Knicks Slow Start Is Putting Mike Browns Biggest Lineup Call Under Pressure

Coach Mike Brown faces a critical decision as the New York Knicks' starting lineup falters amidst a challenging early season, sparking discussions of potential changes to regain their championship form.

The Knicks keep winning just enough to keep the panic from fully taking over, but the bigger issue hasn’t gone away. At 7-6, they’re still searching for the version of themselves that looked like a champion last season, and too often they’re spending the night digging out of holes instead of setting the tone.

Sunday’s overtime comeback against the Toronto Raptors fit the pattern perfectly. New York erased a 13-point fourth-quarter deficit to stay above .500, but the result didn’t exactly settle the bigger debate. It only bought Mike Brown a little more breathing room while the same question keeps hanging over the season: why doesn’t this starting five work better?

The current group - Jalen Brunson, Mikal Bridges, Josh Hart, OG Anunoby and Karl-Anthony Towns - is now in Year 3, and the early returns look a lot like the first two seasons: underwhelming. The Knicks’ starting five is a -22 in 127 minutes this season, which works out to -8.4 per 100 possessions.

That comes after two years of modest regular-season results from the same unit. And yet, the playoff version of this lineup has been a different story entirely.

Last year, that five-man group posted a +63 in 263 postseason minutes, good for a 12.5 net rating. In the Finals, it was even better, with a 21.8 net rating in 58 minutes.

The simplest explanation for the slow start is also the most obvious one: the shots aren’t falling. Brunson is at a 50% eFG, which would be the worst mark of his career.

Bridges is at 43.2%. Anunoby is at 48.1%.

Hart is down at 41.4%, and he hasn’t made a shot in two games.

“Make-or-miss league” rings especially true when 80% of a starting lineup are in shooting slumps.

That doesn’t mean the starting five is the only reason the Knicks have stumbled out of the gate. But when the roster is built around that group financially, and that group keeps logging major minutes, it’s fair to ask why the results still aren’t better.

Brown has been clear that he views his starting lineup as fixed, with the rest of the rotation more open to change from night to night. He hasn’t made a habit of moving away from that group when things get rocky.

Still, the recent language around Landry Shamet suggests the door isn’t completely closed. Brown has described Shamet’s rotation role as nearly as secure as the starters’, and he currently ranks fifth on the team in minutes per game.

Outside of Towns, there’s a case that Shamet has been the Knicks’ second-best player so far.

The numbers back that up in a hurry. With Shamet replacing Hart in the starting five, the Knicks are plus-17 per 100 possessions.

With Shamet in Bridges’ spot, they’ve posted a 39.2 net rating, though that comes in just 19 minutes. Miles McBride has also given the group a lift in smaller looks.

The Brunson-McBride-Shamet-Anunoby-Towns lineup has a 21.7 net rating in 23 minutes.

Brown has to be aware of that. After 114 games, he’s seen enough to know there’s at least some upside in trying a different look - especially in a season where New York would rather avoid spending so much energy clawing back into games. A stronger start would make life a lot easier.

The problem is that the obvious candidate to move is not so simple to move. Bridges is too important to treat lightly, even with his first two seasons in New York coming in fits and starts. Benching him would be a major story, and it could easily mess with his confidence while he’s already in a rough patch.

Hart is the cleaner basketball answer, but that comes with its own complications. He’s an emotional leader and one of the team’s glue pieces, the kind of player who does plenty of the dirty work that helps a team function.

He has also made it clear before that he doesn’t want to come off the bench. He did it willingly in the 2025 Eastern Conference Finals, but that was a different situation entirely, with the Knicks on the brink.

And it’s hard to forget what happened when Hart missed three weeks last season. From late December to mid-January, New York went 4-5 and looked flat.

That’s why Brown isn’t making the move yet. There’s enough evidence to question this starting five, but there’s also enough proof that it can still work when the pressure rises. The Knicks are only 13 official games removed from a championship, and a change this big could easily be viewed as an overreaction, especially with so many of the key pieces stuck in shooting slumps.

Still, the clock is ticking. New York has a difficult stretch coming over the next two weeks before the schedule eases a bit in mid-December. The Raptors, Minnesota Timberwolves, Indiana Pacers, Cleveland Cavaliers and Miami Heat are all on deck, and slipping below .500 is very much in play.

So the starting five gets more time. But not unlimited time. Brown has to keep weighing whether a different opening group might be the better way to get this team rolling before the calendar turns.

In Other News...

Knicks Fans Are Split Over Tyler Koleks Latest Team Hype Moment

The Knicks have leaned into Tyler Koleks profile lately, and their social media team found a fresh way to do it after Robert Pattinson was announced as the next James Bond. New York posted a comparison tying Koleks look to Pattinsons Bond-era image, a lighthearted move that fit the kind of online banter teams use to keep a role player in the conversation.

Fans, though, did not land on the same page. Kolek is in his third NBA season and has been getting minutes because of a teammates injury, so the post arrived at a time when he is already drawing more attention than usual. Some supporters enjoyed the joke, while others were less sold, giving the latest Knicks hype moment the kind of split reaction that tends to follow anything the team puts out on social media. [Read more 🡒]

Knicks Win Raised Two Big Questions Fans Cant Ignore

Josh Hart was right in the middle of the Knicks surge, making key plays during a 19-0 run that flipped the game late in the second quarter and gave New York the lead. It was the kind of stretch that can change the tone of a night, especially for a team still sorting through what its rotation is supposed to look like around the margins.

One of those margins is the backup point guard spot, where Jose Alvarado and Tyler Kolek have offered different looks in recent games and left the Knicks weighing what they need most behind the starters. Another is the next matchup with Toronto, where the defensive assignment gets tricky fast with Scottie Barnes and Collin Murray-Boyles creating problems in different ways, making the margin for error feel awfully thin. [Read more 🡒]

Knicks Just Found A Dangerous New Way To Use Karl-Anthony Towns

Karl-Anthony Towns gave the Knicks a glimpse of just how many problems he can create in the half court during an overtime win over the Raptors, scoring 28 points and pulling down 17 rebounds while making shots from different spots on the floor late in the game. It was the kind of performance that reminded everyone why his versatility matters so much in New York, especially when the offense needs a reliable way to bend a defense without becoming predictable.

The next meeting with Toronto should give the Knicks another chance to lean into that flexibility, with Towns and Jalen Brunson offering a pair of pressure points the Raptors have to account for on every possession. If New York can keep moving Towns around the floor and force Toronto to choose between helping on him or staying attached to Brunson, the Knicks may have found a cleaner path to generating the kind of offense that travels. [Read more 🡒]