The New York Mets are heading into an offseason that already feels loaded with pressure.
After a second straight disappointing year, the club has plenty to clean up - and president of baseball operations David Stearns is about to take on one of the biggest offseasons since he arrived. New York was supposed to contend in the National League East in 2026, even after tearing apart the core. Instead, everything unraveled in Flushing.
The season spiraled from the start. The Mets opened with a 12-game losing streak, the offseason additions flopped, and the club ended up making a managerial change in the middle of the year. By the time it was over, New York had finished 74-88 and in last place in the NL East for the first time since 2003.
That collapse traces back to an offseason that went wrong almost immediately. It started when the Mets sent longest-tenured Met Brandon Nimmo to the Texas Rangers for infielder Marcus Semien.
Then, within 24 hours during the MLB Winter Meetings, Edwin Díaz left for the Los Angeles Dodgers, Pete Alonso landed a five-year deal with the Baltimore Orioles, and Jeff McNeil was dealt to the Athletics. The teardown of that core was complete.
What came next only deepened the damage.
Semien, brought in largely for his defense at second base, made six errors this season after committing only two last year with Texas. At the plate, the 36-year-old struggled badly, hitting .215/.280/.340 with 15 home runs, 49 RBIs and a career-worst .620 OPS across 139 games.
Luis Robert Jr. also never got rolling. The outfielder arrived from the Chicago White Sox carrying an injury history, and those issues showed up again.
He played in just 58 games for New York after landing on the injured list on April 26 with a lumbar disc herniation, then spent nearly three months out. The Mets placed him on waivers on Aug. 29, and the Orioles claimed him two days later.
Jorge Polanco’s move to first base was another miss. Stearns signed the veteran infielder to a two-year, $40 million deal to replace Alonso, even though Polanco had never played the position in the majors. The 33-year-old, who also arrived with a lengthy injury background, appeared in only 37 games before left ankle bursitis eventually led to season-ending surgery.
And then there was Alonso himself, who made the Mets pay for letting him go. He finished third in Major League Baseball with 43 home runs and second with 113 RBIs. On Sept. 15, he hit his 300th career homer against the Mets at the ballpark he used to call home.
Freddy Peralta was supposed to anchor the rotation, but that never came close to happening. The Mets acquired him to be the ace, yet the two-time All-Star posted a career-worst 4.99 ERA in 22 starts before being traded to the Tampa Bay Rays ahead of the deadline.
Bo Bichette, signed to a three-year deal, did eventually help late in the year. But his impact came after a rough opening stretch, and it was far too late to salvage the season after the April slide.
Owner Steve Cohen backed Stearns, but the mistakes from last offseason left the fan base frustrated and the organization staring at another major reset. The Mets do have some young talent that stood out during the down year, but that alone won’t be enough. If they want to get back into the race in the ultra-competitive NL East, this winter has to be a strong one.
In Other News...
Mets Quietly Look Better And Better After This Bullpen Trade
Huascar Brazobn had quietly become a useful piece for the Mets after arriving in 2024, giving the bullpen a dependable arm who could handle different roles and take on meaningful innings. Even after a strong first half in 2026, the Mets decided to move him at the deadline, a decision that looked like a standard bullpen shuffle at the time.
Since going to the White Sox, Brazobns results have trended the wrong way, with a higher ERA and a stint on the injured list. Meanwhile, the return is beginning to look more interesting for New York, as prospects Gabe Davis and Zach Franklin have each flashed promise in the minors and given the front office a little more reason to feel good about the trades long-term value. [Read more 🡒]
Mets Suddenly Have A Tough Call On One Departed Depth Piece
MJ Melendez and Vidal Brujan have both elected free agency after the season, leaving the Mets to weigh whether either depth piece still fits into the picture going forward. Melendez got a brief look in the majors but never really got going with the club, while both players spent time in Triple-A and turned in stronger stretches there than they did on the big league stage.
The question now is whether the Mets want to circle back on either player at all, and the answer may be different for each. Brujan does not appear to fill an obvious current need, but Melendez could still be viewed as a possible minor league depth option if the organization wants to keep some familiar coverage in the system. Either way, their futures with the team are unsettled. [Read more 🡒]
Mets Prospects Are Already Creating One Early AFL Debate
The Arizona Fall League season is still young, but the Mets are already getting a better look at how their prospects are fitting into the mix with Surprise. Over the first stretch of games from Oct. 11 through Oct. 17, the clubs group showed up across the box scores, with hitters like Cole Mathis, Boston Baro and Bruin Agbayani collecting opportunities while arms such as Brendan Girton, Calvin Ziegler, Ryan Lambert, Irving Cota and Peyton Prescott got early work in a developmental setting that is supposed to test them as much as showcase them.
Even in a week interrupted by postponed games because of inclement weather and power issues, there has been enough action to spark one familiar fall discussion for Mets observers: which of these young players is making the strongest early impression, and who still needs more runway. The numbers and usage from the opening week have given the organization a useful snapshot, but the broader question of who is truly separating themselves is still very much open as the AFL schedule settles in. [Read more 🡒]