The Mets spent the offseason making moves that were easy to measure right away, but a few of the quieter trades still haven’t shown their payoff at the major league level.
That’s the tricky part with roster shuffling. Some deals tell you what they are immediately.
Others ask for patience. For the Mets, three of last offseason’s trades still fall into that second category, even if the logic behind each one was pretty clear from the start.
The most talked-about one was the swap of Brandon Nimmo for Marcus Semien. The goal there was straightforward: open up a corner outfield spot and wipe out the final two years of Nimmo’s salary.
When the deal went down, Nimmo had five years left; Semien had three. Nimmo hasn’t been outstanding in 2026, but he has been more efficient than Semien.
Still, the real judgment on this trade probably won’t come until after the 2028 season, when the Mets are able to spend more freely. That’s when the savings will either help them land a new fan-favorite, disappear into a bust, or simply get used to lower payroll.
Jeff McNeil’s departure for Yordan Rodriguez was a different kind of move, and one that was easier to defend in the moment. McNeil had been trending down, and with the Athletics taking on $10 million of his $15.75 million salary, the Mets had a clean chance to cut costs.
McNeil has been a lighter version of himself in 2026, and with the way the rest of the offseason played out, he wouldn’t have had much of a role anyway. Rodriguez, the pitcher coming back, has missed all of 2026 because of an injury.
That doesn’t really change the outlook much. He’s only 18, and injury issues are part of the risk with young pitchers.
For now, the hope is that this turns into at least something worth pointing to later.
The least noticeable trade may also be the one with the longest runway. The Mets sent prospect Franklin Gomez to the Cleveland Guardians for international bonus slot money, and that kind of move can disappear into the background fast.
But Gomez hasn’t exactly gone quiet. The right-hander posted a 3.10 ERA in 10 starts in High-A, earned a promotion to Double-A before the season ended, and then put up a 3.78 ERA in four starts there.
He’s 21 now, which puts him more or less on schedule, though Rule 5 Draft eligibility starting this December means the Mets need him to keep moving. Cleveland probably wouldn’t be looking to grab him this offseason, so that concern can wait.
The bonus money is already gone too, with the Mets using it on Wandy Asingen and Cleiner Ramirez. Ramirez accounted for all $1.37 million, and his .819 OPS in the DOSL at least gives the deal a little more substance than a pure money swap.
In Other News...
Mets Just Turned Another Special Weekend Into A Fan Frustration
The Mets spent Sept. 19 trying to make a weekend feel celebratory, but the timing never quite let it breathe. Carlos Beltrans jersey retirement ceremony landed in the middle of a critical stretch of the season, and the weather did the atmosphere no favors, turning what should have been a polished tribute into another reminder that even the clubs special dates have been hard to stage cleanly this year.
Howie Roses long-awaited celebration is now being pushed to the opening weekend of the 2027 season, a delay tied to ongoing collective bargaining agreement negotiations and, reportedly, his own preference. Still, it fits a broader pattern for the Mets, who have managed to create multiple calendar headaches around their feel-good moments, leaving fans to wonder why so many of the years best intentions keep arriving with some obvious complication attached. [Read more 🡒]
Carlos Beltran Just Changed The Mets Manager Search Mood
Carlos Beltrans number retirement ceremony at Citi Field gave the Mets a celebratory backdrop, but it also turned into a reminder of where the clubs managerial search stands. Asked about the opening, Beltran did not close the door, yet he made clear that the job would require a major commitment and that his current personal and professional priorities are part of the equation. For a team still sorting through what it wants in its next manager, the timing of the question alone said plenty.
The Mets are widely viewed as needing someone with experience and a steady hand, and Beltrans response only sharpened that conversation. He remains a beloved figure in the organization, but his uncertainty adds another layer to a search already tied to broader questions about fit, readiness and leadership. Even on a night meant to honor his place in franchise history, the discussion drifted back to the future and the challenge of finding the right person to manage it. [Read more 🡒]
Former Mets Reliever Is Becoming A Phillies Problem At The Worst Time
When the Phillies brought in Brooks Raley from the Mets to shore up their bullpen, the idea was pretty straightforward: add a trusted left-hander for the stretch run and make a deeper October mix even more dangerous. Raley had done exactly that for New York, giving the Mets a reliable late-inning option and plenty of reasons to believe he could fit into another contenders relief plans without much fuss.
It has not gone that way in Philadelphia. Raley has struggled badly since the move, piling up an 8.71 ERA over 10.1 innings while allowing multiple runs and too many walks, a sharp departure from the steadier version the Mets knew well. With the postseason picture tightening, his spot on the Phillies' playoff roster suddenly looks a lot less secure than anyone expected when the deal was made. [Read more 🡒]