The Mets’ offseason may end up being defined by one swing at the very top of the pitching market: Tarik Skubal.
New York is still sorting through the aftermath of a lost season, but the bigger question sitting ahead of 2027 is clear enough. How does this rotation get built, and who takes the ball at the front of it?
David Stearns already chose not to force Nolan McLean into an ace role in his first full season. Instead, he brought in Freddy Peralta from Milwaukee, only for that move to collapse and send Peralta to Tampa Bay at the trade deadline. That left McLean to finish the year as the staff’s No. 1 arm, and he has handled it well enough to give the Mets a real choice going forward.
They can keep McLean in that spot and look for a co-ace, or they can go after a bigger name and change the shape of the staff entirely. Skubal is the rare option who could do that with money alone.
The reigning two-time AL Cy Young winner is with the Los Angeles Dodgers now after being dealt there at the deadline, which matters because Los Angeles cannot attach a qualifying offer to him. If the Mets want him, the price would be purely financial: the contract itself, plus the luxury tax hit that comes with it.
There are obvious concerns. Skubal turns 30 in November, and he missed time this season after having his elbow scoped in May.
He is also represented by Scott Boras, which almost certainly means a massive ask. The benchmark is Yoshinobu Yamamoto’s 12-year, $325 million deal, currently the biggest free-agent pitching contract in history.
Yamamoto’s deal averages a little more than $27 million per season and includes an opt-out after year five. Skubal brought a better résumé to market than Yamamoto did, but Yamamoto was 25 when he signed, giving his team more of his prime years. Skubal is older, and that changes the math.
Still, there are signs this could move faster than a typical Boras free agency. There have been rumblings that Boras may want to get Skubal signed before a possible work stoppage, and that could help the Mets.
There are also rumors about how a government investigation into Dodgers owner Mark Walter’s finances might affect Los Angeles’ interest in keeping Skubal. That could leave the door open for New York.
The Mets’ payroll situation gives them a path to make a run at him. They do not have many long-term commitments, with only Francisco Lindor and Juan Soto under contract beyond the 2028 season. Most of the guaranteed money comes off after next season, when Sean Manaea, Kodai Senga and Jorge Polanco’s combined $57 million disappears from the books.
Another $42 million could come off after 2027 if Bo Bichette opts out of the final year of his deal. Marcus Semien, Devin Williams and Luis Torrens each have just one guaranteed year left for 2028. That creates a route for the Mets to add Skubal and still get under the luxury tax line by 2028, which would reset their tax rate before future spending sprees.
The biggest question is whether Stearns is willing to move away from his usual discomfort with long deals for older pitchers. He offered Yamamoto the same contract structure the Dodgers did, including the opt-out after five seasons. That gives some hint at how he thinks about the tradeoff between years and flexibility.
For Skubal, the Mets could try to push the average annual value as high as possible while keeping the term shorter. A five-year offer in the neighborhood of $45 million per season would top the $43.3 million annual average Max Scherzer and Justin Verlander received on their two-year Mets deals. It would also let Boras claim Skubal as the highest-paid pitcher on an annual basis, while giving New York the rest of his prime.
Even a six-year version of that deal would run only through Skubal’s age-35 season, and the Mets would have room to absorb it with so much money coming off the payroll and a wave of cheaper young players filling out the roster.
That is the argument for going big. The Mets have already spent heavily on the middle of the market, handing out shorter deals to pitchers like Frankie Montas, Manaea and Clay Holmes. Holmes was the only one of those contracts that really paid off, which makes a different approach look reasonable.
Landing Skubal would also change the rest of the rotation picture. McLean would slide into the No. 2 role, and the Mets could add another starter to slot in behind him before Christian Scott. That kind of group would put them in the conversation with the Philadelphia Phillies for the best rotation in the NL East, while also letting Zac Thornton and Jonah Tong serve as depth instead of being pushed into major roles.
There would be a public-relations boost, too. Signing the best pitcher on the market would land differently after an offseason in which Stearns drew plenty of heat for letting several fan favorites leave.
The case is pretty straightforward: the upside outweighs the risk. The Mets should be aggressive when Skubal reaches free agency this winter.
In Other News...
Mets Bullpen Overhaul May Come Down To One Coveted Free Agent
After moving Luke Weaver to the Pittsburgh Pirates at the trade deadline, the Mets are heading into the offseason with bullpen help near the top of the shopping list. The need is clear enough even before free agency gets rolling, and it has already put San Diego left-hander Adrian Morejon on the radar as a name worth watching for New York.
Mike Axisa of CBS Sports linked the Mets to Morejon, who has become one of the more intriguing relief arms available. At 27, he brings recent success and the kind of versatility clubs value, with the possibility of helping either out of the bullpen or, if needed, in a starting role, which only adds to the appeal for a team trying to reshape its pitching depth. [Read more 🡒]
Which Mets Prospect Looks Closest To Helping The Roster Next
The Mets have spent this season leaning on rookies in a way that has kept plenty of attention on the big league club, even as the standings have not given fans much to celebrate. That has only sharpened the eye on the next wave, and three prospects in particular have started to stand out as names worth tracking: Emilien Pitre, Mitch Voit and Gabe Davis.
Each has a different case, but all three bring the kind of minor league production and positional flexibility that can move a player quickly into the conversation. The question now is which one is most likely to follow the path of the current rookies and put himself in position to help the Mets by 2027, a race that will be shaped as much by development and roster fit as by raw talent. [Read more 🡒]
Nolan McLeans Late Surge Could Mean More For Mets Than One Award
Sal Stewart has drawn most of the Rookie of the Year attention in the National League, but Nolan McLean has made himself part of the conversation with the kind of late-season pitching stretch that can change how an award race looks in a hurry. For the Mets, it is more than a nice individual subplot. McLeans recent run has given them a homegrown arm worth watching at a time when young pitching remains one of the most valuable things a team can uncover.
There is also a practical angle beyond the trophy chase, since McLeans place in the vote could affect where the Mets land in the draft order. That makes his final weeks more meaningful than a typical September audition, especially with the award picture still fluid and the betting market treating the race as very much alive. For a club that has spent plenty of time thinking about the future, McLeans surge now carries a little extra weight. [Read more 🡒]