most of his chance and put himself firmly in the conversation for a bigger role.
Young appeared in 103 games and hit .266/.330/.429 with 17 doubles, nine home runs and 39 RBIs. That’s useful production, but it doesn’t scream “full-time first baseman” for 2027. The cleaner setup for New York would be to pair him with a right-handed bat and form a platoon.
Among the available options, Jake Burger stands out as the best trade fit.
Burger doesn’t carry the same name recognition as some other first basemen, but the power is real. In three of his four full major league seasons, the right-handed hitter has launched at least 28 home runs. The underlying tools back that up, too: his 75.7 mph bat speed and 12.3% barrel rate both sit in at least the 80th percentile, according to Baseball Savant.
The catch is consistency. Burger’s 2026 season was uneven, and he finished at .228/.302/.421 with 23 doubles, 28 home runs and 90 RBIs.
A lot of that damage came against left-handed pitching, where he hit .265 with 12 home runs and an .891 OPS. Against right-handers, though, he managed just .215 with a .659 OPS.
That split is exactly why he makes sense for the Mets. In a platoon, Burger could be deployed mostly against lefties, where his bat plays best, while Young handles the other side of the matchup. It’s a natural fit.
The Rangers may also be in a position to listen. Evan Grant of the Dallas Morning News reported that Texas is open to moving several key players this offseason as it looks to “reallocate” money while keeping payroll around $190 million. Burger isn’t one of the club’s priciest pieces, with MLB Trade Rumors projecting him at $6.9 million in arbitration, but the presence of higher-paid veterans with full no-trade clauses - Jacob deGrom, Corey Seager and Nathan Eovaldi - could make him more available.
There’s another layer here for New York: Burger comes with two more seasons of team control. That makes him more than a short-term patch. And because he plays a less premium position and has had his share of offensive inconsistency, he probably wouldn’t cost as much in a trade as established first basemen such as Yandy Diaz or Christian Walker.
He’d also bring a solid glove. Burger isn’t a Gold Glove defender, but he posted plus-1 Outs Above Average at first base last season, which adds to his appeal.
The Mets do have other right-handed first-base possibilities, including Ty France and Paul Goldschmidt in free agency. But if they end up spending heavily elsewhere - on top targets like Tarik Skubal or Michael King, for example - a lower-cost trade route could make more sense. Burger fits that lane.
A Burger-Young platoon would give the Mets balance at first base and let each hitter work in the spots that suit him best. If Burger sharpens his production against right-handed pitching, he could even grow into the everyday job, with Young sliding into a bench or designated hitter role.
It may not be the splashiest move on the board, but for a team trying to rebuild the position without overpaying, it could be one of the smartest.
In Other News...
Mets May Have Found A Risky Pete Alonso Replacement
The Mets are still sorting through life after Pete Alonso, and the search has already taken them into some uneasy territory. Jorge Polanco was brought in to handle first base, but the fit never really took hold, with his struggles at the position and injury issues in 2026 forcing the club to keep looking for a more stable answer.
One name that has surfaced is Spencer Torkelson, the Tigers first baseman whose power would fit the lineup but whose defense has raised questions. A deal would likely cost the Mets prospects Ryan Clifford and Will Watson, which underscores how much they may have to give up to patch a spot that has become one of the more complicated on the roster, especially with free-agent alternatives like Ty France and Jake Bauers also in the mix. [Read more 🡒]
Mets Suddenly Have A Real Carson Benge Lineup Dilemma
Carson Benges 2026 season gave the Mets something they did not necessarily expect to be debating this soon: where he belongs in the lineup. After a slow start, Benge settled in and showed real growth in both batting average and power, enough to make him a legitimate option near the top of the order rather than just another young bat trying to find his footing. For a club that spent much of the year leaning on Francisco Lindor in the leadoff spot, that kind of emergence changes the conversation in a meaningful way.
Lindors profile only adds to the intrigue. He has primarily hit first, but his power production has looked more like a cleanup hitters than a classic table-setters, which opens the door to a reshuffled 2027 alignment. If the Mets decide Benge is ready to lead off and Lindor is better suited driving in runs behind him, it would be a notable shift in how they build their offense. For now, it is the kind of lineup dilemma teams welcome, even if it leaves one obvious question hanging over the winter. [Read more 🡒]
Mets Just Added Another Hitting Voice To A Staff Already Crowded
The Mets are adding another familiar name to the hitting side, hiring Johnny Washington as a co-hitting coach on Andy Greens staff. Washington comes over after serving as the Braves minor league hitting coordinator, and he brings previous big-league experience from the Angels and Padres, giving New York another voice with a broad background in player development and major league instruction.
It is a crowded setup for a department that already includes two hitting coaches and recently saw Mariano Duncan promoted to the major league staff. For a club trying to get more consistency at the plate, the move suggests the organization wants as many perspectives as possible in the room, even if it leaves open how all those voices will be sorted out once the season gets moving. [Read more 🡒]