The Knicks are going to open this season wearing the bull’s-eye that comes with being the champs, and around the league there’s no shortage of doubt about whether they can run it back at the same level.
That doesn’t mean New York has slipped out of the conversation. It just means last spring’s march through the playoffs was so sharp, so physical and so complete that repeating it may be tougher than people think. A scout who spoke to Sports Illustrated framed it this way: “They'll probably be tough in the playoffs because of the experience they have if they're healthy, but I probably wouldn't put them as a clear-cut favorite right away.”
At the center of everything is Jalen Brunson, who now sits in a strange place for a superstar: still undersized by league standards, still impossible to ignore. The scout compared him to Victor Wembanyama in a way that had nothing to do with body type and everything to do with how both players warp expectations.
“They call Wemby the Alien. Brunson is, too,” the scout said.
“Brunson is a different kind of alien, but the same category where he's doing s--- at his size that you wouldn't expect. And regardless of his physical numbers, you couldn't stop him.
It was crazy.”
That was the story of the Knicks’ title run. They won their first championship in 53 years with a roster that kept delivering from top to bottom, but Brunson was the engine and the face of it all, earning Finals MVP honors along the way. Now the challenge is turning that one historic postseason into something repeatable.
“Can [Brunson] do it again? If he can keep that up for a whole season or even back-to-back playoffs, I'll be surprised just because of how high of a level he was playing at and scoring at,” the scout said.
New York’s core is still intact. Karl-Anthony Towns, OG Anunoby, Josh Hart and Mikal Bridges are all back, which gives the Knicks a real foundation to work with.
The problem is that the league around them has changed, and it has gotten crowded fast. The Eastern Conference, in particular, picked up superstar additions for the Sixers, Heat and Raptors.
Indiana will have Tyrese Haliburton back. Boston is still hanging around.
Detroit is coming off a 60-win season. And whoever comes out of the East still has to deal with Wembanyama and the Spurs or Shai Gilgeous-Alexander and the Thunder on the other side.
The Knicks also took a hit where it mattered most in the postseason. Mitchell Robinson, who played a major role in the defensive plan against Wembanyama, left for the Celtics on a three-year contract.
New York couldn’t keep him while holding onto the rest of the bench and staying under the second apron. Ariel Hukporti also departed over the offseason and signed with the 76ers.
To patch that hole, the Knicks brought in Andre Drummond on a veteran minimum. He gives them rebounding and some bench size, and he even showed a little three-point touch last season, which Robinson doesn’t bring. Still, Drummond is 33, and he isn’t a simple one-for-one answer for everything Robinson provided.
“For the Knicks it is about staying healthy. Mike Brown did a great job managing minutes last year and he has to do that again.
Obviously, losing Robinson, can Drummond replace those minutes? That will be huge,” the scout said.
“... I mean, numbers wise, I would guess it's not that great of a drop-off with Drummond because Robinson only played 20 minutes a game, but I'd be curious to see how Drummond plays.
“Robinson, I feel like, did a pretty good job of doing exactly what he does well and only doing that. And at least historically, Drummond, I feel like at times, tries to do a little too much. Maybe he won't do that with that team and then it'll be more of a push, but I guess we'll see.”
Even with that change, the Knicks did manage to keep most of their bench together. Landry Shamet returns after his playoff shotmaking mattered so much.
Jose Alvarado, acquired at the trade deadline, is back too. Jordan Clarkson stayed put.
And Mohamed Diawara could carve out a role after signing a four-year, $11.3 million deal this summer. The 6-foot-9 wing flashed enough in a limited first NBA season to put himself in Brown’s rotation mix.
The opener will tell us plenty. New York starts the defense of its crown on Oct. 20 against the 76ers, and that comes right after the ring ceremony at Madison Square Garden. From there, the schedule turns into a long test of whether last year was the beginning of a real window or just a perfectly timed storm.
For now, the Knicks still look built to matter. Maybe not untouchable.
Maybe not the obvious favorite. But with Brunson, Towns, Anunoby, Hart and Bridges still together, they remain one of the few teams in the East with a path all the way through.
In Other News...
Knicks And Karl-Anthony Towns Now Face A Real Long-Term Problem
Karl-Anthony Towns and the Knicks have spent the summer in extension talks, but the conversation has not produced a deal. New York has decided to set those discussions aside for now and shift its attention to the upcoming season, leaving the veteran big man in a familiar holding pattern as the team tries to keep its focus on the court.
Towns has made clear he wants to stay in New York, but the organization has not shown urgency to lock anything in, and the two sides remain apart on the terms. With the season approaching, the absence of movement adds a little more intrigue to a situation that was supposed to be straightforward, and it leaves the long-term picture murkier than either side likely wanted. [Read more 🡒]
Landry Shamet Is Putting Real Pressure On A Knicks Role Battle
Landry Shamet came to the Knicks on an Exhibit 9 deal in September 2024, and he has turned that low-profile signing into something much more meaningful. He has carved out real rotation minutes, and his preseason work has only strengthened the case that he belongs in the mix when New York starts sorting through the back end of its guard rotation.
The bigger issue now is where that leaves the teams sixth-man conversation and Miles McBrides spot in the pecking order. Shamets steady play has added another layer to a group that already needed clarity, and if he keeps forcing the issue, the Knicks may have a tougher decision than they expected as they weigh how to balance immediate production with long-term roster flexibility. [Read more 🡒]
Jalen Brunson Addresses Knicks Tension Around Two Key Starters
The Knicks have put a pause on extension talks with two of their most important starters, Karl-Anthony Towns and Josh Hart, as the team shifts its attention to getting ready for the upcoming season. A team spokesperson said the conversations will pick back up later in the year, which leaves both players in a familiar holding pattern even as they remain central pieces of the roster.
Jalen Brunson tried to steady the moment by emphasizing that everyone in the room understands the job in front of them and will stay professional no matter where contract discussions stand. For a team trying to build on its expectations, the timing is delicate, but Brunsons message was clear enough: the Knicks plan to keep the focus on basketball first, even with a couple of important decisions still waiting in the background. [Read more 🡒]