The Mets are heading into the stretch run with one of their offseason bets looking more and more like a problem they’ll have to untangle next year.
Jorge Polanco was supposed to help hold down first base while also chipping in enough offense to soften the loss of Pete Alonso’s production in aggregate with Mark Vientos. Instead, the move has been wrecked by injury, and the Mets still don’t have a clean answer for what Polanco should be going forward.
The trouble started early. David Stearns did not seem to place much value on Polanco’s injury history before the season, and that decision came back fast when Polanco strained his Achilles tendon in early April.
The injury pushed him into a designated hitter-only role and left a hole at first base. Things only got uglier when he tried to keep playing through it, a move that cost him power and speed.
By the time the Mets finally shut him down and put him on the injured list in mid-April, the damage had already piled up. It took months for Polanco to return because the Achilles kept bothering him.
When he finally came back in mid-July, the offense never followed. Since then, he has just seven hits in 68 at-bats, a .102 average, with one home run, three RBIs and 22 strikeouts.
Polanco’s situation is part of a larger offseason miss for Stearns, who also counted on Marcus Semien and Polanco to be lineup anchors in the effort to replace Jeff McNeil and Alonso. Polanco’s case is especially frustrating because the Achilles issue appears to have been aggravated by the Mets letting him play through it for a few weeks. Those injuries, as the situation has shown, can linger for a long time.
Now the Mets have to decide what comes next, and the financial piece makes it harder. Polanco is owed another $20 million next season, and Stearns is unlikely to want to move on after only one year. But bringing him back as the everyday first baseman again would be asking for the same trouble all over again.
A better path may be to use Polanco more like a utility option. He has experience as a middle infielder, so he could potentially bounce around the other infield spots while also handling designated hitter duty. That would only make sense, though, if he arrives at spring training fully healthy - whenever that begins next year, after a possible lockout.
At this point, the Mets may even want to consider shutting Polanco down and focusing entirely on treating the Achilles problem that has followed him all season. Keeping him in the lineup every few days during a lost season isn’t helping much of anyone. If the goal is to salvage value for 2027, the clearest route might be to get him healthy enough to serve as the primary DH.
That role would likely keep him healthier and leave room for occasional work in the field. For the Mets, that may be the only realistic way to get something useful out of Polanco next season. Right now, the current setup clearly isn’t working, and the team may be nearing the point where it has to admit defeat on this season.
In Other News...
Mets Prospect Rankings Just Raised A Bigger Question About The Farm
MLB Pipelines latest update to the Mets top prospect list reflects how much the farm has shifted after recent trades and draft picks, and it gives a clearer picture of where the organization stands right now. One of the more notable changes is the rise of Cole Mathis, while Emilien Pitre has emerged as a player who could fit the utility role the club always seems to value. The update also underscores a lingering concern for the system: catching remains an area where the Mets still do not have an obvious answer waiting in the wings.
The trade that sent Huascar Brazoban elsewhere is part of that broader conversation, because the return brought back Zach Franklin and Gabe Davis and added more depth to a system that is still trying to strengthen its middle tiers. Even so, the rankings suggest the Mets are left with a familiar question about quality at the top versus volume throughout the rest of the farm. For a team that keeps looking for the next wave, the bigger issue may be whether the organization has enough impact talent developing fast enough to matter. [Read more 🡒]
Mets May Have Found A Corner Infield Answer They Need To Win
The Mets have spent plenty of time this season trying to piece together their corner-infield picture, and an offseason name has already surfaced that fits the kind of search they may need to keep doing. Teruaki Sato, the 2025 NPB Central League MVP, has been turning heads in Japan with strong offensive production, and his profile makes sense for a club looking for help at either first or third base.
Sato is the sort of player who can draw a wide market quickly, especially when a team is hunting for a bat that might stabilize a position for the long term. For the Mets, the appeal is obvious: a productive infielder with a track record that suggests he could translate into a meaningful upgrade, even if the competition for him is expected to be crowded. [Read more 🡒]