Knicks Still Have One Young Roster Dilemma To Settle

As training camp approaches, the Knicks face critical decisions on key players that could shape their upcoming season and future success.

The Knicks may have most of their roster sorted out with training camp drawing near, but a few real questions still hang over the team. The biggest unfinished item is a third center. After that, the spotlight shifts to a trio of wild cards: Mo Diawara, Pacôme Dadiet and Deuce McBride.

Diawara is the most intriguing of the group because the Knicks already rewarded his strong stretch late last season with a four-year, $11.2 million deal. From Dec. 18 through the end of the regular season, he shot 37.1% from three and made his mark with on-ball defense.

Over that 52-game stretch, New York outscored opponents by 7.3 points per 100 possessions with Diawara on the court and posted a 111.2 DRTG. Corner threes were falling too, and he hit 57.6% of them in that span.

But that momentum never carried into the playoffs. Diawara barely touched the rotation, and his postseason minutes came in garbage time.

Summer League was supposed to give him a bigger stage, but instead it brought a rough two-game showing in Vegas. He had trouble handling the ball, finishing at the rim and creating his own shot. Diawara scored just seven points while shooting 7.1% from the field, going 1-of-14, before a finger issue ended his run.

Even so, there’s no reason for Knicks fans to panic. He still may not be ready to help in a real rotation this season, and Summer League is not the place to draw sweeping conclusions. The bigger question is how he responds after that rough showing, especially now that he’s on a four-year extension and carrying more expectations.

The Knicks don’t need Diawara to become a creator right away. They already have enough ball-handlers to cover that job.

What matters is whether he keeps defending at a level that gets him onto the floor. From there, the hope is that his game keeps growing the way it did last season.

Dadiet is a different story. The former first-round pick also had a rough Summer League, and at this point he still hasn’t shown much reason to believe he’s an NBA rotation player. In the G League with Westchester, he put up 19.2 points per game in 29 games with a 62.4% TS%, but none of that has translated to the NBA level.

For some time now, Dadiet has looked like a name more likely to show up in trade chatter than in a real Knicks plan. He’s been included in mock deals for rotation help this offseason, and his main value is tied to salary matching.

New York holds a team option worth about $5.3 million for the 2027-28 season, and that decision has to come by Halloween this year. If the Knicks can use that contract to improve the roster in 2026-27, they should think hard about it. But there’s also a case for keeping him around until that expiring money becomes useful later.

That’s where the salary mechanics matter. With the Knicks staying under the second apron after letting Mitchell Robinson and Ariel Hukporti leave for conference rivals, they can still aggregate salaries.

If they manage to avoid the second apron for all of 2026-27, Dadiet could become a young, movable $5.3 million contract. Beyond that, his outlook is pretty straightforward: it feels more like a question of when New York sends him out than if.

Then there’s McBride, whose upcoming season could shape a lot of what comes next. He missed half of 2025-26 because of an ankle injury and then a core issue that required surgery, yet it still became a career year. McBride averaged 12.0 points per game and shot 41.3% from three.

The playoffs told a more uneven story. His shooting dropped to 33.3% from the field, and Mike Brown trimmed his minutes from 26.3 per game in the regular season to 17.6 in the postseason. Even so, New York was electric with him in the 2026 playoffs, outscoring opponents by 20.8 points per 100 possessions with a 126.5 ORTG.

The Finals, though, were a different animal. McBride played about 13 minutes per game and the Knicks were 2.5 points per 100 possessions better without him on the floor than with him.

What still stands out is how much he lifts the team around him. Since the start of the 2025-26 season, the Knicks have been 5.6 points per 100 possessions better with McBride on the floor, according to PbP Stats. His fit alongside Jalen Brunson has helped both sides of the ball since he became a key part of the rotation.

There were moments over the last two seasons when people wanted him starting over Josh Hart or Mikal Bridges, but Brown showed the Knicks can win with the current starting group. That leaves McBride in a bench role.

His contract makes the next decision even more important. McBride signed a three-year, $13 million deal after the Knicks traded Immanuel Quickley to the Raptors in the OG Anunoby trade, and it expires after the 2026-27 season. He’s in line for a major raise, likely in the $15 million to $20 million range per year, and the Knicks probably won’t be able to pay that and keep building a contender.

That leaves a difficult choice. New York benefits from having McBride, but keeping him beyond this season may be what forces the issue. If the Knicks do decide to move him, a young, affordable player such as Yves Missi on the Pelicans could be the kind of return that makes sense.

In Other News...

OG Anunoby Could Unlock A More Dangerous Knicks Offense

OG Anunoby has already changed the Knicks look on one end, giving them the kind of length, strength and discipline that can make possessions miserable for opponents. The broader question now is what happens if that same level of force shows up more often on offense, where his physical tools should translate just as well when he is attacking instead of waiting to be found.

There is a reason the idea matters for New York. Anunoby has shown he can absorb contact and stay balanced against hard defense, which makes him a natural fit for a more assertive role in the scoring mix. If he starts taking more proactive chances with the ball and putting pressure on defenses earlier in possessions, the Knicks could become harder to load up against and a lot less predictable when the game tightens. [Read more 🡒]

Josh Hart Gives Knicks A Tough Decision In Their Biggest Moments

Josh Hart has become one of the Knicks most useful players because he does a little bit of everything the roster asks for. He can rebound, defend multiple spots and help move the offense along as a secondary playmaker, which is why his value tends to show up most clearly when games get tight and possessions get heavier. For a team that has spent so much time leaning on effort and versatility, Hart fits the identity almost too well.

Still, the Knicks also have to think about the bigger picture with him now that the roster is deeper and the roles are more defined than they were before. Hart remains the kind of player you want on the floor when the game is on the line, but the challenge is making sure he gets there fresh enough to matter most. The balance is no longer about whether he belongs in those moments, but how carefully the Knicks should manage him so he can keep swinging them. [Read more 🡒]

Knicks Guard Battle Just Took A Turn That Helps Tyler Kolek

The Knicks' guard picture got a little more interesting with Jack Kayil heading to Alba Berlin on a five-year deal, a move that keeps the 2026 draft pick overseas for now and gives New York one fewer immediate piece to sort through. For a team that already has to manage a crowded backcourt, it is the kind of development that can quietly ripple through the rest of the roster discussion, especially when every available spot and rotation minute matters.

Tyler Kolek sits closer to the center of that conversation than he did a few days ago. Mike Brown has already shown a willingness to trust Kolek in meaningful moments even with the defensive concerns that come with his game, and that kind of faith can matter in a competition where opportunities are never handed out freely. For all the help this opens up on the guard side, it also leaves New York with another decision looming as it weighs how best to balance the backcourt against bigger needs elsewhere. [Read more 🡒]