The Knicks didn’t just walk away from extension talks with Karl-Anthony Towns, Josh Hart, and Miles McBride. They also walked straight into a mess of speculation that’s now hanging over the team, and it’s hard to ignore how much noise that has created around a reigning champion trying to defend its title.
The lack of new deals isn’t the whole story behind what’s gone wrong in New York. But it has clearly added another layer of uncertainty, and that uncertainty is starting to show up in the conversation around the roster - and, possibly, in Josh Hart’s game.
Hart has become the clearest example. He’s the emotional center of these Knicks, and right now he’s stuck in a rough stretch that looks ugly on the stat sheet.
He’s shooting a career low on twos, on threes, and from the free-throw line. In New York’s loss to the Indiana Pacers, he didn’t score at all and didn’t play in the fourth quarter.
It’s easy enough to point to the injuries. Hart has already missed time with an ankle injury, then an illness, and he was also dealing with a calf injury in September. But after the Pacers game, he made it clear the issue is bigger than that.
“Wish I could tell you [why],” he explained, per Stefan Bondy of the New York Post. “Don’t know.
Right now I’m not in a good headspace, and I’ve got to figure out how to improve that. And improve my play.”
That doesn’t prove the extension talks are the reason for his struggles. It would be a leap to say that outright.
Still, Hart has already acknowledged that his future can become a distraction, and in his case that makes sense. His situation is very different from Towns’.
Towns has a player option for next season, which gives him far more control. At the worst, he could pick it up and make $61 million.
Hart’s setup is much less secure. He has a $22.4 million team option, which means the Knicks hold the cards.
They could move on from him next summer, and maybe even before then at the trade deadline.
Meanwhile, Towns has opened the season playing at a level that’s hard to ignore. That kind of start usually helps a player’s standing. In this case, it may only raise the cost of keeping him around.
And once that happens, the rumor mill starts looking for someone else to target. For a while, Miles McBride was the name that kept coming up as the possible odd man out. Now Mikal Bridges’ early-season slump has pushed him into that same kind of trade chatter, with proposals floating around that would let the Knicks keep Towns while creating flexibility elsewhere.
That conversation isn’t going away. Neither is the speculation around McBride. If the Knicks don’t change course, Hart’s name figures to get pulled into it too.
Towns could end up in the rumor mill as well, even if he’s too important for the Knicks to seriously consider moving. The longer he goes without an extension, the more people will talk about other teams trying to chase him in the summer, or even at the trade deadline.
None of those hypotheticals may carry much weight on their own. But together, they add up to a constant distraction for a team that doesn’t need any more of them.
By shutting down in-season extension talks, the Knicks created this situation themselves. It’s far too early to say whether that was a fatal mistake.
What’s clear now is that closing the door has not made their title defense any easier.
In Other News...
Knicks Fans Have Every Reason To Question Jose Alvarados Role
Jose Alvarados return from an ankle injury was supposed to give the Knicks another usable guard option, but for nearly two weeks he has been stuck on the margins. In recent games, his appearances have come only in garbage time, while Mike Brown has continued to tinker with his rotations and look at other combinations as the team settles into the season.
Pacme Dadiet even got a brief look against the Indiana Pacers, which only sharpened the question around Alvarados place in the mix. When a player is healthy enough to dress but not trusted with meaningful minutes, it usually says something about where the coaching staff sees him right now, and Knicks fans have every reason to wonder what comes next. [Read more 🡒]
Knicks Deadline Hunt For A Towns Backup Just Got Tougher
The Knicks have spent the early part of the season looking for a sturdier answer behind Karl-Anthony Towns, but the search is getting harder by the day. New York does not have a lot of trade ammunition to work with, and the financial side of the equation only narrows the path further as the deadline approaches.
Now there is another wrinkle. Recent reporting around NBA lottery reform suggests fewer teams may be willing to move useful players, especially centers who can actually help a contender, which could tighten the market even more. For a Knicks front office already trying to thread the needle on cost and fit, that means the backup-center hunt may turn into a waiting game with plenty of competition and not many clean options. [Read more 🡒]
Josh Harts Slump Is Becoming A Real Knicks Problem
Josh Harts recent stretch has become hard to ignore for the Knicks, especially with the team trying to keep its offense and energy level steady. He has gone scoreless in back-to-back games, and Hart has openly acknowledged that the issue is not just physical, but mental as well. For a player whose value often comes from doing the little things and helping set the tone, that kind of skid stands out.
The Knicks have other encouraging signs around them, including Karl-Anthony Towns pointing to conditioning changes as part of his own improved play, but Harts drop-off is a problem that could linger if it does not turn quickly. New York needs his usual edge back, because when Hart is engaged and productive, the whole rotation tends to look more stable. Right now, though, the concern is less about one bad night and more about whether this slump is starting to settle in. [Read more 🡒]
