The Mets spent the trade deadline thinning out their bullpen, and now the work shifts to rebuilding it. That’s the next puzzle for David Stearns, who admitted in his end-of-year press conference that he hasn’t done a good enough job putting the roster together. With several relievers headed for free agency this offseason, the Mets have a chance to patch one of their biggest problem areas before 2027.
One obvious path would be a reunion with A.J. Minter.
New York moved him in July after getting a strong half-season out of him and turning that into a solid return of two prospects from the Minnesota Twins. Minter only made 36 appearances across parts of two seasons with the Mets, largely because of injury and then the trade, but he was excellent when healthy.
He posted a 1.64 ERA in 13 games in 2025 and a 2.35 ERA in 23 games in 2026, then kept rolling with Minnesota with a 2.78 ERA in 25 appearances. At 33, he’s no longer young, but he’s been a dependable reliever for most of his career and would fill an obvious need as a left-hander.
He also already knows how to handle New York.
Another name that fits the Mets’ setup picture is Robert Suarez. He has spent the last few seasons in San Diego in the shadow of Mason Miller, but the production has been there all along.
Suarez is 35 and owns a 2.68 career ERA, including a 2.62 mark in 38 appearances in 2026. He has three full seasons with an ERA under 2.00, and the worst ERA he has posted in a season with at least 20 innings was 2.91 with the Blue Jays in 2019.
He isn’t a big strikeout guy, but he limits baserunners and home runs, and when he’s healthy, he’s a real weapon. He’s never been a closer, but he has the profile to handle that kind of role if needed.
With Devin Williams likely to be the Mets’ closer in 2027, Suarez would give them a dependable setup arm and a fallback option if Williams doesn’t lock things down.
Rafael Abreu brings a different kind of upside. The longtime Astro is finally reaching free agency after carving out a solid career since debuting in 2019.
He has never made an All-Star team, but outside of a rough 2021 season, he’s been effective at his worst and dominant at his best. His 2026 season was his weakest since that 2021 stretch, as he finished with a 3.73 ERA in 66 appearances and a WHIP well above 1.300 while battling command issues and issuing too many walks.
Still, Abreu has always been a wild arm, and the track record is hard to ignore. In four full seasons, 2022 and 2025, he posted a 2.30 ERA.
He’s only 29, which makes him a strong bounce-back candidate for 2027 if the Mets think they can clean up the control just enough.
Taylor Clarke is another reliever who made himself money with a strong 2026. He broke out with the Arizona Diamondbacks, putting up a 2.96 ERA in 71 games after carrying a 4.73 career ERA and spending most of his time as a low-leverage option before this season.
Clarke, 33, finished with an exact 1.000 WHIP and allowed just 1.7 walks per nine innings. His strikeout rate dipped to 5.5 per nine, well below his career norm, but the formula worked because he kept runners off base.
He didn’t record a save in 2026 and has only eight saves in more than 300 career appearances, which makes him a better fit for the Mets’ bullpen bridge than for the ninth inning. That’s fine.
The Mets don’t need a closer here; they need someone who can work the middle and late innings before handing things off to Williams.
Then there’s Tim Hill, a name that has hovered around the Mets for a while now. The funky lefty returned to the Yankees on a one-year deal last winter, and after a rough season, it’s less likely they bring him back.
Hill finished 2026 with a 4.60 ERA, but his recent track record suggests he can still be useful. He posted a 3.36 ERA in 2024 and a 3.09 ERA in 2025.
He’ll be 37 at the start of next year, so age matters, but his style should help him keep getting outs as he moves deeper into his career. Hill struck out just under four batters per nine innings this season while posting a 1.142 WHIP.
He does a solid job avoiding walks, though he can get into trouble when hitters start stringing together base hits. The Mets could take a look, but he shouldn’t be counted on for high-leverage innings if they do.
The bullpen needs help, and this market offers a few very different ways for the Mets to attack it. A reunion with Minter would give them a familiar lefty.
Suarez and Clarke would strengthen the late innings. Abreu would be the upside swing.
Hill would be the cheaper contact-based option. However they choose to go about it, the Mets have work to do.
In Other News...
Mets Trade Return Suddenly Looks A Lot Better After Cubs Exit
The Cubs quick exit from the Wild Card Series only sharpened the view from Queens. Chicago was swept by the Padres, and for the Mets, that result offers a fresh lens on the trade deadline deal that sent Clay Holmes and Tyrone Taylor to the North Side in exchange for prospect Jefferson Rojas. Holmes and Taylor were brought in to help a postseason push, but their impact was limited when it mattered most.
Rojas, meanwhile, is the piece New York can point to as it looks beyond this October. He is regarded as a promising young player who could fit into the Mets future roster, and Chicagos short stay in the playoffs makes the return feel even more relevant in hindsight. For a club still balancing present needs with long-term planning, that kind of upside is exactly what can make a deadline move age well. [Read more 🡒]
Nolan McLeans New Arsenal Creates A Real Mets Debate
Nolan McLeans pitching profile looks a lot different in 2026, and for the Mets that is creating a pretty interesting evaluation as they sort out what kind of starter he can become. After working with six pitches in 2025, McLean expanded to eight offerings this year, giving the club more to consider as it tries to decide which parts of his arsenal are real weapons and which ones are still works in progress.
The sinker has stayed steady and effective, but the rest of the mix has not been so simple. His four-seam fastball and cutter have both trended down, while a new slider has shown enough promise to make the old sweeper look less essential. For a Mets team trying to build around young pitching, the question now is whether McLeans added variety is sharpening his game or just making the choice of his best version harder to pin down. [Read more 🡒]
Mets May Be Running Out Of Time With Ronny Mauricio
Ronny Mauricios place with the Mets has quietly become one of the more interesting roster questions on the board. After appearing in 20 major league games in 2026 and showing some pop with four home runs, the young infielder still has not found the kind of regular role that would let the club properly evaluate him over time.
Because Mauricio has no minor league options left, the Mets may soon have to make a tougher call than simply sending him back down. A trade has started to look like the likeliest path, and the Seattle Mariners have come up as a possible fit with needs at both shortstop and third base, which could push this situation toward a resolution sooner rather than later. [Read more 🡒]