The Mets have spent decades building a draft record that stacks up with just about anyone’s. The organization has turned picks into franchise staples, All-Stars and, in a few cases, stars who left Queens and still carved out huge big league careers.
With the MLB Draft nearing, it’s a good time to look back at the five best selections in Mets history. Some names are obvious.
Others are a little more complicated. But all of them left a real mark.
At No. 5 is Nolan Ryan, which feels strange at first glance because so much of his legend was built somewhere else. Still, few players ever drafted by the Mets had a bigger overall impact in the majors. Ryan was part of the 1969 Miracle Mets as a middle-of-the-rotation starter before being traded to the Los Angeles Angels in 1971 in the Jim Fregrosi trade.
What came next was the real shock. Ryan went from an inconsistent pitcher in New York to a Hall of Famer through years of elite work with the Angels, Astros and Rangers. His only ring came with the Mets, and that helps him edge out names like Pete Alonso and Brandon Nimmo for now.
Jacob deGrom sits right behind him, and even though his career is still active, he’s already the best developmental draft story the Mets have ever had. New York grabbed him in the ninth round after a college conversion from shortstop to pitcher, then watched him become one of the most dominant arms in baseball.
His peak from 2018 to 2021 was as good as it gets. deGrom won back-to-back Cy Young Awards and came close to Bob Gibson’s modern-era single-season ERA mark before injuries ended his 2021 season in July. The Mets didn’t give him enough offense early on, and that’s why he picked up his 100th career victory with Texas this season. Even so, his case for the Hall of Fame should be a fascinating one when he’s done.
David Wright comes in at No. 3, and this one traces back to a compensation pick the Mets received in 2001 after Mike Hampton’s appreciation for the Colorado educational system. They turned that pick into a franchise cornerstone.
Wright was an All-Star almost from the moment he arrived and became one of the rare homegrown Mets position players to spend his entire career in Flushing. A back injury shortened what could have been an even bigger career and kept him from owning every Mets offensive record, but he still has a chance at Cooperstown. He first appeared on the ballot in 2024 and has been climbing since.
The top two are inseparable enough that the Mets retired their numbers together in 2024. Dwight Gooden comes in at No. 2 after being the club’s top pick in 1982 and reaching the majors just two years later.
Gooden wasted no time becoming a force. He won Rookie of the Year in 1984, took home the Cy Young in 1985 and became the ace of the 1986 Mets.
He anchored the rotation through 1995, though drug problems damaged his Hall of Fame case. Even with that setback, the numbers he put up put him in a class that only deGrom and Tom Seaver have really matched in franchise history.
At No. 1 is Darryl Strawberry, the top pick in the 1980 draft and still the best draft selection the Mets have ever made. He arrived in 1983 and quickly became the centerpiece of the lineup, making the All-Star team every year from 1984 through 1990.
Strawberry also won two Silver Slugger awards and played a major role in the Mets’ 1986 World Series title. Drug problems ended his Mets run earlier than anyone would have wanted, and Frank Cashen let him go to the Los Angeles Dodgers after the 1990 season. Even so, Strawberry left Queens as the franchise’s all-time home run leader, a mark that stood for 35 years until Alonso broke it last summer.
In Other News...
Mets Just Sent Ronny Mauricio A Message Fans Can't Ignore
Ronny Mauricios path back to the Mets took another hit when the club needed infield help after Mark Vientos landed on the injured list. Instead of giving Mauricio the opening, New York turned elsewhere, a decision that speaks to where the organization sees him right now and how crowded the infield picture has become.
Mauricios major league stint has not matched the promise he has shown in the minors, and his production at the top level has been too light to force the issue. He has been sent back to Triple-A, where he can keep playing every day, but for now the message is clear: the Mets are not handing him a job, and the next step in his season will have to be earned the hard way. [Read more 🡒]
Mets 2027 Rotation Looks Closer Than Fans Think But One Need Looms
The Mets can already sketch a plausible 2027 rotation without squinting too hard, which is not something that has always been true for this franchise. Sean Manaea, Nolan McLean, Christian Scott and Clay Holmes give the club a mix of established arms and younger pieces to imagine around, while Freddy Peralta sits out there as the kind of proven starter who could change the whole conversation if the price ever lines up.
Still, the picture is not complete, and that is what makes the next couple of seasons so interesting in Queens. The organization has internal depth to consider, including Jonah Tong as a possible long-term answer, but the real issue is finding the kind of frontline starter that can anchor a postseason-caliber staff. However the Mets go about it, whether through the trade market or a bigger swing in free agency, the need for a true ace is the part of the rotation puzzle that remains unsolved. [Read more 🡒]
Former Mets Draft Pick Is Suddenly Back In The Spotlight
Gavyn Jones has quietly worked his way back into the conversation since the Mets took the left-hander in the 18th round of the 2023 MLB Draft and he opted for college instead of signing. After beginning at McLennan Community College, he moved on to Oklahoma and settled into a bigger role with the Sooners, giving him a chance to keep developing rather than jumping straight into pro ball. He also got valuable summer work in the Cape Cod Baseball League, the kind of stage that tends to put a pitcher back on scouts radar.
Now draft eligible again, Jones is once more the sort of name teams will have to sort through carefully because the path has already taken a few turns. He was the only one of the Mets 2023 high school draftees not to sign, and his rise through junior college and Oklahoma has only added to the intrigue around what comes next. For the Mets, it is another reminder that a late-round pick can leave the organization, grow elsewhere and still circle back into the spotlight. [Read more 🡒]