The Mets are making waves this offseason by bringing in Bo Bichette and Jorge Polanco to strengthen their infield. Polanco inked a two-year, $40 million deal back in December, while Bichette, one of the top free agents, joined the team in January with a three-year, $126 million contract, including opt-outs after 2026 and 2027. Both players are set to tackle new roles, with Bichette taking on third base and Polanco splitting time between first base and designated hitter.
When it comes to offensive prowess, Bichette stands out. Despite a challenging 2024 season due to injuries, where he only played 81 games, he’s consistently delivered at least 20% above average by wRC+ since 2019.
Last season, Bichette showcased a stellar .314/.357/.483 line, boasting a 134 wRC+, marking the best full-season performance of his career. His strikeout rate was also impressive, tying for the 25th-lowest among 145 qualified hitters.
Polanco, on the other hand, is coming off a career-best season. In 524 plate appearances with the Mariners, he posted a .265/.326/.495 line with a 132 wRC+, nearly matching Bichette's numbers.
Notably, Polanco slashed his strikeout rate from 29.2% in 2024 to 15.6% in 2025. While his previous track record was solid, it didn’t quite match Bichette’s consistency, with a few exceptions in 2020 and 2024.
Defensively, neither player shines. Bichette, who has primarily played shortstop, ventured to second base during the 2025 World Series due to injury.
His defensive metrics from 2025, including a first percentile range and negative views on arm strength and sprint speed, suggest a move to third base makes sense, especially with Marcus Semien handling second. However, Bichette may face challenges with balls in play from right-handed hitters at third.
Polanco started his career at shortstop but has focused on second and third base since 2023. In 2024, he was rated -1 DRS and -10 OAA as a second baseman.
By 2025, he logged -4 DRS and -4 OAA between second and third, playing fewer defensive innings as he often served as a DH. Statcast also views Polanco’s range and arm strength negatively, though this is less of an issue at first base.
Unlike Bichette, Polanco struggles more with balls in play from left-handed hitters.
The financial aspect is crucial in assessing their value to the Mets. While the team can handle hefty contracts, the current front office under David Stearns prefers short-term deals. Bichette’s opt-out clauses after 2026 could turn his contract into a one-year, $47 million deal, offering flexibility but also posing a risk given his defensive challenges and new position.
Polanco’s contract lacks opt-outs, guaranteeing him $40 million through 2027. Although he’s less costly than Bichette, his offensive consistency is uncertain, especially if his strikeout rate regresses. His declining walk rate since 2022 adds to the concern, and at four years older than Bichette, age could become a factor as he continues playing.
The Mets’ fans are left to ponder: Does Bichette’s offensive firepower justify his high salary despite defensive concerns? Can Polanco replicate last year’s success at first base?
Which player offers better value for their contract? The debate is open.