The latest slight against Geno Smith is the kind of thing that should have Jets fans bristling.
In today’s NFL, even a veteran quarterback on a rebuilding team doesn’t get to drift into the background anymore. FanSided asked 50 of its NFL experts to rank every quarterback, and Smith came in at No. 32 out of 93. That’s not a disastrous placement on its face, but it does leave him as the fourth-worst starting quarterback on the list.
Ahead of him were only the Falcons’ Michael Penix Jr. at No. 34, the Cardinals’ Jacoby Brissett at No. 35 and the Browns’ Deshaun Watson at No. 42. If Penix is indeed the Week 1 starter, Smith’s slot looks even more pointed.
The real problem isn’t simply that Smith landed near the bottom tier. It’s that the tiering itself feels off. The list had the Titans’ Cam Ward at No. 23, which is a preference call more than a slam dunk, but there were bigger head-scratchers further down.
Fernando Mendoza, ranked No. 30, should not have been eligible at all, since he hasn’t played a game and is expected to be the Raiders’ third-string quarterback. Rookies getting pushed ahead of veterans is becoming a league-wide habit on these rankings, but it still makes for strange results.
Smith is not being sold here as a star. He’s a stopgap quarterback, a player who can hold things together for a team with bigger issues under center.
But if that’s the standard, then Joe Flacco at No. 28 should have been judged in the same bucket. Instead, Flacco was placed in the “game manager” tier, despite being a 41-year-old backup.
The strangest part might be Tua Tagovailoa checking in one spot ahead of Smith. The voting happened before Tagovailoa’s rough preseason wrapped up, but the placement still raised eyebrows.
Smith at least had the excuse of playing behind a terrible offensive line in Las Vegas last season. Tagovailoa, meanwhile, had De’Von Achane and Jaylen Waddle around him, and the Dolphins still reached the point where they were willing to take on an NFL-record $99.2 million in dead money to move on from him.
The scores were close - Tagovailoa at 6.40, Smith at 6.28 - so the gap wasn’t exactly huge. Even so, it’s hard to see why anyone would prefer Tagovailoa over Smith, especially with the injury history involved.
Maybe that’s just the “LOL Jets” cloud hanging over the franchise again.
It’s not a flattering read on Smith, and it has been that kind of offseason for him. Tagovailoa and Mendoza over Geno is a choice, no matter how you slice it. But Smith is also the one of that trio who should get an early chance to answer back on the field.
In Other News...
Jets Backup Quarterback Debate Just Got A Lot More Uncomfortable
The Jets quarterback room has taken on an oddly delicate feel after the team decided to carry only two passers on its active roster, leaving Cade Klubnik as the backup behind the starter while Bailey Zappe sits on the practice squad. Klubniks preseason didnt exactly settle the matter, and that has made his place on the depth chart feel less like a firm judgment and more like a roster call the team had to make.
Around the league, Klubnik is one of three rookie quarterbacks serving in backup roles, but the bigger question for the Jets is whether he actually won the job or simply ended up there because of how the roster broke. With the regular season approaching, that uncertainty hangs over a position where the margin for comfort is usually thin and every decision gets scrutinized a little harder. [Read more 🡒]
Jets Defense Suddenly Faces A Bigger Week 1 Concern Than Expected
Jarvis Brownlee Jr. may be front and center for the Jets sooner than expected in Week 1, with uncertainty surrounding DAngelo Ponds availability leaving New Yorks slot corner spot in a more fragile place than the matchup plan probably anticipated. Brownlee, acquired from the Titans during the previous season, is the next man up if the Jets need help inside, and that alone adds an extra layer to a game that already carried some early-season intrigue.
The assignment could be a tricky one, too, because Brownlee may end up across from Titans slot receiver WanDale Robinson, who led the league in slot receiving yards last season. Brownlees numbers have been mixed, and the Jets do not have much proven depth waiting behind him, so this is the kind of early test that can quickly ripple through a defense if the coverage structure does not hold up. [Read more 🡒]
Mason Taylor Is Giving The Jets A Tough Week 1 Decision
Mason Taylor has spent training camp doing exactly what the Jets needed from a young tight end: making himself hard to ignore. He caught 17 passes from Geno Smith in team drills, more than any other Jets tight end, and his workload has reflected both his receiving ability and the coaching staffs confidence in his blocking.
His rise has also been helped by Kenyon Sadiq working back from a hernia recovery, which opened more opportunities for Taylor to climb the depth chart. The question now is how much of that camp momentum carries into the regular season, especially with other offensive weapons around Smith and a week-one plan that still has plenty of moving parts. [Read more 🡒]