David Stearns Faces Three Mets Decisions That Could Define This Offseason

As the Mets navigate crucial offseason choices, strategic signings in the bullpen and batting lineup could define their success.

David Stearns has plenty on his plate this offseason, and the Mets’ president of baseball operations has already shown he’s willing to make moves that don’t always fit the easy script. That’s why the conversation around New York shouldn’t stop at the obvious names. There are realistic targets out there who could help the roster right away, and three stand out: closer David Bednar, starter/reliever Michael King, and second baseman Josh Lowe.

The bullpen is one of the first places the Mets have to sort out. Devin Williams lost the closer job in 2026 because of his poor performance, and Kodai Senga still hasn’t shown he can handle a full season as a reliever, much less as a closer.

Bednar would give them a cleaner answer. He’s coming off one of the strongest seasons of his career, piling up 35 saves - the second-most he’s ever had in a year - while logging a career-high 69.1 innings.

Jim Bowden of The Athletic projected Bednar for a three-year, $55 million deal. That would top the contract Williams signed last offseason by $4 million, but Bednar brings a longer record of success.

It would also leave Williams with a chance to slide into an eighth-inning role and try to reset his Mets tenure. Trevor Megill is another name in the mix, but he’s in a contract year in 2027 and could be traded, which would likely require a hefty prospect return.

Bednar, by contrast, would cost money - and Steve Cohen has plenty of that.

If the Mets decide against a run at Tarik Skubal, King becomes an interesting alternative alongside a possible reunion with Clay Holmes. In theory, the two contracts combined could come in a little below or around Skubal’s price, giving the Mets two high-end pitchers instead of one. King just opted out of his deal with the Padres after throwing the most innings of his career, 185, and posting a 3.21 ERA with 159 strikeouts.

There’s also a New York angle with King that matters. He has already shown he can thrive in the city, with some of his best seasons coming with the Yankees.

After the Freddy Peralta signing went so badly, prior success in New York has to count for something when the Mets weigh free agents. King’s background as a reliever adds another layer of value, too.

If the Mets are good enough to get into the playoffs, he could still be used out of the bullpen - a much easier ask than leaning on young pitchers like Nolan McLean and Zac Thornton in that role.

Lowe might be the least flashy name of the group, but he could end up being one of the most useful. He has put together back-to-back seasons with 30-plus home runs, and this past year he added 96 RBI and an .824 OPS.

Even in the two seasons when he drove in more than 90 runs, 2021 and 2026, he didn’t make the All-Star team. Still, the market should treat him like a real bat, with Bowden projecting a three-year, $45 million contract.

The fit isn’t perfect, though. Marcus Semien’s contract is still on the books for $46 million over the next two seasons, and Jefferson Rojas is waiting in Triple-A as the organization’s top prospect.

Rojas could be ready to handle second base in the majors as soon as 2027. But Semien’s rough 2026 season changes the equation, and a lockout could also slow Rojas’s development by keeping him out of minor league games.

That could leave the Mets in a tough spot if they’re forced to open the season with Semien.

That’s where Lowe could make sense. He’s a proven second baseman who can drive in runs, and that’s something the Mets have been missing for a long time. In an offseason where Stearns has to think big and think differently, Bednar, King, and Lowe all belong on the board.

In Other News...

Mets Offseason Activity Is Picking Up Faster Than Fans Expected

The Mets offseason started to take shape a little earlier than some fans probably expected, with the club making a handful of small but notable moves as the calendar turns toward winter. New York claimed Jack Anderson and Pierson Ohl off waivers and added Christian Cairo on a one-year major league contract, the kind of roster housekeeping that often signals a front office getting busy before the bigger decisions arrive.

There was also a bit of good news on the player-development side, with Carson Benge named a finalist for the National League Rookie of the Year Award. And for fans already looking ahead to next season, the team moved up the single-game ticket sale date to November 12, another sign that the offseason is picking up steam even as the rest of Major League Baseball sorts through award finalists and roster churn across the league. [Read more 🡒]

Mets Rumored Free Agent Fits Come With One Big Problem

The Mets are already being sized up for the 2027 offseason, and the early free-agent chatter is less about splash and more about fit. Names like Ty France, Adrian Morejon and Jake Bauers have surfaced as possible targets, but each one comes with a different version of the same issue: the roster picture, the money picture and the teams actual needs do not line up neatly.

For a club that is always under pressure to add talent, that creates a familiar kind of offseason frustration. The speculation is easy enough to generate, but the path from rumor to signing is much harder to map when the Mets have to balance what they want with what they can realistically afford and where the roster can actually absorb another piece. [Read more 🡒]

Mets Mourn A Franchise Icon From Their First Golden Era

Jerry Koosman, one of the defining figures from the Mets first golden era, has died at 83, closing the book on a career that helped shape the franchises identity. A Hall of Famer in team history and a cornerstone of the 1969 World Series champions, Koosman spent 12 seasons in New York and left behind the kind of rsum that still carries weight whenever the Mets talk about their roots.

His place in club lore was already secure long before the team retired his No. 36 in 2021, making him just the third player in franchise history to receive that honor. Koosmans 140 wins and 3.07 ERA speak to the consistency he brought over a long run in Queens, and his passing is a reminder of how much of the Mets earliest success was built on players whose impact still echoes through the organization. [Read more 🡒]