The Mets are staring at a first-base problem that can’t be ignored this winter.
After entering 2026 without Pete Alonso for the first time, New York got a harsh reminder of how much production can disappear at one position. Mets first basemen ranked fifth-worst in MLB with a .690 OPS, and David Stearns didn’t dance around it in his end-of-season press conference. The message was clear: an upgrade is needed.
The free-agent board doesn’t offer much comfort. Ty France, Jake Bauers, Alec Bohm, and Paul Goldschmidt are among the names out there, but the market may point the Mets toward trades instead. If that’s the route, there are a handful of options worth circling.
Yandy Diaz fits the “steady production” category as well as anyone. He’s spent the last five seasons putting together consistently strong offensive numbers, including an OPS of at least .750 in each of those years and three seasons with 20 or more homers. The 35-year-old didn’t slow down in 2026, either, hitting .293/.359/.446 with 22 home runs and a 125 wRC+.
Diaz is entering the final year of his contract with the Tampa Bay Rays after his vesting option was exercised, and he’s set to make $13 million in 2027. That kind of short-term commitment makes him appealing for a contender that wants real offense without a long runway attached.
The catch is defense. Diaz has never been known for his glove, and he spent all of 2026 at designated hitter.
Moving him back to first base every day would bring some risk, especially for a Mets club that has emphasized run prevention. Even so, his bat is exactly the kind of bat that can make teams overlook the glove.
Christian Walker brings a different profile: more defense, plenty of power, and a more balanced fit. He hasn’t been the same hitter he was in his Arizona days, but his pop has held up since joining the Houston Astros two years ago. In 156 games last season, he hit .226/.299/.427 with 29 home runs, 87 RBIs, and a 103 wRC+.
He also remained strong at first base, finishing at +3 OAA. Walker is owed $20 million in 2027, and that salary could push Houston toward a move as it looks for more financial flexibility. For New York, he would bring a dependable everyday option with power, defense, veteran experience, and postseason background.
Spencer Torkelson is the swing-for-the-fences option. The former first overall pick has never stopped flashing big-time power, but the rest of the package has been more uneven. In 2026, he hit .230/.331/.435 with 26 homers, 77 RBIs, and a 115 wRC+, yet the swing-and-miss issues were obvious: a 32.4% whiff rate and 194 strikeouts.
His defense was even tougher to ignore. Torkelson finished at -12 Outs Above Average, which placed him in the first percentile across MLB, according to Baseball Savant.
Still, he’s only 27 and entering what should be the prime of his career. He also has two years of team control left with the Detroit Tigers, though a roster crunch could make him available if the club wants to open a path for its next wave of prospects.
Jake Burger offers another power-heavy possibility, and maybe the cleanest pairing with Jared Young. The 30-year-old has hit at least 20 home runs in three of his four full major league seasons, and his bat speed stands out. In 2026, he went .228/.302/.421 with 28 home runs, 90 RBIs, and a 104 wRC+.
Burger’s issue is consistency, not pop. He can run hot and cold, but the power threat is real, and the Texas Rangers are reportedly considering whether his name fits their push toward a younger, more versatile roster. He has two years of control left, which could make him attractive to the Mets if they want flexibility at first base and a matchup-based platoon option.
Royce Lewis is the wild card. A couple of years ago, the idea of the Minnesota Twins moving him would have sounded unthinkable, but his stock has taken a hit after another rough season. In 2026, Lewis hit .227 with 15 home runs and a .667 OPS, and injuries limited him to 125 games.
There’s still plenty of intrigue because he’s just 27 and once looked like a future star. He also spent most of his career at third base before getting regular time at first in 2026. The adjustment came with some growing pains, though he held his own defensively with a -3 OAA across 684 innings.
Lewis would be more of a secondary play than the Mets’ clear-cut answer at first base, but that’s also what makes him interesting. If the talent eventually clicks the way many once expected, he could end up looking like a bargain.
In Other News...
Mets Could Keep Winning From The Brooks Raley Trade
Brooks Raley gave the Mets a useful left-handed arm out of the bullpen before the club moved him to Philadelphia, and his results since the deal have only sharpened the contrast. New York turned that reliever swap into a pair of prospects, John Spikerman and Luke Gabrysh, and the early read is that the return could end up mattering more than a simple midseason bullpen upgrade ever would.
Gabrysh, in particular, has already drawn attention for strong pitching metrics, which gives the Mets something tangible to track as the trade ages. Even with Raley's decline after leaving New York, the bigger question for the Mets is whether the value they picked up will keep growing into something more than a useful piece of deadline business. [Read more 🡒]
Mets May Have To Cash In Prospects To Fix Costly Holes
The Mets entered the winter with a familiar kind of roster math to solve, one made trickier by the contracts already on the books and the possibility that baseballs financial system could look different soon. After being viewed as sellers at the deadline, the tone is now more cautious and more targeted, with the front office weighing whether the quickest path to fixing the biggest holes is to deal from a farm system that has real value but also real vulnerability.
Among the names that could come into play are Jacob Reimer, Sammy Stafura and Jack Wenninger, and the key detail is that none of them are being treated as untouchable. Each has a different track record and a different fit on the field, which gives the Mets room to be selective if they decide to chase immediate help. The harder part is knowing how far they want to go in giving up prospect capital when the roster still needs both answers and flexibility. [Read more 🡒]
Mets May Need To Act Fast On A Breakout Building Block
Carson Benge has given the Mets plenty to think about as they look ahead to the next phase of building around a young core. After a strong rookie season, the question is no longer whether he belongs in the mix, but how quickly the organization should move if it wants to keep him in Queens for the long haul. The idea of striking early on an extension has real appeal, especially for a club that could use more certainty around its emerging talent.
The Braves have made a habit of locking up young players before their prices climb, and the Mets have every reason to study that model closely. Benge is part of a broader wave of youth the team hopes can add speed and energy, with stolen bases still a need and prospects Jefferson Rojas and Nick Morabito potentially part of that answer. The challenge now is deciding whether to act before Benges breakout season turns into something even more expensive to buy into. [Read more 🡒]