In a move that underscores the high-stakes nature of MLB trades, a former New York Mets prospect, now shining as a Chicago Cubs star, has secured a lucrative contract extension. This development highlights the costly gamble the Mets took years ago.
The Mets, known for their aggressive strategies, have enjoyed moments of success, like their 101-win season in 2022 and a National League Championship Series appearance in 2024. However, this approach has also led to its share of setbacks, including losing records in three of the last six seasons and a disappointing collapse last year. For a team with such high expectations, anything less than a deep playoff run feels like a missed opportunity.
Being aggressive in the MLB comes with literal costs-big contracts and trading away top prospects to land star players. As the 2026 season approaches, the Mets are still feeling the impact of these decisions. Former top outfield prospect Pete Crow-Armstrong, who was traded to the Cubs in 2021, is finalizing a significant contract extension with Chicago.
While the specifics of the extension are yet to be revealed, it's expected to reflect Crow-Armstrong's remarkable 2025 season. At just 23, he delivered a stellar performance with 31 home runs, 95 RBIs, 35 stolen bases, and standout defense, earning him All-Star honors and a Gold Glove award.
The Mets traded Crow-Armstrong, their No. 5 prospect at the time, for shortstop Javier Baez and pitcher Trevor Williams during the 2021 trade deadline. At that point, the Mets were sitting eight games above .500, aiming for a postseason push.
Unfortunately, that push never materialized, as the team faltered in the second half, ending the season 77-85 and missing the playoffs by 11.5 games. Baez left in free agency, and Williams contributed modestly with a 1.4 WAR before moving on.
Meanwhile, Crow-Armstrong found his stride with the Cubs, establishing himself as one of the league's top center fielders. His breakout year in 2025 set the stage for the well-deserved extension he's about to receive.
This saga serves as a reminder of the risks and rewards inherent in MLB trades, where the fortunes of teams can hinge on the development of young prospects like Crow-Armstrong.