The Mets are staring at a familiar kind of roster squeeze this week, and the Rule 5 Draft is the reason why. Teams have to make their 40-man calls on Tuesday, even if the league could be heading into a lockout by the time December rolls around and nobody can say for sure whether the draft will even happen. Still, clubs have to plan as if it will, and for the Mets that means sorting through a handful of prospects with very different levels of urgency.
Jefferson Rojas is the easy one. He’s the top prospect in the system, and there’s no real debate about whether he belongs on the protected list. If the Mets are making a clean decision anywhere, it’s here.
After that, things get murkier.
Chris Suero has the kind of profile that could tempt another club. He can catch, but he also offers some flexibility, with the ability to handle first base and the outfield.
That sort of versatility can make a player attractive as a third catcher or a bench stash. Even so, his .201 batting average in Double-A last season makes it hard to see the Mets using a 40-man spot on him.
Jack Wenninger is another name to watch. He has slipped a bit, but he still looks like a player who could draw interest in the Rule 5 Draft.
The comparison to Mike Vasil matters here, since Vasil wasn’t able to survive the 2024 Rule 5 Draft. Wenninger feels like the next most likely Met to be protected after Rojas.
Gary Gill Hill is a tougher call. The Mets acquired him in the Freddy Peralta trade, but that alone shouldn’t force their hand.
What makes him worth debating is the talent. The concern is the lack of experience beyond Double-A, which makes him look like the type of player another team might take and then potentially send back.
He’s the kind of prospect who could go either way.
The rest of the group doesn’t look like it belongs on the 40-man.
Ryan Clifford struggled badly in Triple-A this year, and protecting him would only complicate things. He doesn’t look like a likely Rule 5 pick, and if another team took him and got something out of him, that would be their win.
Randy Guzman is still too far away from the majors to justify a roster spot. As promising as his career has been, protecting him would burn through a minor league option too quickly.
Jacob Reimer remains one of those power bats who hasn’t quite put everything together. He’s Rule 5 eligible this winter, but he’d have to beat the odds to stick on a big league roster. At this point, he looks more like a trade candidate, and the Mets should be trying to move him now.
Zach Franklin, acquired in the Huascar Brazoban trade, is a decent enough pitching prospect, but the Mets not protecting him would also make that deal look even more questionable. They didn’t give him a big league look late in 2026 even though they knew this decision was coming. That suggests they’re willing to take the risk, and they probably should.
Anyone not named here fits into the same bucket: not important enough right now to claim a 40-man spot.
The Mets do have other Rule 5-eligible prospects, with pitching the most likely area for another team to target. And while they could at least consider selecting someone themselves, the way this roster has been handled makes it hard to believe any addition would actually stick.
In Other News...
Mets Face One Team That Could Ruin Their Tarik Skubal Push
Tarik Skubal is shaping up to be one of the biggest names on the market before the current collective bargaining agreement expires on Dec. 1, and the Mets have already surfaced as one of the teams with a real chance to land him. For a club that has not been shy about chasing top-end talent, that puts them in the middle of a bidding picture that also includes the Dodgers, Padres and Blue Jays, each weighing its own payroll realities and roster priorities as the clock keeps moving.
The wrinkle for the Mets is that this is not just about money, even if money will matter plenty. Skubals camp is expected to have preferences that could influence where he lands, and the teams in the mix are coming at the pursuit from very different angles, with some better positioned than others to make a clean fit. No deal has been announced yet, which leaves New York waiting to see whether its early standing in the race is enough to survive the final stretch. [Read more 🡒]
Mets First Base Search May Hinge On One Contract Line Stearns Hates
Ty Frances career year has put him squarely in the conversation as the Mets sort through first-base options, and the fit is easy to see on paper. He is coming off the kind of season that tends to change how teams view a player in free agency, which is why his name has started to surface alongside other possible targets as New York weighs how to address the position.
The bigger question may not be Frances ability so much as the shape of the deal, because the Mets have shown a clear preference for certain contract structures and that can matter just as much as the player himself. Alec Bohm and Paul Goldschmidt are part of the same broader discussion, but the market for first basemen has been shifting, and one contract term could end up making France more or less appealing to David Stearns and the front office. [Read more 🡒]
Yankees Could Get An Early Warning From This Ex-Bullpen Arms Market
The Blue Jays rough 2026 season left them staring at a familiar winter priority list, with injuries hammering the starting rotation and the bullpen likely to get its share of attention, too. Toronto is expected to be aggressive in the offseason as it looks for upgrades on both fronts, and one name already drawing notice is free agent reliever Jonathan Loaisiga, a pitcher whose market appears to be forming quickly.
Loaisigas appeal is easy to see for a club trying to patch together depth and swing-and-miss relief help, but Toronto is not alone in the chase. With multiple teams also in the mix, the early interest around the right-hander could become one of the first signs of how competitive the bullpen market may be, and for the Yankees, it offers a useful read on how much demand there may be for familiar arms from around the division. [Read more 🡒]
