The National League Rookie of the Year race has turned into a real three-way debate, and the finalists all bring something different to the table.
New York Mets outfielder Carson Benge is in the mix with St. Louis Cardinals shortstop JJ Wetherholt and Cincinnati Reds corner infielder Sal Stewart, and each one has a case that can be sold in a different way. The field could have looked different, too, with Mets starter Nolan McLean and Colorado Rockies first baseman TJ Rumfield both left out despite what the source material describes as strong cases of their own.
Wetherholt is the cleanest statistical argument if you want to reward the most complete season from start to finish. He spent most of the year looking like the favorite, and for good reason.
His defense at second base was elite, with +25 DRS, and his bat was right around league average at a 101 wRC+. Even with only 139 games played and a few weeks lost to wrist tendonitis, he still led all National League rookies with 4.6 fWAR and trailed only Kevin McGonigle among all rookies.
He was steady from the jump, and that kind of consistency always plays well in award voting.
Stewart is the loudest traditional candidate. His defense at first base was below average at -2 DRS, and his 112 wRC+ doesn’t scream superstar.
But the counting numbers are impossible to miss. He hit 32 home runs, the most of any NL rookie by a wide margin, and his 112 RBI were 20 more than any other rookie and third in all of baseball.
He finished with 2.0 fWAR, which was only fifth among NL rookies and 17th among all rookies, but the raw production jumps off the page. His .263/.330/.457 slash line only adds to the case.
In another era, that kind of season probably wins going away.
Then there’s Benge, who gives voters a little bit of everything. He finished with 4.3 fWAR, second among NL rookies and third among all rookies, while pairing a 118 wRC+ with solid defense at +1 DRS.
He also went 20/20, finishing with exactly 20 home runs and 22 stolen bases. That alone puts him in rare company.
According to research done by MLB.com’s Anthony DiComo, Benge became the eighteenth player in MLB history to reach that mark as a rookie, and eight of those eighteen did it in their debut season, Benge included.
His season also came with a clear arc. April was rough, with a 48 wRC+.
He bounced back in May with a 128 wRC+, slipped a bit in June at 108, then caught fire the rest of the way with a 126 wRC+ in July, a 143 wRC+ in August and a 147 wRC+ in September. That turnaround gives his candidacy a different kind of weight.
He didn’t just put up numbers; he recovered from a brutal start and then became one of the best rookies in the league over the summer.
Any of the three could win, and none of the outcomes would be shocking. Still, Benge may be the most interesting blend of the three styles of argument.
He has the analytical case, the traditional 20/20 case and the narrative case, all in one package. Even so, the guess here is Stewart gets the vote, because a 32-homer, 112-RBI season is the sort of thing that tends to stick with voters.
In Other News...
Mets Prospects Are Sending Very Different Signals In Arizona
The Arizona Fall League has offered a mixed read on a handful of Mets prospects over the past week, with some players stacking productive outings while others have been harder to pin down. The game results from Nov. 2 through Nov. 8 have given the organization a fresh look at where several young names stand, and the season-to-date numbers have started to separate those who are making a clear case from those still searching for rhythm.
Bruin Agbayani, Boston Baro, Cole Mathis, Irving Cota, Brendan Girton, Ryan Lambert, Peyton Prescott and Calvin Ziegler have all been part of that uneven picture, with batting and pitching lines that point in different directions. For the Mets, that is the point of the AFL in the first place: a chance to see which prospects are building momentum, which ones are simply getting reps, and which ones still have a little more proving to do before the winter wraps up. [Read more 🡒]
Mets Could Face An Early Trade Mistake At GM Meetings
The GM Meetings are set to put the Mets in a familiar spot, balancing present-day needs against a roster that still has plenty of moving parts. Mark Vientos and Francisco Alvarez are both part of that conversation, and the front office is weighing whether to use one of those young pieces to bring back help that fits a more immediate need, especially on the mound.
What makes this stretch tricky is the timing. With an impending lockout hanging over the sport, the Mets may not get many clean chances to reshape the roster later, which raises the stakes on every trade discussion now. That is why the idea of chasing short-term starting pitching rentals is being viewed with caution, even as names like Reid Detmers surface in broader talks and the pressure to make the right call only grows. [Read more 🡒]
Mets Bullpen Squeeze Leaves David Stearns Facing Harder Choices
Luis Garcias exit after only six games was a reminder of how little room there is for error in a Mets bullpen that was already packed when the offseason began. Signed as a free agent last winter, Garcia never got much of a runway before the club designated him for assignment, and his departure only sharpened the roster squeeze David Stearns inherited.
The bigger issue now is flexibility, or the lack of it. With no impending free agents to clear space and several pitchers still under review because of availability and performance concerns, the Mets have to sort out who fits where before they can even think about adding to the mix. Setup roles and the ninth inning are part of the conversation, but the more immediate challenge is simply finding enough breathing room to make the bullpen work. [Read more 🡒]