Mitchell Robinson’s first preseason look in Boston gave the Celtics something to work with, but not enough to turn the old Knicks debate into a slam dunk.
He opened against Philadelphia on Saturday with six points, five rebounds and 14 minutes. That’s a useful start for Boston, not evidence that the availability issues that followed him in New York have suddenly disappeared.
Robinson has made it clear he wants more freedom to play, and that’s fair. What isn’t fair is using that wish as a retroactive indictment of how the Knicks managed him.
New York had a simple priority: get him on the floor when it mattered most. By the end, that mission paid off.
The latest round of conversation didn’t come from a fresh Sunday interview. Robinson’s comments about playing back-to-backs came in a September 28 Knicks Fan TV interview with CP The Fanchise. They resurfaced Thursday, sparking the usual split between those looking at Boston’s approach and those remembering how New York handled his workload.
There’s nothing wrong with questioning the idea. There is a big difference between saying he wants to play more and proving the Knicks mishandled him. That proof isn’t in the public record.
If anything, Robinson’s final game for New York is the strongest reminder of why the Knicks were cautious. In the championship-clinching win over San Antonio, he logged 20 minutes and grabbed 10 rebounds, including six on the offensive glass.
He wasn’t asked to score much, and he didn’t need to. He still helped deliver the season’s biggest win.
That’s the tradeoff New York was making all along. The Knicks wanted his rebounding and rim presence when the games got heavy in June, and they got it. It’s hard to argue with that outcome just because fans would have preferred to see him in a few more regular-season games along the way.
None of that means every decision was flawless. Players can feel ready to go while teams take the safer route, and sitting out comes with real costs: fewer reps, uneven conditioning and plenty of frustration. Those complaints deserve to be heard, not brushed off.
Still, medical and coaching choices aren’t made off a quote and a stat line. Saturday’s 14-minute preseason stint tells us Robinson played a solid exhibition game. It does not tell us how he’ll hold up in January on consecutive nights.
Boston is free to take a different approach, and maybe it will work. Health changes, training changes and different staffs can all lead to different conclusions. If Robinson ends up playing more and staying available, good for him.
But that doesn’t mean the Celtics have to be the standard the Knicks should have followed. The smarter way to view it is simple: judge Boston’s plan on what happens next, and remember what New York got when it mattered most.
Knicks fans can appreciate Robinson’s role in that June run without pretending a hopeful new situation in Boston proves the old one was wrong.
In Other News...
Knicks Have An Early Problem Fans Already Find Frustrating
The preseason is only a tune-up, but the concerns around the Knicks are starting to look familiar already. Minnesota walked into Madison Square Garden and left with a 122-104 win, pushing New York deeper into an 0-3 start while the Timberwolves continued to look sharper in exhibition play. For a Knicks team trying to build momentum before the games count, the latest showing added another layer of unease.
What stood out most was the gap in how the two teams handled the perimeter game, with Minnesota finding a rhythm that New York could not match. The Timberwolves got strong production from Anthony Edwards, who set the tone throughout the night, and the Knicks never quite found a way to answer as the margin widened. At this point, the frustration is less about one preseason loss and more about how quickly an early-season issue can start to feel like a trend. [Read more 🡒]
Knicks Preseason Loss Put Several Rotation Hopefuls Under Pressure
The Knicks third preseason game offered a familiar split screen: the main rotation pieces looked largely ready, while the fringe spots in the lineup still feel wide open. Jalen Brunson and OG Anunoby again gave New York the kind of stable minutes the team wants to see in October, with both veterans setting the tone in a game that also served as a useful stress test for the rest of the roster.
For players trying to hang onto a role, the pressure is starting to sharpen. Landry Shamet and Mohamed Diawara had quieter nights, and several others either flashed a little progress or ran into the same old issue of inefficient shooting. In a preseason stretch like this, the Knicks are not just looking for talent, but for who can fit cleanly around the established core when the games start to count. [Read more 🡒]
Knicks Banner Night Could Reignite A Debate Fans Already Feel
Opening night at Madison Square Garden will bring a familiar kind of pageantry, with the Knicks set to raise their 2025-26 NBA championship banner before facing the 76ers. It is the kind of moment the franchise has waited decades to stage, and it will give fans a first look at how the organization chooses to frame a season that ended with a title, an NBA Cup victory and an Eastern Conference championship.
What remains unsettled is how much of that success will get permanent recognition in the rafters. The team has not said whether banners for the NBA Cup or the East crown will join the championship banner, even though owner James Dolan had previously signaled the club would honor the league title rather than the in-season tournament win. So when the lights come up on Oct. 20, part of the conversation may be less about the opponent than about exactly how many new banners are on display. [Read more 🡒]