Jets Fans May Hate Where This Quarterback Debate Is Heading

As the Jets face a quarterback dilemma, skepticism surrounds the idea of signing Diego Pavia despite his pedigree and potential, with concerns about his fit and demeanor taking center stage.

Jets fans looking for the next quarterback savior may want to pump the brakes on Diego Pavia.

The former Vanderbilt star has been one of those players who draws a reaction the second he steps into the conversation. Like Johnny Manziel before him, Pavia became a lightning rod because of a self-assured style that, for some, came off as arrogance.

That profile made him easy to notice, but it didn’t make him a lock for anyone. The New York Jets passed on him in April, and now the Baltimore Ravens have moved on too, waiving last year’s Heisman Trophy runner-up with less than a week to go before training camp.

He still went undrafted.

That alone is enough to explain why some Jets fans might be tempted to circle back to him anyway. With the quarterback situation still hanging over the franchise, it’s not hard to imagine people looking at Pavia’s résumé and deciding he should be the one to finally help get the Jets back to a winning record at MetLife Stadium, not Cade Klubnik or Arch Manning.

But the case against signing him is pretty straightforward: he doesn’t really solve what the Jets need.

Pavia’s slide wasn’t just about attitude. He’s an undersized quarterback who turned 24 in February, and even teams that were interested in a developmental arm didn’t spend a seventh-round pick on him. That matters here because the Jets already have their own developmental quarterback in Klubnik.

If Klubnik wins the backup job behind Geno Smith over Bailey Zappe, then the Jets would have to decide whether to keep Zappe as the No. 3 or try to stash him on the practice squad. If they want a different practice-squad option, they’d be better off finding a veteran who becomes available unexpectedly. That doesn’t have to mean someone in their 30s.

The bigger point is that a practice squad spot is too valuable to waste on Pavia when the Jets already have a young developmental option in place. Darren Mougey has picked up enough goodwill and praise this offseason that it’s hard to see him making that kind of move.

None of that is meant to predict where Pavia’s career goes from here. As of Saturday afternoon, he was still unsigned, though it wouldn’t be surprising if he lands somewhere else for the preseason.

And there’s also this: the offseason is still the offseason. The Ravens didn’t have to cut him while worrying about another team sneaking him through waivers.

Teams always like having extra quarterbacks around. But if Baltimore - a franchise that has spent nearly a decade watching Lamar Jackson torment defenses as a dual-threat quarterback - already waived Pavia, that says something.

So yes, it would be easy to look at the Ravens cutting a mobile quarterback and wonder if the Jets should jump in. In this case, though, the smarter move is probably to stay out.

In Other News...

Arch Manning Buzz Just Gave Jets Fans A Familiar Sick Feeling

The early buzz around Arch Manning has already found its way to Jets circles, and it is easy to see why. Any hint of a franchise quarterback naturally lights up a fan base that has spent years searching for stability at the position, and Mannings name carries the kind of weight that can quickly turn draft chatter into a full-blown hope cycle. He is back at Texas after an inconsistent 2025 season, which only adds to the intrigue around how much more he can show before the next draft picture comes into focus.

For Jets fans, though, the appeal comes with a familiar caution flag. Mannings future is still unsettled, and there is no guarantee he even enters next years draft depending on how the season unfolds. There is also another quarterback to keep on the radar in Cade Klubnik, which gives the Jets at least one more name to track as the search for the right answer at the position continues. [Read more 🡒]

Jets Rebuild Suddenly Looks Ahead Of Schedule With One Catch

The Jets rebuild has started to look a lot less theoretical after a sharp rise in ESPNs ranking of NFL talent age 25 and under, a jump that reflects the work Darren Mougey and Aaron Glenn have done in reshaping the roster around younger players under contract through 2027. The appeal is obvious: New York suddenly has a foundation that stretches across both sides of the ball, with promising pieces on offense and defense giving the franchise a more believable long-term shape than it had not long ago.

Olu Fashanu and Armand Membou give the offense a chance to grow from the edges inward, while names like Kenyon Sadiq, Mason Taylor, Adonai Mitchell and Omar Cooper Jr. add to the sense that the Jets are collecting real building blocks instead of just placeholders. On defense, David Bailey, Malachi Moore, Azareye'h Thomas and D'Angelo Ponds are part of the same younger core, which is why the ranking feels earned even with one major question still hanging over the whole operation. [Read more 🡒]

Three Big Unknowns Could Define The Jets All Over Again

The Jets head into 2026 with a roster that can at least make the outline of a respectable season, but the path there still looks shaky. A lot of the optimism rests on first-year players stepping in right away, which is always a risky way to build a team, and the offense still has an obvious hole behind Garrett Wilson. Adonai Mitchell is part of the conversation there, but he has yet to show he can be counted on as a true No. 2 option, leaving the passing game with more questions than answers.

Frank Reichs arrival as offensive coordinator adds another layer of intrigue, because the Jets are betting on a fresh voice to help sort out a unit that needs stability. Aaron Glenn is facing a different kind of pressure after a rough opening season, and now he is taking on even more responsibility on defense while trying to prove the first year was not a preview of what is to come. The talent level suggests a team that could land in the 7-9 win range, but whether the coaching staff can squeeze that out remains the real unknown. [Read more 🡒]