Quinnen Williams is doing exactly what the Cowboys brought him in to do. The problem is everything around him still looks broken.
Dallas has already made a major shift on defense, stripping Christian Parker of play-calling duties and handing that job to former Jets mastermind Mike Pettine. That move says plenty about where this unit stands after another rough outing, and it also sets up the strange reality of Williams’ new home: the star defensive tackle is producing at a high level while the defense keeps sinking anyway.
That’s the part that has to sting for Williams, because it feels awfully familiar. For much of his time with the Jets, outside of a few seasons under Robert Saleh, he played at a near-elite or outright elite level while the defense around him failed to turn his impact into wins. Now he’s in Dallas, and the script is eerily similar.
Per Pro Football Focus, Williams is fourth in the NFL in pressures among defensive tackles, behind only Alim McNeil, Byron Murphy II, and Zach Allen. He also leads the league in run stops by a wide margin, with almost 10 more than second-place Tommy Togiai. In other words, he has been everything the Cowboys could have hoped for, and then some.
And yet the Cowboys are still sitting near the bottom of the league defensively. After giving up 580 yards of offense in a home loss to the San Francisco 49ers, Dallas ranks at or near the bottom in just about every category that matters.
There are pieces here, too. Williams is making plays.
Rookie Caleb Downs is beginning to flash the kind of talent that made him a top pick. The pass rush has some future pieces as well.
But the overall product remains rough enough that the unit can look eye-bleedingly bad at times.
That’s what makes the Jets-Cowboys trade feel like a lose-lose so far. The Jets used the second-round pick they got from Dallas on D’Angelo Ponds, and he has struggled mightily.
Williams has been excellent. The defense around him has not.
There’s even another layer of Jets irony in all of this. Pettine is now calling the defense, Brian Schottenheimer is working on the offense, and Dallas looks a little too much like the 2010 Jets for comfort. Williams, who has still never played in a playoff game or on a team that finished with a winning record, is once again stuck starring for a team that can’t get out of its own way.
In Other News...
Jets Linked To Defensive Upgrades That Could Reshape Their 2027 Plans
The Jets are already looking ahead to a 2027 offseason that could give them the kind of flexibility every front office wants, with significant cap space and multiple first-round draft picks available to attack the defense. ESPN has pointed to defensive tackle Kobie Turner and cornerback DJ Turner as possible free-agent targets, both players who could become available if their current teams decide not to keep them around.
For a roster that still has clear needs up front and in the secondary, that kind of market could give New York a chance to reshape two important areas at once. The Jets are also expected to explore the draft for help at defensive tackle and cornerback, so the bigger picture is not just about one splash move but about how aggressively they want to use that 2027 flexibility to rebuild the defense. [Read more 🡒]
Jets Coaching Buzz Just Took A Wild Kevin OConnell Turn
The coaching chatter around the Jets has taken an unusual turn, with Minnesota Vikings head coach Kevin O'Connell now getting pulled into the conversation as a possible target. The buzz has centered on the idea of a trade to New York that could involve a high draft pick, which is the kind of price tag that instantly makes any coaching speculation feel more serious than the usual offseason noise.
What has helped fuel the talk is O'Connell's connection to Jets executive Darren Mougey, the two having been college teammates who have stayed in touch over the years. O'Connell has also spoken highly of Mougey's work with the Jets, adding another layer to the speculation, but for now there has been no official trade or agreement to point to. [Read more 🡒]
Sauce Gardner Trade Just Became A Brutal Colts Debate
Amazon Prime Video took a playful swing at the Sauce Gardner trade during the Colts-Texans broadcast, using a Grand Theft Auto VI graphic to suggest the Jets came out ahead in the deal. It was the kind of on-air jab that lands harder when the subject is still fresh, especially with Gardner now trying to settle in after a move that has already brought both uneven play and injury concerns.
For Indianapolis, the joke also arrived at an awkward time. The Colts are in the middle of major roster turnover and are headed for a sixth straight season without a playoff berth, so any conversation about the trade now folds into a bigger debate about where the franchise is going and whether this was a move that truly helped at all. [Read more 🡒]
