Pacome Dadiet has become more than a young wing with a shaky trade market. He’s turned into a reminder of just how many cleaner, more useful options were sitting there when the Knicks made the No. 25 pick in 2024.
That’s not a plea to rewrite the past. New York liked Dadiet because he was willing to sign for 80 percent of the rookie scale - $1.8 million in Year 1 instead of the usual $2.7 million - and that kind of flexibility has mattered. It helped the Knicks stay under the second apron and even enabled moves like the Mikal Bridges trade.
But the financial upside doesn’t erase the basketball miss. The Knicks won a title, so nobody has to apologize for anything. Still, there were better players and better fits available, and the list gets uglier the deeper you go.
Kyshawn George is the first gut punch. The Knicks actually held the pick used on him at No. 24 before trading it for No. 26, where they took Dillon Jones, plus a second-rounder.
New York then flipped No. 26 for a package of seconds. George wasn’t going to take Dadiet’s cheaper rookie deal, but the gap wasn’t exactly massive - he made about $1 million more as a rookie and is set to earn only $100,000 more in 2026-27.
His size, shooting, defense, and improving playmaking would fit neatly with the Knicks’ current Wingstop trio.
Terrence Shannon Jr. is another name that stings. He never had a huge role with the Timberwolves, but he brings downhill pressure, has shown some shooting, and plays with defensive bite. On a Knicks bench that currently has only one playable wing taller than 6’5” in Mohamed Diawara, Shannon would be a useful piece, especially if the team wanted someone who could slide into undersized power forward minutes.
Then comes the one that may hurt the most: Ajay Mitchell. New York passed on him four times - at No.
24, No. 25, No. 34 when it took Tyler Kolek, and again at No. 38, when Mitchell finally went to Oklahoma City.
The Knicks traded that pick for No. 40 and cash. Salary doesn’t explain this one away anymore, and using No. 34 on Kolek, who plays the same position, doesn’t really solve it either.
Mitchell began on a two-way deal and has grown into a top rotation player on a championship team. His three-point shot is still inconsistent, but he’s a steady handler, a smart playmaker, a mid-range problem, and a defender who can survive switches.
That one clearly hurts.
Jaylen Wells is another brutal what-if. A 6’7” wing who costs less than Dadiet, shoots it well enough from deep, and consistently takes on tough perimeter assignments?
That’s the kind of player New York could use right now. And the pain only grows when you look ahead: the Knicks will eventually have to decide on Dadiet’s $5.4 million team option for 2027-28, while Wells is on the books for just $2.5 million.
The Knicks also had another shot at a better fit in the second round. They got No. 40 in the Mitchell deal, then sent it to Phoenix for No. 56 and another second.
That pick became Kevin McCullar Jr., but Oso Ighodaro was there at No. 40.
The obvious knock on Ighodaro is that he isn’t much of a rebounder and doesn’t project as a shooter. Even so, he brings defensive versatility, strong screening, smart passing, strong finishing at the rim, and a clear ability to lift his team while he’s on the floor.
Without the Mark Williams injury in Phoenix, the case for him as a Knicks target would be even louder. And if New York hadn’t done so much dealing in 2024, he might already be backing up Karl-Anthony Towns instead of Andre Drummond.
Pelle Larsson at No. 44 is another name that belongs in the conversation. The shot is a question, sure, but he can handle the ball, create offense, and get to the line at a Jimmy Butler-ian rate. With his size, he might be the most frustrating second-round what-if of the bunch.
And then there’s Cam Spencer at No. 53, another player the Knicks never got to seriously consider in the way they should have. Quinten Post at No. 52 is part of the same general sliding-doors story, though he wasn’t on anyone’s radar at the time. Jamal Shead went at No. 45, but the Knicks already have a better version of that type in Deuce McBride.
Spencer, though, has lived up to the billing. The shooting is real, the physicality is real, and the secondary ball-handling has translated. In fact, the production has gotten so loud that he now belongs in a tiny club of players over the past two years averaging at least 20 points, 10 assists, and four made threes per 100 possessions: LaMelo Ball, Luka Doncic, Darius Garland, James Harden, Tyrese Haliburton, and Cam Spencer.
In Other News...
Josh Hart Just Made His Knicks Contract Situation More Interesting
Josh Harts contract status came up at Knicks Media Day, and it was easy to understand why he wanted to address it now rather than let it linger. Entering a season where the roster expects to contend, Hart said he would prefer to have clarity before the 2026-27 campaign begins, a sensible stance for a player who has become a key part of New Yorks rotation and identity.
The bigger issue is less about the paperwork than the possible distraction if negotiations drag on. Hart acknowledged the kind of uncertainty that can creep in when extension talks remain open, and he made clear he does not want the situation hanging over the team for long. For the Knicks, it is another reminder that even in a focused locker room, contract questions can quickly become part of the conversation. [Read more 🡒]
Brunsons Knicks Reaction Made This Celtics Departure Feel Personal
Jalen Brunson has spent the early part of the Knicks summer acknowledging how much Mitchell Robinson meant to the group that reached the championship stage, while also turning the page toward what comes next. Robinsons departure leaves a real void in New Yorks frontcourt, and it is the kind of move that changes both the on-court rotation and the emotional feel of a locker room that had leaned on his presence.
Andre Drummond is now part of that answer, and Brunson sounded encouraged by what the veteran can bring to the mix. The Knicks do not have to wait long for the first test of the transition, either, with early-season matchups looming against the 76ers and Celtics, giving Drummond an immediate chance to settle in and see how New Yorks reshaped big-man group holds up against familiar competition. [Read more 🡒]
Knicks Created A Bigger Problem Than Just Replacing Mitchell Robinson
The Knicks decision to let Mitchell Robinson walk did more than change the center rotation. It also altered the tone around a team that had leaned on Robinsons rim protection and toughness, while bringing in Andre Drummond as a possible answer in the middle. From the outside, it looks like a straightforward roster move, but inside the building it has naturally raised questions about how the defense will hold up and how much of the frontcourt workload will shift to Karl-Anthony Towns.
What makes the move linger is that it is not being viewed as a one-for-one swap, either on the floor or in the bigger picture. The new setup has already fueled speculation about how New Yorks future performance might be affected, and it could even color contract talks down the line. For a team trying to stay in the mix, losing Robinson is not just about replacing a center, it is about managing the ripple effects that come with changing the structure of the roster. [Read more 🡒]