The Jets may already be drifting toward seller mode, and Will McDonald IV looks like one of the names that could be on the move if the slide keeps going.
New York is 1-3 after three straight losses, and Sunday’s meeting with the 3-1 Cleveland Browns at home could sharpen the conversation around the trade deadline on Nov. 10. The Jets followed their Week 1 win over the Tennessee Titans and former head coach Robert Saleh with a 23-12 loss to the Chicago Bears at Soldier Field in Week 4, a game in which they were badly beaten on both sides of the ball.
That’s the backdrop for McDonald, the former first-round pick who has drawn league interest for a year and now appears to be in a tricky spot in Aaron Glenn’s defense. Per Tony Pauline of Essentially Sports, people around the league believe it would make the most sense for the Jets and McDonald to split before the deadline if the losses keep piling up.
The No. 15 pick in the 2023 draft has not been used like a core piece so far this season. He played just 25 snaps per game through the first three weeks before seeing more action against the Bears, when the Jets’ defense was on the field for 89 plays.
Overall, he has appeared in four games with one start and has logged seven tackles, one tackle for loss, one quarterback hit and one sack. He has played 52% of the defense’s snaps and 33% of special teams snaps.
McDonald’s production last season showed why he could interest contenders. In 2024, he put up 28 tackles and 10.5 sacks, along with 11 tackles for loss and two forced fumbles. In his first season under Glenn’s system, he finished with 30 tackles and eight sacks.
New York also already exercised McDonald’s fifth-year option, which could make him even more appealing to a team looking for more than a rental. Jerry Jones said Thursday night that he liked the idea of trading for a player who could stay beyond this season, and McDonald would be on the books for $13.75 million in 2027.
If the Jets don’t plan to make McDonald a featured part of the defense, the logic points toward getting value back now. The team needs draft capital as it keeps trying to build toward contention.
In Other News...
Jets Mock Draft Outlook Just Revived A Familiar Quarterback Hope
With a 1-3 start already putting the season on shaky ground, the Jets are back in the familiar spot of being talked about through the lens of the draft rather than the standings. Their long-term outlook is getting extra attention because they are expected to hold multiple first-round picks in the 2027 NFL Draft, with one of them potentially landing inside the top five. For a team still searching for stability at quarterback, that kind of projected draft capital naturally invites another round of speculation about who might eventually become the next answer under center.
One recent mock draft revived that conversation in a big way by linking Notre Dame quarterback C.J. Carr to New York as a possible franchise fix. Carr has played well in college, and the projection has the Jets eyeing him as a long-term solution if they do end up in position to strike early. The appeal is obvious for a team that has spent years chasing certainty at the games most important spot, even if the real intrigue is in how the quarterback board could unfold before the Jets are finally on the clock. [Read more 🡒]
Geno Smith Faces A Jets Problem That Could Decide Sunday
The Browns have spent the early part of the season leaning heavily on man coverage, and that sets up an interesting test for Geno Smith and the Jets on Sunday. Cleveland has played more man than any defense in the league through four games, which means Smith will likely spend plenty of the afternoon dealing with tight coverage and the kind of one-on-one matchups that can either open things up or stall an offense in a hurry.
Smith has handled man looks well enough to keep the Jets in games, ranking near the top in success rate and completion percentage against those coverages. But the pressure point is hard to miss: he has also been taking sacks in those situations, and if that trend continues against a Browns defense built to challenge quarterbacks that way, it could shape the outcome of a crucial matchup for New York. [Read more 🡒]
Jets Face Growing Questions Over Adonai Mitchell Injury Handling
Adonai Mitchell has already missed the last two weeks with an undisclosed finger injury, and his absence is starting to raise more than routine availability questions for the Jets. The third-year receiver was ruled out for the upcoming game, and he has not practiced recently, leaving the team to manage a situation that has lingered without much clarity while the offense waits for another healthy option at receiver.
What has made the injury even more of a talking point is the uncertainty around its severity and the lack of any injured reserve move despite Mitchell missing multiple games. Reports have suggested the finger may be broken and could require surgery, but Aaron Glenn has pushed back on that line of thinking, leaving the Jets with a gap between the public explanation and the broader speculation around how serious this really is. [Read more 🡒]