The New York Jets finally found themselves on the right side of a close one, edging out the Atlanta Falcons 27-24 at MetLife Stadium in Week 13. It’s a much-needed win for a Jets team that’s been searching for positives in a challenging season. But while the scoreboard showed a victory, the tape - and the analytics - tell a more nuanced story, especially on the offensive side of the ball.
Pro Football Focus dropped their postgame grades, offering a deeper dive into individual performances that go beyond the box score. And for the Jets’ offense, there were some clear areas of concern. Let’s break down the five lowest-graded offensive players from Sunday’s game, based on PFF’s evaluation (minimum eight snaps played).
5. Allen Lazard - WR
PFF Grade: 54.9
Lazard was brought in to be a reliable target and a physical presence on the outside, but this week’s performance didn’t quite hit the mark. His 54.9 grade reflects a quiet afternoon where separation was hard to come by and his impact in the passing game was minimal. For a veteran who’s expected to be a steadying force, this was a step back.
4. Josh Myers - OL
PFF Grade: 52.1
The offensive line has been a revolving door for the Jets all season, and Myers’ showing against Atlanta didn’t help stabilize things. With a grade just north of 50, his struggles in both run blocking and pass protection were evident. The Jets were able to put up points, but the interior pressure made it harder than it needed to be.
3. Isaiah Williams - WR
PFF Grade: 50.5
Williams has flashed at times this year, but this was not one of those games. His 50.5 grade suggests a lack of consistency in his routes and limited production when targeted. For a young receiver trying to carve out a role, these are the kinds of games that can slow momentum.
2. Armand Membou - OL
PFF Grade: 44.0
Membou had a tough day in the trenches. Whether it was handling stunts or anchoring against bull rushes, he struggled to hold his ground.
A 44.0 grade is a red flag, especially for a unit that’s been under the microscope all season. The Jets need more from their depth up front, and this outing didn’t inspire much confidence.
1. John Metchie III - WR
PFF Grade: 41.6
At the bottom of the list is Metchie, who had a game to forget. A 41.6 grade is indicative of a performance where little went right - from route execution to contested catches, the second-year wideout couldn’t get into rhythm. It’s a disappointing showing for a player with talent and upside, and the Jets will be hoping this was just a blip, not a trend.
While the Jets came away with the win, these grades highlight the ongoing inconsistencies on offense. The flashes are there - enough to squeak out victories - but the unit still has a long way to go if it wants to string together solid performances down the stretch.
Wins are always welcome, especially in a season like this. But the film doesn’t lie, and the Jets have plenty to clean up as they look to build on this momentum.