The Mets' recent signing of Bo Bichette, after missing out on Kyle Tucker, is an intriguing move that could reshape their infield dynamics. While the Mets don't have a pressing need at shortstop, Bichette's eagerness to take on third base offers a potential solution to their uncertainty at the hot corner. His three-year, $126 million contract, however, is layered with complexities that could impact both his and the team's future.
The contract's unique structure includes opt-outs after each of the first two years, allowing Bichette the flexibility to test free agency again. Notably, if he opts out after 2026, he pockets an additional $5 million bonus on top of his $42 million salary.
This setup places the Mets in a tricky position. Should Bichette excel, he'll likely take the bonus and explore more lucrative opportunities, leaving the Mets to fill the void.
Conversely, if his performance dips, he might choose to stay, content with his substantial salary.
Positionally, Bichette's move to third base raises questions. Historically a shortstop, his defensive metrics suggest a shift could be beneficial.
In 2025, he recorded -12 Defensive Runs Saved, the lowest among shortstops, echoing his struggles from 2022 with -16 DRS. His limited range and agility have been consistent issues, and while third base might mitigate some concerns, his arm strength and range remain potential liabilities.
Spring training has yet to provide clarity on his defensive capabilities at third, leaving the Mets to ponder his long-term fit. If he remains for the contract's full term, decisions about his ideal position will persist.
Will teams see him as a viable shortstop, or will third base become his permanent home? And if his defense doesn't improve, could a shift to another infield position be on the horizon?
The Mets' commitment to Bichette, particularly after the Tucker negotiations, suggests a calculated risk. The front office's confidence in his potential is evident, yet the player options present more questions than answers. Depending on how this pans out, Bichette's contract could either set a new precedent or be a cautionary tale for future deals.