The Mets may not have much choice with Marcus Semien, but that doesn’t mean the second-base job should be handed over without a fight.
Semien arrived in the trade that sent Brandon Nimmo to the Texas Rangers last offseason, a move that was unpopular from the start and built around David Stearns’ winter-long push for run prevention. The idea was simple: strengthen the infield defense and tighten things up.
That part hasn’t really played out the way the Mets hoped. Semien’s glove hasn’t been as advertised, and the bat has gone in the wrong direction in Queens.
At this point, the concern is bigger than one bad stretch. Semien will be 36 years old on Opening Day, and his overall game has clearly slipped.
The offensive numbers tell the story plainly: .220/.284/.350 with 14 home runs, 45 RBIs, and a .634 OPS following New York’s 9-4 Labor Day win against the Marlins. That’s not the kind of production the Mets were banking on when they made the deal.
Still, the contract complicates everything. Semien has two years left and is due $26 million next season, which makes moving him highly unlikely. So for now, the more realistic question isn’t whether he’s gone - it’s whether anyone can push him.
Stearns has publicly called Semien a “steadying force” and praised his work ethic, and the Mets clearly still value what he brings in the clubhouse. The team also appears to believe his defense can still hold up. But Stearns has also made it clear that the Mets need more from him at the plate next year.
That’s where spring training gets interesting.
Jefferson Rojas looks like the cleanest fit to apply pressure at second base. He has the kind of skill set that makes sense there, and there’s even a path to a job share that could let him back up Francisco Lindor at shortstop from time to time, especially if Lindor is managed more carefully at this stage of his career.
Mitch Voit is another name to watch, and Émilien Pitre belongs in that same conversation. If one of those prospects turns heads in camp, a platoon with Semien could be on the table right away. There’s also the possibility of a shared role with Brett Baty if he remains on the roster beyond this season.
That setup might help Semien, too. Less wear and tear could lead to better numbers on both sides of the ball.
But the bottom line is simple: the Mets need insurance. Semien is still the favorite to open as the starting second baseman, but if he doesn’t get going early, the club has to be ready to turn to one of its young infielders.
My best guess is that Semien gets another shot in 2027. The leash, though, should be short.
In Other News...
Bo Bichette Is Creating A Mets Problem Fans Can Already See
Bo Bichettes arrival gave the Mets a much-needed boost, but it also came with a layer of roster planning that is already hard to ignore. His deal runs three years with player options after the first two, which means the club does not have anything close to a locked-in answer about whether he will still be around in 2027, even as the immediate fit looks clear.
The bigger wrinkle is what the signing cost and what a better Mets team could cost next. New York already gave up draft picks because of the qualifying offer rules, and if the club keeps climbing and pushes deeper into luxury tax territory, more penalties could follow. Bichettes recent uptick only adds to the uncertainty, since a strong finish would make it more realistic that he tests the market again before the Mets get the long-term stability they were buying. [Read more 🡒]
Mets Prospect Is Already Making His Draft Snub Look Ridiculous
Across the Mets Single-A and High-A ranks, the season brought its share of uneven results, but Aiden Robbins gave the organization something far more encouraging to track. The outfielder, taken in the third round at No. 92 overall, jumped into pro ball quickly and handled 26 games across A-Ball and High-A with a steady bat and enough defensive versatility to give the Mets another look at his long-term value.
What makes Robbins stand out is how much he already looks like a miss by the clubs that let him slide. MLB Pipeline had him ranked as the 29th best amateur prospect, and his early work has only reinforced the idea that New York may have gotten a little extra value on draft day. The larger question now is whether that strong first impression keeps growing as he settles in against tougher pitching and a bigger stage. [Read more 🡒]
Mets Roster Shuffle Says A Lot About Who Still Has A Chance
The Mets were back to making small but telling adjustments to the pitching staff, sending Jefry Yan down to Syracuse and recalling Tobias Myers as they continue sorting through who can help right now and who still needs more time. Moves like this rarely grab much attention on their own, but for a club trying to keep its options open, they can say plenty about where the roster stands and how carefully every arm is being evaluated.
Around the National League East, the day carried its usual mix of results and reminders that nothing stays static for long, with the Braves beating the Phillies, the Marlins taking care of the Cubs and the Nationals falling to the Dodgers. Add in the league-wide churn of milestones, injuries and even the news of Joe Morgans death, and the Mets latest shuffle fits the broader picture: October hopes are shaped not just by the stars at the top, but by the fringe players still fighting for one more chance. [Read more 🡒]