The Mets have never been a team to ignore what the numbers are trying to say, and the expected stats on three pitchers from 2026 are loud enough to matter. Justin Hagenman, Tobias Myers and Devin Williams all finished with seasons that don’t line up neatly with the underlying data, and that mismatch could shape how the club thinks about them going into 2027.
Hagenman is the kind of pitcher whose surface line can fool you if you’re not looking deeper. In just 8 big league innings across 3 appearances, he posted a 3.38 ERA, but the expected numbers painted a much uglier picture.
He allowed 2 home runs in that short stretch and averaged only 4.5 K/9, which dragged the analytics way down. His expected slugging percentage sat at .560, far above the .452 opponents actually produced against him.
The story didn’t get much prettier in Triple-A, where he worked 14 innings, gave up 2 more homers and struck out only 8. He can get outs, but the contact he allows and the home run risk make him a tricky arm to trust, even if he can function as an innings-eater.
Myers is a different case, and maybe the more interesting one. He ended the year with a 5.53 ERA, but his expected ERA came in at 4.15, a gap big enough to make the Mets pause before deciding what to do with him.
He’s also a swingman type, and that matters because he won’t have any minor league options left in 2027. That gives the team less flexibility.
The numbers underneath his season were better than the final line suggested: hitters batted .268 against him, while his xBA was .259. They slugged .483, but his xSLG was .407.
He also ranked in the 86th percentile in barrels, which helped put some red on his Baseball Savant page. Whether that’s enough to keep him in the bullpen picture is the real question.
Williams is the one who will keep splitting opinion. His 4.43 ERA looked rough, but his 3.22 xERA says the season may have been more about bad fortune than bad pitching.
His xAVG of .218 points in the same direction, suggesting a much stronger performance than the results showed. He was basically the same pitcher he was with the New York Yankees the year before, just a little worse in some areas.
His walk rate climbed, his strikeout rate dropped, and yet his xSLG improved to .306 from .314 the previous season. His average exit velocity also dipped from 89.5mph to 87.7mph.
Add in a 4.5% barrel rate, which is below his 5.7% career mark, and there are clear signs that Williams could give the Mets a lot more next season than his ERA says.
In Other News...
Mets May Have A Clear Path To Freeing Up Payroll Fast
The Mets spent plenty of time this season trying to sort out a pitching mix that looks good on paper but can be difficult to carry in practice, especially when Sean Manaea and Kodai Senga are both in the picture. Each brings real value, but the roster math gets tighter when two high-salary starters are occupying important spots and the club is trying to keep enough flexibility to address other needs.
Jeff McNeils earlier move is a reminder that this front office is willing to make uncomfortable decisions if it believes the payoff is worth it. With Manaea and Senga, the question is whether the Mets might again look at a veteran with a meaningful contract as a path to freeing up payroll and opening roster space, even if the return and timing are not simple. [Read more 🡒]
Mets Got An Early Look At What Nick Morabito Might Become
Nick Morabitos rise through the Mets system finally reached the majors in 2026, giving the club an early glimpse of the kind of player it drafted back in 2022. In 19 games across two stints, he didnt do much with the bat, but the bigger picture was always about the traits that carried him through the minors: speed, defense and the ability to give a roster some range in the outfield.
For a team that can always use versatility at the back end of the roster, Morabitos profile still points to a possible future as a fourth outfielder and late-game pinch runner. His limited big league sample offered only a small taste, but it also reinforced why the Mets kept him on the radar for so long, and why his next step will be about turning those tools into something more consistent at the highest level. [Read more 🡒]
Mets Bullpen Plans Suddenly Center On A Risk Fans Know Too Well
The Mets are already thinking ahead to bullpen help, and Adrian Morejon has surfaced as one of the more interesting names in the mix. The left-handers strong recent work with the Padres makes him an appealing fit for a club that has spent plenty of time trying to stabilize the late innings, and any offseason pitching conversation in Queens figures to involve David Stearns and Steve Cohen weighing how aggressive they want to be.
But the bigger issue is less about Morejon himself than about the price tag attached to relievers in general. The Mets have lived through the downside of making a major commitment to the bullpen, and the front office has to decide whether it wants to chase another high-end arm or take a different route this winter. For a team that knows how quickly relief pitching can become a costly gamble, that choice looms over everything. [Read more 🡒]