One of the Mets’ biggest winter questions sits right at first base, and David Stearns is clearly weighing every possible answer. Free agency is part of the conversation - The Athletic’s Will Sammon reported interest in Alec Bohm on Thursday - but FanSided’s Pat Ragazzo also floated a trade route that would send St. Louis Cardinals first baseman Alec Burleson to New York.
Burleson would come with a loud résumé from 2025. In St.
Louis, the 28-year-old broke out with a .279 average, 26 home runs and 116 RBI in 605 at-bats, finishing as the league leader in RBI. He also posted an .816 OPS and 3.7 Wins Above Replacement, production that put him in the mix for down-ballot MVP consideration.
On paper, Burleson looks like the kind of player a team would want to keep. But the Cardinals also have to think about timing.
He still has two years of club control left before reaching free agency, which gives St. Louis a chance to either work out an extension or test the trade market while his value is high.
For the Mets, the fit is obvious enough. Burleson would be a clear upgrade over Jared Young and could let Young slide back into a utility role that suits him better. The problem is the price tag, which could climb quickly.
That’s partly because the free-agent first base market doesn’t offer much separation. Bohm, Jake Bauers and Ty France are among the names at the top of that group, and none of them scream impact addition. With Burleson under control for two more seasons, the Cardinals could push for a return that reflects both his age and his production.
If New York got serious, controllable pitching would likely have to be the centerpiece. St.
Louis has needs throughout its rotation, so a package built around an arm would make sense. Stearns might be willing to include a big leaguer such as Zac Thornton, though the Cardinals could prefer a higher-upside pitcher like Jonathan Santucci.
The Cardinals could also ask for infield help, especially at third base. Their middle infield appears set with J.J.
Wetherholt and Masyn Wynn, and Jefferson Rojas is expected to be off limits. That leaves the Mets looking at Brett Baty as a major-league option or a prospect from the Jacob Reimer, Emilien Pitre, Sammy Stafura group as the headliner on the infield side.
Because Burleson has an extra year of club control, St. Louis would likely try to squeeze a third piece out of any deal as well. That could mean a lower-level prospect with some upside, such as utility player Chris Suero or right-hander Will Watson, both still a few years away.
It’s a steep ask for a player whose previous bests were 21 homers and 78 RBI in 2024. If Stearns believes the breakout is for real, he might still pay that kind of freight. If not, the Mets may end up circling back to other trade or free-agent options to solve first base.
In Other News...
Mets Linked To An Outfield Bat Who Could Spark A Bidding War
The winter market for Japanese outfielder Teruaki Sato is already shaping up to be one of the more intriguing pursuits on the board, and the Mets are right in the middle of it. Philadelphia is reportedly interested in adding Sato to help its outfield, but USA Todays Bob Nightengale says the Mets, Yankees and Padres are also viewing him as a top free-agent target after a season that featured 39 home runs and a .306 batting average.
For the Mets, the appeal is obvious. They have been linked to a bat with real impact potential, and Satos combination of power and production would make him a sought-after fit for a lineup looking for more thump. With multiple big-market teams involved, this is the kind of chase that can turn into a bidding war quickly, and the Mets figure to have company every step of the way. [Read more 🡒]
Mets First Base Search Just Took An Interesting Turn
The Mets search for help at first base is already taking shape, and Ty France has emerged as one of the names worth watching. New York is looking to strengthen the position this offseason, and France fits the kind of practical, middle-of-the-order depth the club has been weighing as it sorts through both free-agent and trade possibilities.
France is coming off a strong 2023 season with the Padres, which helps explain why he is in the mix alongside Alec Bohm as a potential target. The Mets are still in evaluation mode, but the fact that they are considering more than one route at first base suggests this could become one of the more interesting roster decisions of the winter. [Read more 🡒]
Mets First Base Plan Just Got More Complicated Fast
Jake Bauers is off the board, and the Red Sox did not waste much time making a major commitment to one of the top first-base options in the market. After a strong 2026 season with the Brewers, Bauers had been viewed as one of the most appealing names available at the position, which made him a logical fit for teams looking to stabilize the infield and add some left-handed thump.
For the Mets, the timing matters. Their first-base picture was already going to require some sorting out, and losing a player of Bauers caliber only narrows the pool of realistic possibilities. Ty France and Alec Bohm remain among the names to watch, but with one prominent target gone, the front office has a little less room to be selective and a little more pressure to find the right answer. [Read more 🡒]