Jorge Polanco’s rough start with the Mets has already turned into a problem, but it may also be forcing the front office to face something it can’t talk its way around: the lineup needs more help, not less.
Polanco did give people a brief reason to wonder if the tide was turning. He went 2-for-4 with a double and a home run to close out the series against the Cleveland Guardians, and that was enough to get some folks thinking he might have finally found a spark.
Then came the Pittsburgh Pirates series, where he went 0-for-7 with a pair of strikeouts. At this point, the struggles have gotten so ugly that passengers from the 2013 “poop cruise” might be offering sympathy.
The numbers are brutal. Polanco is hitting .136/.190/.229 overall, and since coming off the IL, he has been even worse at .097/.138/.177.
A player brought in to fill multiple roles has not come close to meeting expectations, no matter how you slice it. If you thought he was supposed to replace Pete Alonso’s offense or Brandon Nimmo’s offense, this signing is tracking toward all-time bust territory.
And yet, there is at least one silver lining for the Mets if Polanco keeps scuffling: it should make it impossible for David Stearns to sell himself on an inferior lineup going into next season.
Stearns built this his way, and in 2026, just about everything went sideways. Polanco’s usage as a DH with some first-base upside stands out as one of the messier parts of the whole thing, even if it didn’t directly push out any fan favorites. There’s still a world where he and Pete Alonso are on the same roster, but Alonso is no longer part of the equation.
That leaves the Mets to sort through what comes next at first base. If Polanco’s health and production keep trending the way they have, the team can’t pretend he’s anything more than a part-time DH at best. Defense is still supposed to matter here, and that narrows the field.
One obvious name is Ty France, who signed a split contract with the San Diego Padres. He leads the leagues in OAA at first base and is carrying an .862 OPS, with splits that are pretty even against righties and lefties. If the Mets want to keep it simple, he looks like the straightforward target.
Of course, this is the Mets, so the options don’t stop there. They can also get creative and move players around.
There are multiple big-league roster pieces who should be taking ground balls before 2026 is over. The boldest idea of all would be shifting Juan Soto to first base and using the left-field spot for the team’s major offseason offensive addition.
Ian Happ is another name in the mix. He owns multiple Gold Gloves, brings proven right-handed power, and has a track record of strong on-base numbers.
He’s having a down year for the Chicago Cubs, but the profile still suggests a rebound could be coming. The concern, though, is obvious: he’s striking out nearly a third of the time.
However the Mets decide to attack it, Polanco staying cold only makes the warning lights brighter. A turnaround from him would be welcome, sure, but the bigger lesson may be that the Mets can’t afford to let his slump convince them they’re closer to finished than they really are.
In Other News...
Mets Prospect Depth Is Suddenly Giving Fans Plenty To Watch
A busy stretch around the Mets farm system has given the organization a deeper look at the names that could matter down the line, with Syracuse, Binghamton and Wilmington all turning in recent action worth tracking. The reports from those clubs included game results, individual stat lines and pitching performances, a reminder that the pipeline is not just about one headline prospect but a wave of players trying to force their way into the conversation.
The movement has not been limited to the box scores, either, as the roster shuffle continues to keep things interesting across the affiliates. Eric Wagamans assignment to Syracuse adds another layer to the upper-level picture, while Binghamtons pitching staff has also been adjusted with Bryce Conley coming aboard and Felipe De La Cruz heading to the injured list, leaving the Mets with a few more reasons to keep an eye on the systems next turn. [Read more 🡒]
Francisco Alvarez Headlines Mets Audition For A Future Role
The final seven weeks of the season have become less about the Mets present and more about their next meaningful roster decisions, with several players getting a chance to show whether they belong in the picture beyond this year. Brett Baty, Kodai Senga, Zac Thornton and a handful of bullpen arms are all part of that evaluation, but Francisco Alvarez stands out as one of the clearest names with real stakes attached to every game he plays.
For the Mets, the larger question is not just who can help now, but who can still matter when the club is mapping out its 2027 roster. Alvarez remains central to that conversation, even as trade talk continues to swirl around him and Francisco Lindor, adding another layer to what is already a crucial stretch for a team trying to sort out its future while the season still has some time left. [Read more 🡒]
Mets Just Got A Quick Reminder About Letting Jihwan Bae Go
Jihwan Baes path has already circled back into view for the Mets, just not in the way they might have hoped. After New York released him, the Brewers moved quickly to bring him aboard, a reminder that even players who spend most of a season in the minors can still draw real interest when another club sees a fit. Bae also brings a complicated background, including a domestic violence suspension from 2019, which only adds to the scrutiny surrounding any decision to give him another chance.
For the Mets, the jolt is less about one transaction than the larger question of whether there was more to keep there when they let him go. Milwaukees willingness to add Bae says something about the leagues appetite for depth and upside, especially with roster needs shifting from week to week. His season has been largely spent in the minors, but his quick reappearance in a big-league conversation is the kind of detail that can make a release look a little different in hindsight. [Read more 🡒]