David Stearns and the Mets front office have plenty to sort through this offseason, but the bullpen may not need to be solved with a splashy move.
New York’s biggest jobs are clear enough: add multiple starting pitchers, find a first baseman, and build out bullpen depth. Since the rotation and first base are likely to demand the heavier financial lift, the Mets could be wiser to shop for relief help a different way - with smaller, under-the-radar signings. That’s a path Stearns has leaned on before.
As the free-agent market takes shape, these five relievers stand out as possible fits for the Mets.
John Curtiss Loaisiga is already well acquainted with New York, having spent eight seasons with the Yankees before signing with the Arizona Diamondbacks for 2026. The right-hander was once seen as a dominant late-inning weapon, but a torn UCL in 2024 interrupted that rise.
His return in 2025 wasn’t smooth at first, as he finished with a 4.25 ERA. Still, the move to Arizona seems to have brought his best work back.
In 67 innings with the Diamondbacks, Loaisiga posted a 2.42 ERA, struck out 48 batters, and logged a 1.03 WHIP. He also showed sharp command, with a 5% walk rate that ranked in the 96th percentile, per Baseball Savant.
His sinker averaged 97.9 mph and again looked like one of the best pitches in the sport, producing a +10 run value. The last time that pitch was this dangerous was 2021, when it carried a +11 run value.
That kind of profile makes him especially appealing for a Mets bullpen that doesn’t have many experienced high-leverage arms beyond Devin Williams. Loaisiga’s success in New York already gives him a leg up as a fit.
Sean Newcomb offers a different kind of appeal. Mets fans may remember him from his days with the Atlanta Braves, when he broke into the majors as a starter. That didn’t work out particularly well, and eventually he moved to the bullpen.
The transition took time, but at 33, Newcomb is beginning to look like a dependable reliever. He threw 90.1 innings for the Chicago White Sox this season and put up a 3.09 ERA, 84 strikeouts, and a 1.18 WHIP. He also leaned on his starting background, working multiple innings more than once.
That flexibility matters now more than ever, as teams ask less and less of their starters. Newcomb’s six-pitch mix and low arm angle also give him an unusual look that pitching staffs can play with in different game situations.
Then there’s Evan Phillips, whose path mirrors Loaisiga’s in some ways. He was dominant before Tommy John surgery in 2025, and his early return this season was rocky.
Through his first 17 appearances, he carried a 5.27 ERA. But he settled in as the year went on and looked much more like the reliever he had been.
Over his final 19 appearances, including the postseason, Phillips posted a 1.17 ERA and struck out 22. At 32, there’s reason to think that late-season surge can hold. He still brings a four-seam fastball averaging 96.9 mph and a wipeout sweeper, and his experience in big spots would give manager Andy Green another dependable option when games tighten up.
The Mets also need left-handed relief help, and the internal choices are thin: Nate Lavender, Cionel Perez, Jefry Yan, and Philip Abner. Brock Burke could help solve that issue. He is coming off a standout year with the Cincinnati Reds, where he threw 77.1 innings, recorded a 2.30 ERA, struck out 74, and finished with a 1.26 WHIP.
Burke was especially good at keeping the ball off barrels, as his 32.7% hard-hit rate ranked in the 89th percentile. He handled lefties well, holding them to a .195 average, and was nearly just as tough on right-handers, who hit .208 against him.
He also has the ability to work multiple innings, doing so in 13 of his 77 appearances. That kind of versatility only adds to his value for New York.
Mike Okert is another lefty worth a look, and another former division opponent, after three seasons with the Miami Marlins. Since joining the Houston Astros, he has completely reshaped his approach and found more success.
In 2026, Okert put together the best season of his nine-year career, posting a 2.13 ERA with 68 strikeouts and a 0.87 WHIP in 67.2 innings. The biggest change was his pitch usage. He leaned almost entirely on his slider, throwing it 67% of the time and pairing it with his four-seam fastball 28% of the time.
That kind of simplification reflects a broader trend, with pitchers increasingly leaning on their best weapons. In Okert’s case, the slider delivered a +11 run value in 2026. He was also effective against both sides of the plate, holding right-handed hitters to a .194 batting average and left-handed hitters to a .186 mark.
For the Mets, that could make him a relatively affordable addition who settles in quickly as a steady piece of the bullpen.
In Other News...
Mets First Base Search Is Coming Down To One Crucial Debate
The Mets offseason first-base search is starting to take shape, and the debate has become less about finding a name and more about deciding what kind of fit matters most. With the position underperforming in 2026, the club is weighing several options, including free agents Ty France and Jake Bauers, along with international bat Teruaki Sato, each bringing a different blend of offense, defense and long-term appeal.
France offers a steadier major league track record, Bauers brings a different power-leaning look, and Sato adds the intrigue that comes with an overseas target. For a team trying to shore up first base without creating another hole elsewhere, the decision comes down to balancing reliability against upside, with each choice carrying its own risk and reward as the Mets sort through the market. [Read more 🡒]
Cubs Could Have A Bigger Market Than Fans Expected This Winter
With Juan Soto, A.J. Ewing and Carson Benge already penciled into the outfield, the Mets look set there for now, but the lineup still has a spot that could use a jolt. The designated hitter role underperformed last season, and that has left some room for the club to explore offensive upgrades even if the rest of the outfield picture is mostly settled.
Seiya Suzuki and Ian Happ have come up as possible fits if the Mets decide to add another bat, though the bigger question is how aggressive they want to be. The interest is easy enough to understand, since both would add balance and production, but whether New York is willing to spend at that level remains the part still hanging in the air. [Read more 🡒]
Mets Already Face A 40-Man Decision On Three Overlooked Additions
Late in the 2026 season, the Mets used waiver claims to add Christian Cairo, Cameron Weston and Philip Abner to their 40-man roster, a trio of moves that barely registered outside the front office but can matter a lot once the offseason roster crunch begins. None of the three appeared in a major league game for New York, yet each gives the club another arm or infield option to sort through as it tries to balance depth, upside and flexibility.
Now comes the part the Mets always have to navigate this time of year, when marginal additions can turn into real decisions. Cairo, Weston and Abner all sit in that gray area where recent performance and organizational need will shape what comes next, but the bigger question is how much room New York is willing to keep open for players it only just brought in and has not yet seen on the field. [Read more 🡒]