The Knicks’ biggest danger right now isn’t the second apron. It’s James Dolan.
That’s the blunt reality hanging over a team that just ended a 53-year championship drought and should be thinking about how to keep its core intact. Instead, the organization has already sent out a statement saying contract-extension talks with eligible players such as Karl-Anthony Towns, Josh Hart, Miles McBride and Tyler Kolek are being tabled.
On the surface, the second apron is the explanation. And sure, it matters.
Crossing it brings real roster restrictions, and no front office treats it lightly. But the idea that this is only about basketball economics misses the bigger problem: Dolan appears to be steering the conversation in a way that could shorten the life of a team that isn’t anywhere near its expiration date.
The timing is what makes this look so jarring. Four days after a title, the Knicks are effectively signaling they may not pay what it takes to keep the group together. That’s a brutal way to greet a championship window.
The more revealing part is how this got out. On an episode of the Katz and Shoot podcast, The Athletic’s James Edwards said people inside the organization “were blindsided” by Dolan’s comments. That matters because it points to a basic failure of communication between the owner and the front office that built the roster in the first place.
And that’s the part that keeps coming back with Dolan: he doesn’t just have money, he has a habit of getting in the way.
This is not a case where the Knicks are being forced into one narrow, unavoidable path. Entering the second apron is a serious decision, and even if New York had been willing to do it, the front office still might have decided that keeping Mitchell Robinson, a backup center with a checkered health bill, wasn’t worth it. Leon Rose and the staff also may not have approached Towns and Hart any differently.
But Dolan’s public stance changes the tone of everything. It turns what could have been a calculated basketball decision into a messy declaration that the team may not even consider the second apron at all.
Other owners don’t usually handle this kind of thing with such a loud, clumsy public message. Even teams that haven’t paid the second apron yet have shown they can live with it when the time is right.
Oklahoma City is one example. Thunder general manager Sam Presti has all but said the team moved players to avoid the second apron this season so it could time its entry for when Shai Gilgeous-Alexander’s salary rises in 2027-28.
That’s what makes the Knicks’ situation feel so self-defeating. It initially seemed like they were following a similar logic, buying time below the second apron until Jalen Brunson’s next deal kicks in during 2028-29. But Dolan’s words and actions have undercut that assumption.
The Knicks are here because of smart basketball decisions and some major breaks, not because of Dolan. Leon Rose pushed to land Brunson.
Dallas badly misread him. Brunson’s rise, and his decision to pass on 2025 free agency, changed everything.
Even the path to Towns was shaped in part by the second apron itself.
That’s what makes Dolan’s posture so galling. He acts as if he’s driving the car, when the reality is much messier. He’s also the same owner whose history with the franchise includes using the Knicks’ parade to throw political shade, saying yes to a White House visit without speaking to the people who mattered, continuing to link the team with Isiah Thomas, and allegedly turning Madison Square Garden into a surveillance state.
None of that means the Knicks should rush into every expensive deal or pretend the second apron is irrelevant. It isn’t.
The team is trying to balance a delicate payroll situation. But the way New York is handling it now looks less like careful planning and more like an owner once again making himself the story.
That’s the real warning sign. For years, the best thing you could say about Dolan was that he mostly stayed out of the way. Now he seems to be back in the middle of it.
And if this continues, the damage won’t just be financial or cosmetic. It could create real resentment inside the roster, including for Towns and Hart, no matter how many blue-and-orange heart emojis are flying around now. It also makes New York’s 2027-28 payroll harder to map out, because without knowing what Towns is making, the Knicks can’t clearly figure out where McBride or Hart fit in a below-second-apron plan.
In other words, a team that finally reached the mountaintop is now at risk of tripping over the owner’s own habits. The Knicks have a title window. Dolan is the one making it smaller.
In Other News...
Knicks Already Showing Something Fans Will Love Inside The Locker Room
The preseason results have not been kind so far, with the Knicks falling again to the Wizards and slipping to 0-2, but there was still a little something to like in the aftermath. Josh Hart and Jalen Brunson, who have built a longstanding friendship as teammates, brought some easygoing energy to a postgame media session that suggested the locker room mood is still loose even when the scoreboard is not.
For Mike Brown, that kind of chemistry matters as much as any exhibition loss in October, especially with time left to tweak the rotation before the regular season begins. The Knicks are still sorting out how they want to look when the games count, but between Hart and Brunson, there is already evidence of the kind of comfort and familiarity teams hope carries over once the schedule gets real. [Read more 🡒]
Knicks Came Surprisingly Close To Watching Jalen Brunson Become The Enemy
Jalen Brunsons rise in New York is already one of the franchises defining modern moves, but it almost looked very different before he ever signed with the Knicks. Brunson remains the lone NBA superstar to change teams via free agency this decade, and the path that brought him from Dallas to Manhattan was shaped by a chain of draft decisions and trade conversations that still echo through both organizations.
The Mavericks were weighing their options around the 2020 draft and had enough asset flexibility to make the kind of move that could have changed the leagues balance in a hurry. For the Knicks, the fascinating part is how close the story came to turning Brunson from the player who steadied their backcourt into something far less pleasant to deal with, with a different set of circumstances potentially sending his career and the rivalry in a completely different direction. [Read more 🡒]
Knicks May Finally Have A Real Way To Move On From Dadiet
Pacome Dadiets spot on the Knicks roster has become one of those quiet situations that tends to linger until a team finds the right lever to pull. New York has reasons to keep looking around, too. Dadiet has not given the club much on the floor, and the Knicks are always weighing ways to clear room, both on the roster and on the books, as they try to keep their flexibility intact.
The interesting part is that the Knicks now have more ways to grease a deal than they did not long ago. With extra future second-round picks in hand, they can make a modest trade more appealing if another team is willing to take a chance on Dadiet. Teams with cap room or trade exceptions can be part of that conversation, which opens the door to a handful of possible partners and leaves New York with a real path to moving on if it decides the time is right. [Read more 🡒]