David Peterson’s run in Chicago is doing more than giving the Mets a reason to smile. It may also be helping shape the return they can get for Freddy Peralta before next week’s MLB trade deadline.
Peterson already brought New York a legitimate prospect in Cole Mathis, and there could be another payoff coming. With August 4 looming, every player on an expiring contract and more is suddenly on notice that they may be packing for a new team soon.
There’s a growing belief that Peralta’s rough year may not be entirely on him. The idea is simple enough: maybe the Mets are the ones who have left him looking like a pitcher whose stock has fallen from budding Cy Young contender to someone whose rotation spot is now fair game for questions. Peterson’s success with the Cubs only gives that theory more oxygen.
His 5.57 ERA in Chicago doesn’t really capture the full picture. One ugly outing - 10 runs allowed in 3.2 innings - has done most of the damage. Outside of that, Peterson has been sharp: 5.2 innings with two runs allowed, five innings with one run allowed, and most recently 6.2 scoreless frames.
There hasn’t been much public insight into what the Mets are doing with their pitching staff, aside from the slap on the wrist they took earlier this year for trying to use A.I. for pitch selection. MLB shut that down before it could turn into a bigger issue, though the source material notes they weren’t the only team allegedly using technology with bent rules.
Peralta’s latest outing came Sunday against the Los Angeles Dodgers, when he worked four innings and was charged with two earned runs. Even so, his ERA dipped to 4.99 on the season - a number that might look fine on a Walmart shelf, but not nearly good enough for a trade deadline market.
That’s the bind for any team considering him: is this just a bad year, or is something deeper going on? Whoever trades for Peralta will be buying with caution.
The Mets do have to move him, unlike Clay Holmes, who would be a qualifying offer candidate. And with more than half the league expected to be buyers, plus the constant demand for starting pitching and Peralta’s relatively modest salary, there should be plenty of interest. In the end, it may take only one club believing the Mets are the reason he’s struggled.
In Other News...
Mets Under Fire After Loyal Season Ticket Holder Gets Pushed Aside
A longtime season ticket holder found himself displaced from his first-row right field spot at Citi Field as the Mets made room for a movie shoot during the series against the Dodgers. The production, for the upcoming baseball-romance film The Catch, brought extra Hollywood traffic to the ballpark and even had both teams in standard uniforms to keep the scenes looking right.
Emma Stone was seen in the dugout with Juan Soto during the filming, a reminder of how far the Mets were willing to go to accommodate the project. The move left a familiar seat occupied by someone else for the moment, and it added another layer to a week in which the ballpark felt as much like a set as a stadium. [Read more 🡒]
Mets Fans May Not Like Where Francisco Alvarez Trade Talk Is Going
The latest Francisco Alvarez chatter is the kind that makes Mets fans uneasy, because it starts with a simple baseball question and quickly turns into a bigger one about value. Alvarez has shown enough offense to keep his name in the conversation, but his defensive issues remain part of the equation, and recent trade talk has framed him as the sort of player who could draw a meaningful return if the Mets ever decided to listen.
Bostons deal for Curtis Mead from Washington, with Connelly Early going the other way, offers at least one benchmark for how clubs are valuing young talent right now, and it helps explain why Alvarez is being discussed in the first place. Seattle has been floated as one possible fit, and the Mets, if they ever went down this road, would be looking for a major leaguer back, likely on the mound or perhaps at third base, even as some around the game are already cooling the idea of an actual trade. [Read more 🡒]
Mets Free Agency Regret Looks Even Worse After Another Rival Win
Kazuma Okamotos first season after leaving Japan has become a useful reminder of how quickly a free-agent market can look upside down. The slugger landed a four-year, $60 million deal and has already given his new club the sort of middle-of-the-order production teams pay for, with power and run production carrying the profile even as the batting average and strikeout totals stay noisy.
For the Mets, the comparison is hard to ignore because the names ahead of Okamoto on their wish list have not delivered the way anyone expected. Kyle Tucker and Bo Bichette were the big swings, the kind of targets that can shape an entire winter, but both have underwhelmed relative to their reputations and price tags, leaving another rival success story to sharpen the sense that the safer, less glamorous path might have been the better one. [Read more 🡒]