Mets Face A Costly Ace Decision They May Not Avoid

As the Mets navigate the tumultuous waters of free agency, the team's pursuit of Tarik Skubal tests their balancing act between financial caution and the urgent need for a dependable ace.

The Mets are staring at a familiar winter dilemma, and Tarik Skubal sits right in the middle of it.

The two-time Cy Young winner is already drawing interest from the Mets, the Dodgers and the Blue Jays, with reports also linking him to the Padres this week. That fits the mood around the league right now. The General Manager Meetings in Las Vegas earlier this month made one thing clear: this offseason is moving fast, and the looming lockout is pushing everyone toward the finish line sooner than usual.

That urgency matters here. In a normal market, a player like Skubal would have time to let the bidding breathe. This time, he and agent Scott Boras have a strong reason to move before the collective bargaining agreement expires, especially if the possibility of a salary cap hangs over the negotiations.

For the Mets, that creates a problem that is easy to see and hard to solve. Signing Skubal to the kind of long-term deal he is expected to command would almost certainly be a bad bet on paper.

Pitchers are fragile investments. Even when they stay healthy, those contracts tend to age badly.

Steve Cohen put that reality in blunt terms back in September.

“Free agency is a negative expected value,” Cohen said then. “It just is.

If you’ve got to constantly dip into free agency and you do it enough, that can come back to bite you…It would be my preference (to build a team via the farm system) but if you have to fill in holes, you’ve got to fill in holes, too. You’ve got to be tactical but every time you dip into free agency, you know that’s a tough place to be.”

And yet the Mets may not have much choice.

No one is going to hand Skubal $400 million because some spreadsheet says he is “worth” that number. He’ll get paid because that’s the market for an ace of his caliber. The Mets have spent the last couple of seasons boxing themselves into a corner, from the 2025 implosion to this past season’s $345 million humiliation ritual, while David Stearns has taken heat for aggressive moves that didn’t land and for steering clear of the kind of massive ace contract this roster has been missing.

That’s why Skubal is more than just another expensive target. He’s the sort of front-line starter the Mets have lacked since the Jacob deGrom era, the kind of arm that changes the feel of a rotation the moment he takes the ball. He would also ease the pressure on young pitchers like Nolan McLean and Christian Scott, instead of forcing McLean into an ace role before he’s ready and asking him to learn on the fly.

There’s also a more immediate reason the Mets might want to push here: the team finished 2026 looking a lot better than it did in the middle of the season. The youth movement brought some life back, Bo Bichette showed improvement, and the bullpen arms called up after the trade deadline fire sale gave the roster some promise. Manager Andy Green guided them back toward respectability.

That mattered. A season that had been defined by tearful TV interviews eventually gave way to something closer to acceptance and a desire to fix what could be fixed. The Mets would be wise not to waste that momentum or let next season slide any further into the abyss.

The Dodgers can sell Skubal on a midseason arrival. The Blue Jays can point to their 2025 World Series run.

The Padres, under new ownership, can make their own pitch. But the Mets have money, and they have reason to be aggressive.

It may not be the smartest financial move.

It still might be the one they have to make.

In Other News...

Mets Bullpen Addition Says Plenty About David Stearns Pitching Plan

The Mets added another arm to their bullpen mix, signing left-handed reliever Darwinzon Hernndez to a three-year, $12 million contract. It is the kind of move that fits neatly into the broader way David Stearns has approached pitching depth, with the front office continuing to look for options that can strengthen the staff without waiting around for the market to settle.

Around the league, the Rockies landed pitchers Luis Castillo and Davis Martin in a trade with the White Sox, while Nationals catching coach Bobby Wilson is headed to the Astros as their bench coach. Against that backdrop of roster churn and constant speculation, Hernndezs deal stands out as a reminder that the Mets are still shaping their pitching group with an eye on both present value and longer-term flexibility, even if the rest of the winter keeps producing more noise than answers. [Read more 🡒]

Mets May Have Found A New Pitching Fit They Actually Need

The Mets are taking a look at another intriguing arm as they continue to sort through their pitching options this winter. Free agent Kaima Taira is on their radar, and the club is planning a Zoom meeting with him after a strong season in Japan that showed the kind of versatility teams tend to value this time of year.

Tairas background gives the Mets something to think about because he has worked both as a starter and a closer, which opens the door to multiple roles if the fit is right. For now, it is still just part of the evaluation process, with no contract finalized, but it is the kind of pitcher profile that could help a staff looking for answers in both the rotation and the bullpen. [Read more 🡒]

Mets Tender Deadline Hints At More Bullpen Turnover Than Fans Expected

The Mets tender deadline brought a little more roster churn than some around the club may have expected, especially on the pitching side. New York moved on from Christopher Morel, Dylan Ross and Hayden Senger, while keeping a core of younger and more established pieces in place by tendering contracts to Francisco Alvarez, Brett Baty, Reed Garrett, Tylor Megill, Dedniel Nez and Mark Vientos.

There was also a flurry of bullpen-related movement around the edges of the roster, with the Mets agreeing to one-year deals with Cionel Prez and Austin Warren and claiming Yunior Tur off waivers from the Athletics. The shuffle did not stop there, either, as Chayce McDermott went to the Cubs on waivers, a reminder that this part of the winter can change a bullpen picture quickly even before the bigger moves arrive. [Read more 🡒]