David Stearns spent enough of the past year giving the Mets new problems that this winter feels like another test of his judgment. Some of those swings didn’t bury the club - the Luis Robert Jr. trade, for example, didn’t end up punishing the Mets too badly. Others are still hanging around, including the kind of money tied up in Jorge Polanco that makes you wince.
Now Stearns is headed toward another offseason where one wrong call could stick, while another one might be worth living with. The bigger issue is figuring out which mistakes the Mets can actually survive.
One area Stearns can’t afford to mishandle is the group of players who already lost his trust. He made a bold shakeup last winter, but there were still more names he could have moved on from if the market had cooperated.
That was never simple. Some of those players had tanked so badly that nobody wanted them.
He can’t blow the whole thing up, but he does need to keep the changes coming. That means decisions on Mark Vientos, Sean Manaea, Kodai Senga, and Ronny Mauricio.
Mauricio belongs in that conversation now, too. He’s out of options, hasn’t done much in the majors, and looks so far removed from the team’s future plans that he might not even still be around by the non-tender deadline later this week.
The most likely outcome is that Vientos, Mauricio, and Senga are wearing different uniforms. Senga and Manaea are the tricky pair because neither really fits in the big league rotation to open the year.
Senga is the easier one to move, mostly because his salary is about $10 million lower. There’s also the possibility of someone taking a shot on him in the bullpen.
The Mets can’t let fear of him succeeding in another role get in the way. He’s been given plenty of chances, and aside from a brief stretch, he looks too close to finished.
At second base, though, Stearns can afford to be a little more patient. The current idea seems to be Marcus Semien and Brett Baty fighting for the job, and that’s a shaky plan on paper. Counting on Semien to reverse a long decline or on Baty to become something much more than he has been so far is a big ask.
But this is one spot where the Mets have enough cover to let it play out. Jefferson Rojas, Emilien Pitre, Mitch Voit, and even a veteran signed with the hope of turning into another Jose Iglesias give them backup paths.
If they cut Semien now, that could affect how they spend elsewhere. And the expectation is that his time in New York ends after the 2027 season anyway.
The Mets could still chase a trade-deadline rental, or even slide Bo Bichette or A.J. Ewing over to second. With that many possible routes, they’d be wasting money - and maybe a roster spot - by rushing to add someone else for the job.
It’s a mistake to assume Semien and Baty are already good enough. It’s also one the Mets can probably afford to let unfold.
In Other News...
Mets Face One Team That Could Ruin Their Tarik Skubal Push
Tarik Skubal is shaping up to be one of the biggest names on the market before the current collective bargaining agreement expires on Dec. 1, and the Mets have already surfaced as one of the teams with a real chance to land him. For a club that has not been shy about chasing top-end talent, that puts them in the middle of a bidding picture that also includes the Dodgers, Padres and Blue Jays, each weighing its own payroll realities and roster priorities as the clock keeps moving.
The wrinkle for the Mets is that this is not just about money, even if money will matter plenty. Skubals camp is expected to have preferences that could influence where he lands, and the teams in the mix are coming at the pursuit from very different angles, with some better positioned than others to make a clean fit. No deal has been announced yet, which leaves New York waiting to see whether its early standing in the race is enough to survive the final stretch. [Read more 🡒]
Mets First Base Search May Hinge On One Contract Line Stearns Hates
Ty Frances career year has put him squarely in the conversation as the Mets sort through first-base options, and the fit is easy to see on paper. He is coming off the kind of season that tends to change how teams view a player in free agency, which is why his name has started to surface alongside other possible targets as New York weighs how to address the position.
The bigger question may not be Frances ability so much as the shape of the deal, because the Mets have shown a clear preference for certain contract structures and that can matter just as much as the player himself. Alec Bohm and Paul Goldschmidt are part of the same broader discussion, but the market for first basemen has been shifting, and one contract term could end up making France more or less appealing to David Stearns and the front office. [Read more 🡒]
Yankees Could Get An Early Warning From This Ex-Bullpen Arms Market
The Blue Jays rough 2026 season left them staring at a familiar winter priority list, with injuries hammering the starting rotation and the bullpen likely to get its share of attention, too. Toronto is expected to be aggressive in the offseason as it looks for upgrades on both fronts, and one name already drawing notice is free agent reliever Jonathan Loaisiga, a pitcher whose market appears to be forming quickly.
Loaisigas appeal is easy to see for a club trying to patch together depth and swing-and-miss relief help, but Toronto is not alone in the chase. With multiple teams also in the mix, the early interest around the right-hander could become one of the first signs of how competitive the bullpen market may be, and for the Yankees, it offers a useful read on how much demand there may be for familiar arms from around the division. [Read more 🡒]
