Mets Could Be Drifting Back Toward A Familiar Rotation Gamble

Can David Stearns resist the temptation of a marquee signing, or will he stick to his tried-and-true strategy of cautious acquisitions as the New York Mets eye Tarik Skubal?

The Dodgers’ deadline splash for Tarik Skubal is already sending out ripples beyond Los Angeles, and one of the names that could end up circling back to the Mets is another left-hander with plenty of intrigue and plenty of risk: Kris Bubic.

Skubal’s long-term future is still unresolved with free agency looming in November, which is why the Mets are an obvious team to watch once he reaches the open market. A pitcher of that caliber would fit neatly atop a rotation ahead of Nolan McLean, and for Mets fans, that kind of addition would feel like a dream. But president of baseball operations David Stearns has not tended to chase the top of the market that way.

Instead, Stearns has usually leaned into a different kind of bet - the sort of move that looks a lot more like the Dodgers’ rental of Royals lefty Kris Bubic than a full-scale swing at an ace.

That’s been the pattern in Queens. Outside of the big push to bring in franchise centerpiece Juan Soto, the Mets have kept their spending cautious under Stearns.

Pete Alonso and Edwin Diaz were allowed to walk last winter, and when it comes to the rotation, the approach has been even more conservative. Stearns has repeatedly passed on the premier pitching names even when the need for a front-line arm was obvious.

There have been hits along the way. The 2024 club got strong results from Luis Severino and Sean Manaea at the top of a rotation that didn’t look like much on paper.

Clay Holmes was good enough to bring back a major prospect this summer. Even Griffin Canning, who gave the Mets a solid half-season last year before injuries ended his run, fit the formula well enough to count as a win.

But the misses are part of the story too. Frankie Montas is one the Mets would probably prefer to forget.

Re-signing Manaea after already finding success with him in 2024 proved to be a bad gamble. And the Freddy Peralta trade still leaves a sour taste.

That’s why Bubic feels like the kind of arm Stearns might actually target. On paper, the numbers are appealing: a 3.02 ERA and 3.14 FIP over 29 starts the last two seasons with the Royals. For a team shopping for rotation help, that profile would absolutely play.

The problem is the uncertainty attached to it. Bubic is still at least a month away from returning to the majors for the Dodgers while dealing with a shoulder injury.

He was limited to just 20 starts last season because of injury, and it’s fair to wonder whether he’ll even get back before the regular season ends this year. He has thrown only 50 1/3 innings so far in 2026, and that limited workload could weigh on his value once he reaches free agency.

That kind of situation is exactly the sort of thing Stearns tends to like. It wouldn’t be a shock if the Mets tried to sign Bubic as part of their 2027 rotation plan.

If it works, he could be another Holmes-style win. If it doesn’t, he could end up looking a lot more like Montas.

For a Mets team that needs help just to get back to October next year, that’s the kind of roll of the dice that can shape everything.

In Other News...

Mets Suddenly Have A Francisco Lindor Question Fans Cant Ignore

The trade deadline brought the Mets a wave of high-end farm talent, and the part that stands out most is how much of it lives on the infield. Several of the organizations newest prospects are shortstop-capable, giving the system a different kind of depth than it had a few weeks ago and adding a fresh layer to the way the front office can think about the roster beyond this season.

That kind of inventory naturally invites bigger questions, especially with Francisco Lindor still anchoring the position in Queens. The new group includes players viewed as close enough to matter in the not-too-distant future, which is why the conversation has already started to drift toward what the Mets might do if they ever decide to reshape the left side of the infield. For now, it is only speculation, but it is the sort of speculation that becomes harder to ignore once a team starts collecting shortstops this aggressively. [Read more 🡒]

Mets Prospects Suddenly Have A New Problem In The Farm System

The Mets farm system looks a little different after the organization brought in more talent, and the ripple effect is already showing up in prospect conversations. The names at the top are changing fast, with Jefferson Rojas now drawing attention as the systems most promising player while Jacob Reimer works to hold his place in that discussion. Even beyond that, Billy Amick and Aidan Smith are forcing a fresh look at where the depth really stands.

For a system that has spent plenty of time trying to sort out its true long-term hitters, this kind of movement matters. Amick is emerging as a more intriguing option than Ryan Clifford, and Smith is being measured against Nick Morabito as the Mets try to separate real upside from familiar names. The hard part for the front office is that the answers are arriving quickly, but not all at once, which leaves the ranking of this group very much in flux. [Read more 🡒]

Gabriel Arias Just Raised The Stakes For A Mets Infielder

The Mets added another layer to their infield picture by claiming Gabriel Arias off waivers from the Guardians, a move that speaks as much to roster planning as it does to the present-day bench. Arias brings defensive versatility, and with New York still sorting through injuries and other roster changes, he now gets a real chance to compete for a reserve infielder job.

For a club trying to balance short-term coverage with longer-term flexibility, this is the kind of claim that can quietly ripple through the rest of the roster. Arias arrival gives the Mets another option to evaluate, and it also hints that the final shape of the infield may not be settled anytime soon. [Read more 🡒]