The Knicks still have a little offseason business left, but the heavy lifting is done. Unless New York makes a surprise swing for a blockbuster trade - the kind that brought in Karl-Anthony Towns just days before preseason - the remaining work looks more like the back end of the roster, probably with a third-string center.
That makes this a good time to sort through the summer’s moves and stack them from least impactful to most valuable. The Knicks did not make a huge number of additions, but the ones they did make all fit into a team that is clearly built with bigger goals in mind.
At the bottom of the list is Jordan Clarkson, though calling it the “worst” move feels harsher than it should. It’s more a matter of fit and importance than quality.
Clarkson opened the season slowly and inconsistently, lost some ground in the rotation, then remade himself into something different midway through the year. He went from scoring-first spark plug to a more complete reserve, defending harder and crashing the offensive glass at a level that stood out for a guard, while still giving New York points.
Even so, his role could be less stable now with a full year of Jose Alvarado, Landry Shamet’s return, and the expected growth of Mohamed Diawara. That makes Clarkson’s place in the pecking order less certain than some of the other returning pieces. Still, for a team chasing back-to-back championships, keeping a veteran who can handle a defined role at his price point is hardly a mistake.
The Knicks also drew plenty of heat for the way they handled draft night, when they traded down instead of making a first-round pick. Fans wanted a shot at a backup center or a young wing in a draft class viewed as loaded with high-end talent and useful depth. Instead, the front office chose flexibility over immediate upside.
That frustration made sense in the moment, but the logic is easier to see now. New York did not know how much it would take to bring back Alvarado and Shamet, so preserving every dollar mattered.
If a draft pick had cost them one of those key returnees, that would have been a painful outcome for a contending team. And the Knicks did not leave the draft empty-handed anyway.
Jack Kayil showed some intriguing ability at Summer League, though he likely needs more seasoning before he’s ready for the NBA. Nickel may have a lower ceiling than Kayil, but his shooting and defensive effort could get him on the floor sooner, possibly even this season.
He probably won’t log the kind of minutes a rookie big man might have, but his movement shooting could give New York a different look.
Andre Drummond lands next, and the comparison to Mitchell Robinson is unavoidable because he is the direct replacement. But that comparison only goes so far.
Drummond is coming in on a much cheaper contract and brings a different skill set. He will not match Robinson’s defensive ceiling or his finishing around the rim, but if he keeps producing elite rebounding and tightens up his shot selection, he can be a very usable backup center during the regular season.
The postseason is another story. There is a real chance Drummond either barely plays or doesn’t play at all when the games tighten up.
The idea that he is the long-term answer for those backup center minutes in the playoffs is not something worth buying into. As long as that remains the case, the move looks fine.
If Leon Rose somehow starts treating Drummond as the only solution, the grade changes quickly.
Keeping Mohamed Diawara around is a bigger win. The Knicks held onto a player who flashed real promise as a rookie, and they did it on a four-year contract that won’t even push his salary past $3 million until 2029-30. That kind of value matters.
Diawara’s rough Summer League reminded everyone he still has plenty to prove, even after signing his first major NBA deal. But the upside is obvious if he develops into a true three-and-D player, and his playmaking gives him a chance to become even more than that if his game keeps moving forward.
Jose Alvarado checks in as one of the most important returns. One of New York’s biggest issues last season was ball handling beyond Jalen Brunson.
The roster had secondary and tertiary options, but not many who could reliably bring the ball up and organize an offense against aggressive pressure defenses like the Thunder and Spurs. Alvarado solves that problem.
He won’t pile up huge numbers, but his energy, defense, and ability to keep the offense moving make him a useful piece on a team loaded with talent elsewhere. He also gets a full training camp to deepen his fit with the group. Like the other returning bench pieces, Alvarado was a major part of the Knicks’ title run, and bringing him back at a team-friendly price looks like strong business.
At the top of the list is Landry Shamet. He had some rough moments in the Finals, but over the full postseason he was the most important bench player New York had, and maybe the most important reserve all season.
Shamet just put together arguably the best season of his career, becoming a better shooter and an even better defender. When healthy, he consistently hit timely threes and battled through tough, physical assignments on defense.
The report that he turned down better offers from other contenders only makes the Knicks’ win here look bigger. The trust went both ways.
Considering the contracts signed by players like Kevin Huerter, Dean Wade, and Keon Ellis, New York came out ahead. Shamet should again thrive as a three-and-D specialist who can also start if needed.
In Other News...
Josh Hart Is At The Center Of The Knicks' Next Cap Squeeze
Josh Harts contract has become one of the more important little financial threads running through the Knicks future. He is in the third season of a four-year, $80.9 million extension, and the path that got him there already included a sacrifice in 2023, when he opted into the final year of his previous deal so New York could use the full mid-level exception and keep building around the roster it wanted.
That flexibility helped the Knicks land Donte DiVincenzo, who later became a major part of the teams next wave of moves, and Harts deal still carries a $22.4 million team option for 2027-28. With New York always looking for ways to manage the cap while keeping its core intact, Hart sits right at the center of the next squeeze, even if the clubs broader hope is to find savings elsewhere. [Read more 🡒]
Jason Williams Just Hit The Sixers With A Brutal Reality Check
Jason Williams is already looking past the 76ers and seeing a tougher climb in the Eastern Conference than Philadelphia might want to hear. The former NBA guard said he expects the Knicks, Heat and Magic to finish ahead of Philly in the 2026-27 season, a blunt assessment that cuts against the buzz surrounding the Sixers offseason and the idea that they should be rising back toward contention.
Williams skepticism centered on whether the roster has enough bite where it matters most, especially on defense and the glass. It also puts him on the opposite side of the optimism that followed LeBron James decision to join Philadelphia, since James clearly views the Sixers as the best path to winning, while Williams is still waiting to see whether the pieces around him can support that belief. [Read more 🡒]
Knicks Fans Can't Ignore This Pacers Threat To The East Race
The Knicks have spent the summer trying to keep their own title window open by bringing back most of their 2026 championship roster, even with Mitchell Robinson gone from the mix. That kind of continuity matters in the East, where the margin between a deep playoff run and a tough bracket can be razor thin, and it also means New York is entering the season with a familiar core and familiar expectations.
Indiana is one of the teams that makes that path look less straightforward. With Tyrese Haliburton, Pascal Siakam and Rick Carlisle still in place, the Pacers have the kind of stability and roster depth that can punish any slip in the race for homecourt advantage, especially if their supporting cast keeps growing into bigger roles. For the Knicks, the message is simple enough: if they want to stay near the top of the conference, they cannot treat the Pacers like a background team. [Read more 🡒]