The Broderick Jones-Will McDonald debate was always a little too neat to be real, the kind of draft-day feud people love because it lets them turn one pick into a whole conspiracy. In the end, the story closed in the most Jets way possible: with New York looking smarter than the punchline.
A lot of the noise came from the idea that Bill Belichick and the New England Patriots somehow outplayed the Jets by trading down and letting the Pittsburgh Steelers grab Jones at No. 14 overall. But that version of events was built on assumption, not reality. McDonald was going to be the pick anyway, and between the two players, the Iowa State defensive end has been the better one.
That gap has only widened since then. The Steelers eventually traded Jones to the Dallas Cowboys after he failed to make Mike McCarthy's first 53-man roster, while McDonald has settled in as a major piece of Pittsburgh's revamped pass rush. If the Patriots were trying to embarrass the Jets, the final result did not land the way people imagined.
Jones’ Steelers tenure never really found its footing. He has been inconsistent from the start, and the Jets got a front-row look at it when McDonald and the rest of the defensive line handled him in Week 1 of the 2025 season. A neck injury only made things worse, and Pittsburgh’s willingness to spend first-round picks on offensive linemen like Troy Fautanu and Max Iheanachor while Jones was still on his rookie deal said plenty about how they viewed him.
McDonald, by contrast, has built a case as a player who will either land a solid multi-year contract in New York or earn that money from someone else looking for pass-rush help. He has his flaws, but he has also produced. With 18.5 sacks over two seasons, he has shown he can win off the edge with speed and pressure, even if he is not the franchise star the Jets once hoped for.
So the supposed showdown between Jones and McDonald never really produced a winner for the teams that inspired it. It just ended up underscoring the obvious: the Jets made the better choice, and the whole media-made rivalry was built on two players who were passed over for Christian Gonzalez, Jack Campbell, and Jaxon Smith-Njigba.
In Other News...
Jets Just Moved On From A Former First-Round Bet
Roster cutdown day brought another notable change to the Jets defensive front, with the team releasing defensive tackle Mazi Smith as it trimmed down to the 53-player limit. Smith, acquired in a trade from the Dallas Cowboys, had been a low-risk swing for New York after he saw action in three games last season, but the fit never fully developed as the roster and scheme evolved.
Smiths exit fits the broader direction of the Jets personnel moves, which have included a push to reshape the front seven around a new 3-4 look. New York also parted ways with quarterback Bailey Zappe as part of the final roster decisions, and the emphasis now is clearly on getting the right bodies in place up front before the regular season opens. [Read more 🡒]
Jets Make Another Quinnen Williams Trade Ripple On Defensive Line
The Quinnen Williams trade keeps sending little shocks through the Jets defensive front, and the latest came with the release of Mazi Smith. Smith was part of the package that went to New York in the deal with Dallas, and his short run with the Jets never really got much traction. He played in eight games last season, including three in green and white, and finished with three combined tackles.
His exit leaves the depth chart looking a little clearer for now. Harrison Phillips is expected to settle in as the starting defensive tackle, with TVondre Sweat in line at nose tackle and rookie Darrell Jackson Jr. behind them as a backup. It is the kind of reshuffling that comes with a major trade, and for the Jets it is another reminder that the ripple effects on the defensive line are still being felt. [Read more 🡒]
Jets Just Made A Surprising Call On A Preseason Standout
The Jets made an unexpected roster move by releasing edge rusher Nate Lynn, a player who flashed enough in the preseason to make a real case for sticking around. Signed shortly before the teams Week 2 preseason game, Lynn quickly turned heads with a team-high six pressures and three sacks across two exhibition appearances, the kind of production that usually gets a young pass rusher more runway.
Lynns release does not necessarily close the door on his time in New York. There is mutual interest in him returning to the Jets practice squad if he clears waivers, which gives this decision a very unfinished feel for now. For a team still sorting through its edge depth, Lynns strong summer showing makes him one of the more interesting names to watch in the aftermath. [Read more 🡒]