Mets Have A Real Shot At Two Yankees Arms With One Big Catch

The NY Mets are in a unique position to possibly benefit from unexpected Yankees player releases, with key advisors potentially influencing the acquisition of a seasoned reliever battling injury challenges.

The Yankees’ decision to non-tender Fernando Cruz and Luis Gil on Friday immediately put both pitchers on the radar for the Mets, and not just because of their talent. Each one also comes with a front-office connection that makes the fit a little more interesting.

Cruz has a clear tie to newly hired Mets advisor Derek Johnson. A former Cincinnati Reds reliever, Cruz didn’t reach the majors until his age-32 season, and even after posting a 3.13 ERA this past year, the Yankees were not willing to commit roughly $2.3 million to him, according to the MLB Trade Rumors projection.

Health is the big issue here. Cruz has been diagnosed with a partially torn UCL, and while that does not guarantee he misses time, it does put his future in a precarious spot.

He is already closer to 40 than 30, and he turns 37 in March, which makes the free-agent market a tougher place for him.

That said, Cruz’s best work came over the last two seasons with the Yankees, while Johnson had seen a less effective version of him back in Cincinnati. Even so, the Mets could at least get some extra perspective from Johnson if they decide to take a run at him.

David Stearns could also be part of that conversation, and the Mets have shown they are not afraid to take chances on pitchers with injury histories or even guys already on the injured list. Cruz looks like the kind of arm that would likely need an incentive-heavy deal.

Gil is a different kind of case. The former Minnesota Twins prospect ended up with the Yankees in the trade for Jake Cave, a deal that still looks rough for Minnesota years later.

Derek Falvey was part of that decision, and the trade eventually led to Gil winning the 2024 AL Rookie of the Year. Cave, meanwhile, became a useful bench piece for the Twins and is now bouncing around the minors and international leagues.

For the Mets, Gil presents both appeal and a roster puzzle. He is only 28 and does not turn another year older until next June, but he has spent much of the past two seasons either hurt or in the minors.

The Mets value starting pitching depth, and Gil still profiles more as a starter than a reliever. That makes him harder to place than Cruz, who could fit into almost any bullpen.

The problem is that the Mets would need to clear space to make Gil work. If they were to land Tarik Skubal, for example, Nolan McLean and Christian Scott would already have rotation spots locked in.

Sean Manaea and Kodai Senga are outliers, and Zac Thornton could be pushed aside if the club upgrades elsewhere. Even then, it is fair to ask whether Gil would actually be an upgrade over Thornton.

Gil could wind up as a long man in the bullpen if starting does not click right away, but that is not necessarily the role he wants or the one another team might be more willing to promise him. The Mets have taken shots on players like this before, and Griffin Canning stands out as one of the more successful examples of an outcast who found his footing.

Falvey’s influence here would be limited given how much time has passed since the Twins traded Gil away. The bigger issue is that signing him would create more uncertainty around the rotation rather than less. Unless Gil is open to a minor league deal, the Mets can probably do better.

Cruz, by contrast, feels like the cleaner gamble. But if the Yankees were not interested at that price, it raises obvious questions about where he stands physically.

For Gil, the issue is less about fit in theory and more about timing and guarantees. An out-of-options pitcher trying to stay healthy and coming off a rough year is not exactly the ideal target.

In Other News...

Mets Bullpen Addition Says Plenty About David Stearns Pitching Plan

The Mets added another arm to their bullpen mix, signing left-handed reliever Darwinzon Hernndez to a three-year, $12 million contract. It is the kind of move that fits neatly into the broader way David Stearns has approached pitching depth, with the front office continuing to look for options that can strengthen the staff without waiting around for the market to settle.

Around the league, the Rockies landed pitchers Luis Castillo and Davis Martin in a trade with the White Sox, while Nationals catching coach Bobby Wilson is headed to the Astros as their bench coach. Against that backdrop of roster churn and constant speculation, Hernndezs deal stands out as a reminder that the Mets are still shaping their pitching group with an eye on both present value and longer-term flexibility, even if the rest of the winter keeps producing more noise than answers. [Read more 🡒]

Mets May Have Found A New Pitching Fit They Actually Need

The Mets are taking a look at another intriguing arm as they continue to sort through their pitching options this winter. Free agent Kaima Taira is on their radar, and the club is planning a Zoom meeting with him after a strong season in Japan that showed the kind of versatility teams tend to value this time of year.

Tairas background gives the Mets something to think about because he has worked both as a starter and a closer, which opens the door to multiple roles if the fit is right. For now, it is still just part of the evaluation process, with no contract finalized, but it is the kind of pitcher profile that could help a staff looking for answers in both the rotation and the bullpen. [Read more 🡒]

Mets Tender Deadline Hints At More Bullpen Turnover Than Fans Expected

The Mets tender deadline brought a little more roster churn than some around the club may have expected, especially on the pitching side. New York moved on from Christopher Morel, Dylan Ross and Hayden Senger, while keeping a core of younger and more established pieces in place by tendering contracts to Francisco Alvarez, Brett Baty, Reed Garrett, Tylor Megill, Dedniel Nez and Mark Vientos.

There was also a flurry of bullpen-related movement around the edges of the roster, with the Mets agreeing to one-year deals with Cionel Prez and Austin Warren and claiming Yunior Tur off waivers from the Athletics. The shuffle did not stop there, either, as Chayce McDermott went to the Cubs on waivers, a reminder that this part of the winter can change a bullpen picture quickly even before the bigger moves arrive. [Read more 🡒]