Zac Thornton’s rookie year gave the Mets something they badly needed: a young starter who could take the ball and deliver real innings. It also put New York in a tricky spot. A pitcher who arrived as an overlooked prospect and turned into one of the team’s most interesting arms is exactly the kind of player other clubs would ask about in trade talks.
That’s the tension facing the Mets as they look toward 2027. With the free-agent market described as thin beyond Tarik Skubal, David Stearns and the front office may have to get creative.
That could mean shopping from the roster instead of shopping only outside it. Thornton, coming off an eye-opening first season, looks like the sort of name that would draw attention.
The numbers explain why. After a rough major league debut in May, when he gave up four runs in 4.1 innings against the Washington Nationals and was sent back to the minors, Thornton returned in late July and settled in fast. Over 15 starts, the 24-year-old left-hander posted a 3.42 ERA in 84.1 innings with 68 strikeouts, a 1.14 WHIP, and a 4.51 FIP.
He did it without overpowering hitters in the usual way. Thornton averaged 92.3 mph on his four-seam fastball, which is not exactly the profile teams usually dream on for a young starter.
But he made the approach work with command and a knack for soft contact. His 5.3% walk rate ranked in the 95th percentile per Baseball Savant.
That control helped him go deeper into games, including eight outings of at least six innings. It also showed up in some of the Mets’ biggest moments, none bigger than his seven innings of two-run ball against the New York Yankees in September.
Even with all that, the warning signs are real. Thornton’s 3.42 ERA came with a 4.52 xERA, a gap that points to results that were better than the underlying numbers suggested. His 17.8% whiff rate also ranked among the lowest in baseball, which means his margin for error could shrink quickly if his location slips.
The pitch data tells a similar story. His fastballs were effective, combining for a run value of +7, but his breaking and offspeed pitches combined for a -6 run value.
So yes, the trade appeal is obvious. A 24-year-old lefty with team control and a strong rookie season is the kind of asset plenty of teams would love to get their hands on. But the Mets have reasons to stay put.
For one, they need starting pitching help themselves. Moving Thornton would mean creating another opening in a rotation that already needs work. Stearns said at his end-of-season press conference that he wants 10-12 starting pitchers between the majors and minors heading into 2027, and dealing Thornton would make that harder to achieve.
The Mets do have other young arms, but there’s no guarantee how many of them will become dependable major league starters. Outside of Nolan McLean, every other young pitcher still has to prove he can be counted on long term.
There’s also the possibility that Thornton’s best days are still ahead. He’s 24, and he said after his final start that he believes he can add velocity next season, with a goal of sitting between 94 and 96 mph. Andy Green backed that up, saying Thornton needs to add weight and muscle to his 185-pound frame to help his velocity and keep developing his secondary pitches.
That’s the bet the Mets have to weigh. Thornton’s value may never be higher, and that makes him tempting trade bait. But his upside, his age, and the rotation need in front of New York all point the same way: keep him, and see what comes next.
In Other News...
Edwin Diaz Is Making The Mets Regret This Decision
Edwin Diaz has already started to make the Mets think twice about how they handled his departure. After a rough regular season with the Dodgers, the right-hander found his form again once he returned from the injured list in September, and by the time the postseason arrived he looked much more like the pitcher New York remembers than the one who struggled early on in Los Angeles.
The timing only sharpens the sting for the Mets, who moved on and turned to Devin Williams instead. Diazs strong finish in the NLDS against Atlanta only adds to the sense that he was settling in when it mattered most, and it leaves New York with an uncomfortable reminder of what it gave up. [Read more 🡒]
Mets Should Think Twice Before Copying The Braves On Young Extensions
Around baseball, early extensions for promising young players have become almost routine, especially for teams that want to buy cost certainty before a prospects price rises. The Braves have been the poster team for that approach, moving quickly on players like Ronald Acua Jr., Ozzie Albies, Spencer Strider and Austin Riley, and turning those deals into a central part of their roster-building identity. It is easy to see why clubs covet the model: if the player develops, the team controls a core piece at a manageable rate for years.
For the Mets, though, the lesson is not to treat that blueprint as automatic. The club has its own young talent to think about in Carson Benge, Nolan McLean and A.J. Ewing, but extensions handed out this early can carry real downside when health or performance changes the trajectory of a career. Atlantas experience shows the rewards are obvious when the gamble works, yet the risk can linger long after the agreement is signed, which is why New York has reason to be cautious before rushing to copy a division rivals playbook. [Read more 🡒]
Mets Got An Early Reminder How Raw Their Newest Prospects Are
The Arizona Fall League has already given Mets watchers a small reminder that prospect development does not always move in a straight line. Cole Mathis and Bruin Agbayani have gotten off to slow starts in the desert, combining for just two hits in 24 at-bats, though Mathis has at least shown some plate discipline after missing much of the regular season because of injury and Agbayani is still working with a very small professional resume.
There is still plenty of reason for the Mets to keep paying attention beyond the early line scores. Boston Baro and Irving Cota are also in the mix, and Cota has drawn notice for a promising start on the pitching side, which gives the organization a broader look at how this group is handling a tougher level of competition. For Mathis and Agbayani, though, the early AFL stretch is less about production and more about how quickly raw talent can start to look like something sturdier. [Read more 🡒]