The first day of legal tampering in the NFL is always a whirlwind, but this year, the New York Jets took it to a new level. They made waves by adding six players to their defense, including the standout three-time All-Pro Minkah Fitzpatrick through a trade. However, it wasn’t all gains for the Jets, as they saw four players depart, notably losing two key guards: John Simpson and Alijah Vera-Tucker.
Simpson's exit leaves a glaring gap at left guard, a position the Jets will need to address, whether through free agency, the draft, or a combination of both. Meanwhile, Vera-Tucker's move to the New England Patriots, a division rival, stings less since he missed the previous season with a triceps injury. His departure was anticipated, and there were whispers that he wasn’t keen on returning to New York.
While keeping Simpson might have seemed logical, the Jets made a strategic choice to let him go. Simpson had been one of Joe Douglas’ standout acquisitions during his tenure as the Jets’ general manager, signing a two-year deal worth up to $18 million before the 2024 season.
He shone in his first year, earning a 77.3 overall grade from Pro Football Focus, ranking fourth among left guards. However, his performance dipped significantly in 2025, with his PFF grade dropping to 56.9, placing him 20th among his peers.
He allowed more pressures, committed more penalties, and gave up additional sacks compared to the previous year.
Despite his durability and leadership, the Jets, led by Darren Mougey, decided to let Simpson walk. Although he was projected to command around $6.5 million annually, Simpson secured a three-year, $30 million deal with the Baltimore Ravens-a price the Jets wisely avoided.
With several options at guard, the Jets can explore the veteran free-agent market, look to the draft, or a blend of both to fill the void. Their free agency strategy has been clear and cohesive, focusing on strengthening their defense and seeking value without overspending. Letting Simpson go for the hefty price he commanded aligns perfectly with this plan, ensuring the Jets remain flexible and focused on their broader team-building goals.