Since Jalen Brunson touched down in New York back in 2022, he’s been carving out a legacy as one of the Knicks' brightest stars. His clutch performances and leadership on the court have fans and analysts buzzing, earning him comparisons to the legendary Walt Frazier from the 1970s.
Brunson's impact is so profound that he's often compared to Carmelo Anthony, the last superstar to electrify Madison Square Garden. While Melo's legacy is cemented with a Hall of Fame induction, Brunson's rapid rise through the Knicks' ranks has sparked a lively debate about their respective places in franchise history.
Former Knicks forward Tim Thomas recently weighed in on this discussion during an appearance on The Real Report. When asked who he believes has had a more impactful Knicks career, Thomas didn't hesitate to put Brunson ahead. He acknowledged Melo's illustrious overall career but emphasized Brunson's winning ways in New York.
"He's winning, and that's the bottom line," Thomas stated. While Melo dazzled with scoring and style, it’s Brunson’s success in the postseason that sets him apart. In a shorter span, Brunson has led the Knicks to deeper playoff runs, including their first Eastern Conference Finals appearance in 25 years, outshining Melo’s three playoff berths with only one advancing past the first round.
Statistically, Brunson has the edge too. Averaging 26.3 points, 6.7 assists, and boasting a better effective field goal percentage and box plus-minus, his numbers underscore his influence on the court. It’s clear that Brunson’s tenure with the Knicks is not just impressive-it's historic, and his star continues to rise in the Big Apple.