One of the latest Mets rumors has tied New York to free agent first baseman Ty France, and on the surface it makes sense. France is coming off a career year, and his profile lines up with what the Mets need. But once you start digging into the fit, there are still a few real questions hanging over the idea.
The biggest one is simple: would the Mets go to a fourth year?
Jake Bauers landing four years and $58 million nudges the market a bit for France, even if the two players bring different things to the table. France is a year older, but he’s also more accomplished and a much better defender.
That could push him toward wanting the same kind of term, and he may need it. He’s not the sort of player who can walk into free agency and bank on a comfortable deal all the way into his age-36 season.
That matters because three years has been the ceiling for Mets free-agent signings under David Stearns, with Juan Soto the exception. Tarik Skubal, of course, would be a different kind of case entirely.
The Mets passed on Pete Alonso, at least in part, because of the years involved and concerns about how he would age. So if they were to give France four years, they’d be asking everyone to accept a pretty awkward contrast: France gets the extra year, Alonso didn’t.
Stearns doesn’t seem especially worried about looking like a hypocrite, but signing France could put him in that spot.
There’s also the possibility that the Mets try to solve the money issue by compressing the salary instead of the years. That’s where this starts to feel a lot like Jorge Polanco.
Four years’ worth of money in three years is workable, and it’s the kind of structure the Mets have used before. But with France, that could mean paying around $20 million per year, which feels steep for a player whose recent track record has been uneven.
France has had useful seasons, but he’s also had enough inconsistency to make you pause. From 2023 to 2025, he was not especially impressive, with a .703 OPS in the first year of that stretch as his best. He posted a comparable season to 2026 back in 2022 with the Seattle Mariners, but overall he’s been more unpredictable than dominant.
That’s part of why the Mets may have cleaner paths elsewhere at first base. If they believe in Young, they may be better served looking at other free agents.
They already have interest in Alec Bohm, who brings a bat but not much glove, and who looks like a less powerful but more productive version of Mark Vientos. He’d likely need a shorter deal.
Paul Goldschmidt may be an even neater fit, especially if the Mets want a right-handed platoon partner type of role like he had with the New York Yankees. He’s still the better defender of the two.
And if they want to keep looking beyond free agency, the trade market gives them more room to maneuver. The Mets don’t have a prospect group that looks ready to force the issue, but they do have names to consider.
Ryan Clifford could develop into more than a power bat, and Corey Collins offers an OBP-heavy profile. Between those options and the trade field, the Mets have enough alternatives that they don’t need to force themselves into an uncomfortable Ty France deal.
In Other News...
Mets Face One Team That Could Ruin Their Tarik Skubal Push
Tarik Skubal is shaping up to be one of the biggest names on the market before the current collective bargaining agreement expires on Dec. 1, and the Mets have already surfaced as one of the teams with a real chance to land him. For a club that has not been shy about chasing top-end talent, that puts them in the middle of a bidding picture that also includes the Dodgers, Padres and Blue Jays, each weighing its own payroll realities and roster priorities as the clock keeps moving.
The wrinkle for the Mets is that this is not just about money, even if money will matter plenty. Skubals camp is expected to have preferences that could influence where he lands, and the teams in the mix are coming at the pursuit from very different angles, with some better positioned than others to make a clean fit. No deal has been announced yet, which leaves New York waiting to see whether its early standing in the race is enough to survive the final stretch. [Read more 🡒]
Yankees Could Get An Early Warning From This Ex-Bullpen Arms Market
The Blue Jays rough 2026 season left them staring at a familiar winter priority list, with injuries hammering the starting rotation and the bullpen likely to get its share of attention, too. Toronto is expected to be aggressive in the offseason as it looks for upgrades on both fronts, and one name already drawing notice is free agent reliever Jonathan Loaisiga, a pitcher whose market appears to be forming quickly.
Loaisigas appeal is easy to see for a club trying to patch together depth and swing-and-miss relief help, but Toronto is not alone in the chase. With multiple teams also in the mix, the early interest around the right-hander could become one of the first signs of how competitive the bullpen market may be, and for the Yankees, it offers a useful read on how much demand there may be for familiar arms from around the division. [Read more 🡒]
Mets Fans May Have Forgotten How Valuable Carlos Torres Really Was
When the Mets signed Carlos Torres in 2012, he was more of a useful arm than a headline name, a pitcher with Triple-A mileage, some big-league experience with the White Sox and even a stint in Japan. What followed over the next two seasons was exactly the kind of steady, flexible work that often gets overlooked later: Torres filled whatever role the roster needed, starting and relieving while giving the Mets dependable innings in 2013 and 2014.
His value was easy to miss because it rarely came wrapped in flash, but the results were there. Torres posted ERAs of 3.44 and 3.06 in those two seasons before things unraveled in 2015, when his performance slipped and the Mets moved on. He was released and later caught on with the Braves and Brewers, a reminder that even for a pitcher who never quite became a centerpiece, there was a stretch when he was quietly doing a lot of useful work in Queens. [Read more 🡒]
