The Mets got Thursday night moving at the trade deadline, sending A.J. Minter to the Minnesota Twins and bringing back two prospects in Billy Amick and Bruin Agbayani.
For a front office that has a habit of making its moves at strange hours, this one at least gave the deadline a pulse. The return lands the Mets a pair of ranked Twins prospects, and that alone makes the deal feel like more than a throwaway swap.
The headline piece is Amick. He’s hitting .217/.338/.482 at Double-A this season, but the number that jumps off the page is the power: 23 home runs.
The Mets are adding a bat that could fit the mold of another Mark Vientos, with a future that likely takes him off third base and over to first. That kind of pop matters in a farm system that doesn’t have a lot of it, even if the strikeouts remain a major part of the profile.
Amick has struck out at a 34% clip per at-bat this year, with 18 in 313, though he does draw walks often enough to help offset some of the swing-and-miss.
Agbayani is the more intriguing name for a different reason. He’s the featured player here because of the family connection to former Mets outfielder Benny Agbayani, and he already has a bit of built-in recognition for that alone.
On the field, he’s a shortstop and third baseman, but there isn’t much to evaluate yet. Injuries have limited him to just 15 professional games, with five last season and 10 more in 2026.
He’s only 19, so the Mets have time to see what he becomes.
That’s why the deal settles in as a B-. Relievers on expiring contracts usually don’t bring back a haul that changes the shape of a system, and this one doesn’t quite rise to the level of a home run.
But it also isn’t the kind of move that leaves you scratching your head. If anything, it looks like a reasonable first sign of what David Stearns may be able to pull off as the deadline unfolds.
Brooks Raley could bring back something similar, with the final return depending on how much his smaller salary factors in.
It’s not a franchise-altering swing. It’s not a misfire either. For the Mets, it’s a solid start.
In Other News...
Mets Have One Clear Prospect Priority In Freddy Peralta Talks
If the Mets are going to seriously engage in Freddy Peralta talks, the return is going to matter as much as the arm they might be chasing. The latest look at the market points to a wide field of possible trade partners, with the Rays, White Sox, Cubs, Padres, Diamondbacks, Brewers, Rangers and Phillies all mentioned as clubs that could get involved if the conversation really heats up.
What makes the picture interesting for New York is that this is not just about getting a big league-ready piece back. The Mets are being linked to a range of prospect names across those systems, which suggests the front office would have some flexibility in how it builds a package. The real question is whether the club can line up the kind of return it wants without having to overpay in the sort of talent it would prefer to keep close. [Read more 🡒]
Mets First Base Plan Is Already Becoming A Serious Problem
Jorge Polancos first season with the Mets has turned into a frustrating watch, and the timing could hardly be worse for a club already shifting into seller mode ahead of the trade deadline. Polanco has struggled to get anything going at the plate, and since coming back from a three-month injury absence, the production has been even thinner, leaving the Mets with a first-base situation that looks far less settled than they hoped.
Interim manager Andy Green is still publicly backing Polanco, pointing to the hitters track record and insisting the breakthrough is coming. But with the deadline approaching and Polancos contract making a move unlikely, the Mets may have to live with the current setup for a while longer, even as Jared Youngs recent work against right-handed pitching gives the front office another name to consider and Mark Vientos remains sidelined with a broken hand. [Read more 🡒]
Dodgers Are Already Circling A Mets Arm Before The Deadline
The Dodgers are still hunting for help in the rotation as the deadline approaches, and their need has only grown with a pair of familiar arms working back from injuries. Blake Snell and Tyler Glasnow both add to the uncertainty around that staff, which is why Los Angeles has been casting a wide net while looking for ways to stabilize the group for the stretch run.
For the Mets, the wrinkle is less about what happens in Los Angeles than about who is drawing that kind of attention. Clay Holmes has been on the radar as part of that search, and he was scouted in his last minor league rehab start after missing time since May with a fractured right fibula. Whether the Dodgers ultimately land a bigger name or keep circling back to Holmes, it is another reminder that the market for pitching can shift quickly, and New Yorks arms are already part of the conversation. [Read more 🡒]