ESPN’s midseason report cards didn’t leave much room for debate: two teams crashed all the way to the bottom.
Through roughly the first 90 games of the MLB season, the network handed out grades across the league on Tuesday, and only the New York Mets and San Francisco Giants came away with F’s. A number of clubs earned A’s for outperforming expectations, but these two were singled out for seasons that have gone sideways.
The Mets’ grade reflected a year full of chaos. ESPN pointed to managerial changes, expensive injuries and sloppy play, and even cited several memorable New York Post back pages as a snapshot of how rough things have gotten in New York.
San Francisco’s report card wasn’t any kinder. ESPN highlighted organizational controversy, disappointing free-agent signings and an underwhelming first season under manager Tony Vitello. The outlet also took aim at several decisions made by president of baseball operations Buster Posey, saying few of the offseason additions have provided meaningful value.
Just behind them sat a cluster of teams that came close to the same kind of embarrassment. The Orioles drew a D after another frustrating season for a club that once looked like an American League powerhouse.
The Royals landed at D- as injuries wrecked their pitching staff, even with Bobby Witt Jr. still producing. The Angels also got a D- after another losing year that ended with a front-office shakeup.
Toronto rounded out the group with a D after failing to defend its World Series championship.
Of course, these grades are only a snapshot. The trade deadline is still ahead, injured stars are expected back, and teams like the Mets still have enough talent to make noise in the second half.
Even so, ESPN’s evaluations made the first-half story pretty clear. For the Mets and Giants, the season has fallen far short of the standard they set in March, and both are heading into the stretch run with more questions than answers.
In Other News...
Why Would The Mets Even Consider This NL East Trade Rumor
The National League East has a way of turning even routine roster chatter into something more urgent, and this latest bit of speculation fits that pattern. A CBS Sports writer floated a scenario in which the Mets would consider moving a pitcher who has been sidelined after taking a 110-plus mph line drive off his leg, a reminder that health and timing can reshape how front offices view a player almost overnight.
The wrinkle here is the business side as much as the injury. With a $12 million player option after the season in the mix, the Mets have to weigh whether holding on makes sense if the return could be limited, especially in a division where every edge matters. Nothing has been confirmed, but the rumor underscores how quickly a contender can be pushed to think about value, risk and what happens if it waits too long. [Read more 🡒]
One Forgotten Mets Deadline Move Looks Worse With The Dodgers
The Mets spent the 2024 trade deadline trying to fortify a roster that eventually pushed deep into October, and most of the attention naturally went to the bigger swings that helped shape that run against the Dodgers. But tucked inside the deadline shuffle was a smaller move that has aged a lot more awkwardly, especially now that Los Angeles is getting some useful innings from a pitcher New York once had in its system.
Paul Gervase has given the Dodgers a bullpen option they can keep leaning on, even if the results have come with the usual rookie volatility. He has shown enough swing-and-miss to matter, but also enough control trouble to keep the story from feeling finished, which is exactly the kind of detail that makes a modest deadline deal look different in hindsight. [Read more 🡒]
Mets Fans May Finally Embrace This Tyrone Taylor Trade Idea
If the Mets do decide Tyrone Taylor is movable, the return may not need to be flashy to make sense. Seattle has been sorting through its own outfield picture, and that kind of roster crunch can create openings for a deal built around depth and upside rather than a headline name. For New York, the appeal is obvious: Taylor is the sort of piece a contender can part with if it helps address another part of the roster, especially when the front office is looking for ways to keep the margins working in its favor.
The more interesting part is whether the Mets would use that kind of swap to bring in a pitcher who is close enough to matter soon, but still has some development left in the tank. With A.J. Minter and Brooks Raley no longer in the mix, there is at least a path for a left-handed arm to get a look, and Seattles system has one that has been moving through the upper levels with strong strikeout numbers and steady run prevention. The wrinkle is timing, because a pitcher in that spot can be useful to a club now, while also carrying enough roster pressure that the other side has to decide whether to hold on or make a move before the offseason changes the calculus. [Read more 🡒]