The Phillies thought they had filled a bullpen hole at the trade deadline. Instead, Brooks Raley has become one of the most uneasy names in the relief mix.
Philadelphia added the left-hander from the New York Mets with the expectation that he would give interim manager Don Mattingly a dependable option from the left side. That has not happened. Raley has been far from the pitcher the Phillies believed they were getting, and his latest outing only sharpened that concern.
Against his former team over the weekend, Raley was summoned in relief of Andrew Painter, who worked 5.1 innings and allowed four runs. The idea was to keep the game within reach. Instead, things unraveled fast once Raley took over.
He opened by walking Carson Benge, then gave up a single to A.J. Ewing that moved Benge to third.
After another walk, this time to Marcus Semien, the bases were loaded. Brett Baty followed with a single that brought Benge home, and Mattingly quickly had to go back to the mound for another change.
Raley didn’t record an out in the appearance, and that kind of night has become the story of his Phillies stint. Since the trade deadline, his ERA has shot up to 8.71 across 15 appearances and 10.1 innings, with 10 earned runs allowed.
That’s a sharp drop from what he did with the Mets, where he posted a 1.96 ERA in 45 appearances over 41.1 innings. He struck out 40 batters and finished with 1.5 bWAR in New York. In Philadelphia, the numbers have gone the other way.
Raley has allowed 12 total runs with the Phillies, nine of them earned, while also giving up four home runs after surrendering only two with the Mets. His bWAR with Philadelphia sits at -0.4. The underlying numbers are just as rough, with a 7.45 FIP and an ERA+ of 54.
For a reliever brought in to steady game-to-game spots against left-handed hitters, that’s a brutal swing. Right now, Mattingly doesn’t have much reason to trust him, and Raley is running out of time to change that.
What looked like a helpful deadline addition has turned into a real problem. Raley has one week left to show enough to stay in the playoff picture, because at the moment he’s pitching his way out of it.
In Other News...
Mets May Have A Homegrown First Base Answer After Pete Alonso
Corey Collins spent his second pro season giving the Mets a look at something they do not always get to enjoy from within the system: a young hitter with real power and a patient approach. The 2024 draftee moved through Single-A and Double-A, and his left-handed bat stood out enough to put him on the radar as a possible middle-of-the-order type down the road.
Defensively, the path is still being sorted out, with Collins a converted catcher who could wind up at first base or even in the outfield. For the Mets, that matters because the organization is always thinking ahead at the cold corner, and a homegrown option with some pop and on-base skill is the kind of developmental track worth watching closely. [Read more 🡒]
Mets Prospect Just Put Syracuse's Season On His Shoulders
Syracuse kept its playoff hopes alive in dramatic fashion with a 5-4 win over Lehigh Valley, and Mets prospect DAndre Smith was right in the middle of it. Smith delivered the walkoff two-run home run in the bottom of the ninth, then added a key defensive play earlier in the game, giving the club a needed spark on both sides of the ball when the margin for error was thin.
The victory leaves Syracuse half a game behind Rochester with one game left in the regular season, so every inning from here carries real weight. For a team trying to stay in the race, Smiths impact was the kind that can tilt an entire night, and now the Mets-affiliated club has put itself in position to keep pressing until the final out. [Read more 🡒]
Mets Prospects Forced A 2027 Roster Conversation In 2026
As the Mets minor league season winds down with only Triple-A Syracuse still active, the organization is already getting a clearer picture of which young players are forcing their way into the bigger conversation. Mitch Voit was recently recognized with the 2026 Player Development Award after a noticeable jump in his production, including more pop and more stolen bases, while the system has also gotten important contributions from Nate Lavender and Marco Vargas at different points of the year.
Lavenders return from Tommy John surgery has been one of the quieter development wins, with the left-hander handling both Triple-A and major league work well enough to keep his name in the mix. Vargas, meanwhile, has pushed up to Double-A and shown improved numbers despite injury interruptions, giving the Mets a few more reasons to think beyond the immediate roster picture and toward what the next wave could look like. [Read more 🡒]