The idea of the Jets handing the offense to Cade Klubnik feels less like a move for the present than a declaration that the present is over.
After New York’s indefensible loss to the previously winless Miami Dolphins, a game that left a lot of this fanbase emotionally detached from Aaron Glenn, the conversation has shifted to whether the 2-5 Jets should start looking ahead. Klubnik, the rookie quarterback, is the obvious name getting thrown around, especially with the team all but pointed toward the 2027 NFL Draft class and quarterbacks such as Drew Mestemaker and CJ Carr.
But swapping Klubnik into the lineup now would amount to waving the white flag on 2026 before the season has really had a chance to sort itself out. That’s a hard sell when Geno Smith has been far from the problem.
Smith has been better than expected after his failed Raiders stint, and his production is on track to land just under 4,000 passing yards, 24 touchdown passes and only eight interceptions. Those numbers would put him second in Jets history for passing yards. More important than the raw totals is the fact that he’s still moving the offense at a decent clip despite the recent frustration around him.
And there is frustration, no question. The offense has underachieved even with a group of interesting playmakers in Garrett Wilson, Kenyon Sadiq, Mason Taylor and Omar Cooper Jr., plus the Braelon Allen breakout. Smith hasn’t been force-feeding Wilson, but he has been getting the ball where it needs to go often enough to keep the offense functioning.
That’s why the argument for Klubnik is so thin right now. What exactly suggests he would distribute the ball more effectively than Smith? At this point, it mostly comes down to the vague, familiar line of “you never know until you try.”
There’s also the reality of Aaron Glenn’s situation. He isn’t getting fired in the middle of the season unless things become completely unsalvageable, and he’s going to chase every possible chance to save his job. He can’t honestly look at the roster and say Klubnik gives this team a better chance to win right now.
Players fighting for the season don’t care about draft positioning, and Glenn isn’t about to sacrifice the little job security he still has just to find out whether Klubnik can survive NFL speed in real time. The rookie didn’t throw a touchdown pass in the preseason and had trouble against an ACC schedule last season. Nothing about that points to an immediate fix.
If the Jets are officially out of playoff contention late in the year, then sure, maybe there’s room to give Klubnik a couple of starts and see what they have. Until then, Smith is the safer bet - effective, if not always clean in the biggest spots.
In Other News...
Jets Trade Deadline Could Force Tough Calls Across This Roster
With the Nov. 10 trade deadline approaching, the Jets are facing the kind of roster decisions that can quietly reshape a season before the calendar even flips to winter. Veterans on expiring contracts are already in the conversation, and the bigger issue is how a few players fit into a changing depth chart as the team evaluates both present production and future flexibility.
Among the names being discussed are Harrison Phillips, Nahshon Wright, Andre Cisco, Brandon Stephens, Jamien Sherwood and Will McDonald IV, a group that reflects how wide the possibilities are for New York. Some are veterans who could appeal to other teams, while others have seen their standing shift for different reasons, leaving the Jets to weigh whether holding onto them makes more sense than collecting value now. [Read more 🡒]
Demario Davis Is Putting The Jets In A Tough Spot
Demario Davis has long been the kind of player the Jets could lean on for steadiness in the middle of the defense, but this season has brought a different conversation. The veteran linebackers leadership and experience still matter in the room, yet his physical impact has slipped enough to be felt on Sundays, and it has shown up in a defense that has not been as consistent as the team needs.
Jamien Sherwood has taken a step forward in coverage and tackling, which should have given New York a better foundation at linebacker. Instead, the pairing has not reliably settled the unit the way the Jets hoped, leaving the defense without the kind of stability that usually comes from having an established veteran alongside a rising partner. [Read more 🡒]
Aaron Glenn Has A Jets Problem Fans Can't Ignore
The Jets loss to the Dolphins did more than add another blemish to a frustrating season in the AFC East. It also put a sharper spotlight on Aaron Glenn, whose defense has struggled to deliver against division opponents and whose role as a steadying presence has become harder to sell after another defeat in Miami.
Glenn is still in place, but the optics around him have gotten tougher to ignore. His postgame message was meant to take responsibility, yet it only seemed to deepen the sense that the Jets are still looking for the right tone, the right answers and maybe even the right direction from one of their key voices. [Read more 🡒]