The Jets have already made one trade before the deadline, sending safety Andre Cisco to the Detroit Lions for a 2028 sixth-round pick. But the move that has everyone talking is the one they apparently passed on: a reported chance to move edge rusher Will McDonald for a second-round pick.
That’s the kind of offer that usually gets a team to the table in a hurry. Instead, New York is the team making headlines for saying no, according to a New York Post report that has left plenty of people wondering what the Jets are thinking with the 4 p.m. EST deadline approaching.
On paper, McDonald’s role doesn’t exactly scream untouchable. He has started three of his nine games this season and has been on the field for 46% of the Jets’ defensive snaps. That’s already down from 66% last season, and the slide got even steeper in New York’s recent loss to Kansas City, when he played just 36% of the snaps - his third-lowest total of the year - even with starter Joseph Ossai out again.
The production hasn’t helped his case, either. McDonald has three sacks and 19 total pressures, and the report also said he asked for a bigger role in the defense without getting it. That makes the idea of turning down a second-round pick look even stranger.
Of course, there are other ways to read the situation.
One possibility is that the Jets are the ones floating the rumor to see if they can squeeze a better offer out of another team. Another is that someone in McDonald’s camp put the second-round detail out there to stir up interest and help push him out of New York. There’s no way to know for sure what’s happening behind the scenes, but the reported price is so strong that it naturally invites skepticism.
If the report is accurate, though, the Jets may be trying to play the long game with a player whose value has taken a hit. McDonald’s best stretch came in 2024, when he posted 10.5 sacks and 61 total pressures in his second NFL season. After that, he slipped to eight sacks and 42 total pressures the following year, and 2026 was already shaping up as a pivotal season for the 27-year-old, who was 24 when he entered the league.
Instead of rebuilding his stock, though, McDonald has taken another step back. The idea here would be simple: keep him through the rest of the season, let him try to rebound, and hope his value climbs before the offseason. If the Jets really were offered a second-rounder now, there’s at least a path to believing they could get even more later if he finishes strong.
But that plan comes with obvious danger. His role is shrinking, Aaron Glenn doesn’t appear to be in evaluation mode, and there’s no guarantee McDonald gets the kind of runway that would help him boost his market.
The longer this drags on, the more likely it is that his value keeps sliding instead of rising. Injury is part of that risk, too.
That’s why the safer move seems pretty clear: take the best offer available and move on. McDonald doesn’t look like a clean fit in Glenn’s defense, and even if the Jets think a new coaching staff could unlock more from him, the clock is working against them.
There’s also the bigger question of what McDonald actually is. Through four NFL seasons, he has shown enough one-dimensional traits to make him a tricky fit anywhere.
He lacks strength and edge-setting ability, which points to a role as a pure third-down specialist, much like Bryce Huff in 2022. Even as a pass rusher, his game has been uneven from week to week, even if the highs have been impressive.
And age matters here, too. McDonald will be 28 next year, which is old for a fifth-year player, especially one who entered the league at 24 and was supposed to make an immediate impact. At some point, the question stops being about upside and starts being about what he is right now.
That’s why the Jets would be wise to deal him if the market is real. If there’s demand, they should cash in before the snap count drops further, the production stalls again, or the injury risk becomes the thing that makes this whole debate moot.
In Other News...
Jets Suddenly Have A Bigger Problem Than Fans Expected Up Front
The Jets record has left plenty to unpack, but the issues up front have become impossible to ignore. Even with a roster that Pro Football Focus has ranked 13th in the league, New York has stumbled to 2-7, and the offensive line has not provided the kind of stability the team needs to make the rest of the offense work. Third-year left tackle Olu Fashanu was supposed to be part of the solution, but his season has turned into a concern of its own.
Fashanus struggles have shown up in both pass protection and run blocking, with penalties adding to the frustration around his development. The ground game has offered another clue that the Jets are not fully trusting what they are getting from his side of the line, and that matters for an offense trying to find any rhythm at all. For a team already fighting an uphill battle, the bigger problem may be that the answers up front are not arriving as quickly as expected. [Read more 🡒]
Breece Hall Sends Clear Message As Jets Pressure Builds Around Geno Smith
The Jets loss to the Chiefs pushed them to 2-6 and left them searching for answers after a fourth straight defeat, with Geno Smith again taking some of the heat for an offense that managed only modest production. Breece Hall, though, made it clear the blame should not land on one player alone, stressing that the team needs to be better across the board if it wants to stop the slide.
Halls defense of Smith came at a time when the quarterbacks future has become part of the conversation around the team, even as the Jets try to steady things heading into their next stretch of games. For a locker room already under pressure, the message from one of its most important voices was less about pointing fingers and more about keeping the focus on collective execution. [Read more 🡒]
Jets Fans Have Early Ammo In The Ty Simpson Draft Debate
With the Rams sitting at 5-4 and dealing with the kind of receiver injuries that can expose any roster decision, their choice to use the No. 13 pick on quarterback Ty Simpson is already drawing plenty of second-guessing. For Jets fans, the early debate has a familiar ring to it, because the draft board after Simpson has started to look like a place where other teams found immediate help while the Rams waited on a passer.
The review of the players taken after Simpson only sharpens the argument, especially among fans looking for proof that the safer offensive bet was sitting elsewhere in the first round. Several receivers have already flashed in ways that make the Rams' decision harder to defend, and the tight end taken after Simpson adds another layer to a conversation that is still very much alive. [Read more 🡒]