The Jets are heading into Sunday’s game against the AFC North-leading Browns without Adonai Mitchell, and the bigger story is the silence around his finger injury.
Mitchell hasn’t practiced this week, and New York already ruled him out after he missed the last two weeks with what the team has called an undisclosed finger issue. That absence has started to look less like a short-term setback and more like something the Jets are keeping under wraps.
ESPN’s Rich Cimini added to the uncertainty on The Jets Collective podcast, saying he hasn’t seen Mitchell “in a couple of weeks” and wouldn’t be shocked if the 2024 third-round pick needed surgery.
“They are being really secretive about it,” Cimini said. “I was told that it was broken.
[Jets coach Aaron] Glenn denied that. We will find out.”
That’s a sharp turn for a player many viewed as a breakout candidate after a strong offseason and preseason. Mitchell opened the year with nine catches for 123 yards in the Jets’ first two games, and he had 24 receptions, 301 yards, and two touchdowns after arriving in New York in last November’s Sauce Gardner trade.
The injury handling has raised its own questions, too. NFL rules do not allow teams to conceal injuries, though players can be listed as out for personal or undisclosed reasons in certain situations. The league also told NBC Sports in 2023 that teams do not have to put players dealing with an illness on the injury report if they fully participate in practice.
So far, the Jets have at least been consistent in one respect: Mitchell has repeatedly shown up as a non-participant. Still, if he did have surgery, it’s fair to wonder why he wasn’t placed on injured reserve. He has already been out since Week 2, and IR players can return after missing a minimum of four games.
For now, the details remain murky, and Glenn’s group is giving fans little clarity. That only adds to the frustration around a team that has dropped 17 of 21 games under Glenn.
In Other News...
Jets Mock Draft Outlook Just Revived A Familiar Quarterback Hope
With a 1-3 start already putting the season on shaky ground, the Jets are back in the familiar spot of being talked about through the lens of the draft rather than the standings. Their long-term outlook is getting extra attention because they are expected to hold multiple first-round picks in the 2027 NFL Draft, with one of them potentially landing inside the top five. For a team still searching for stability at quarterback, that kind of projected draft capital naturally invites another round of speculation about who might eventually become the next answer under center.
One recent mock draft revived that conversation in a big way by linking Notre Dame quarterback C.J. Carr to New York as a possible franchise fix. Carr has played well in college, and the projection has the Jets eyeing him as a long-term solution if they do end up in position to strike early. The appeal is obvious for a team that has spent years chasing certainty at the games most important spot, even if the real intrigue is in how the quarterback board could unfold before the Jets are finally on the clock. [Read more 🡒]
Geno Smith Faces A Jets Problem That Could Decide Sunday
The Browns have spent the early part of the season leaning heavily on man coverage, and that sets up an interesting test for Geno Smith and the Jets on Sunday. Cleveland has played more man than any defense in the league through four games, which means Smith will likely spend plenty of the afternoon dealing with tight coverage and the kind of one-on-one matchups that can either open things up or stall an offense in a hurry.
Smith has handled man looks well enough to keep the Jets in games, ranking near the top in success rate and completion percentage against those coverages. But the pressure point is hard to miss: he has also been taking sacks in those situations, and if that trend continues against a Browns defense built to challenge quarterbacks that way, it could shape the outcome of a crucial matchup for New York. [Read more 🡒]
Aaron Glenn Calls Out What Really Doomed The Jets Defense
The Jets came out of Week 4 with plenty to sort through after Chicago piled up yards and kept drives moving in a game that never really settled into New Yorks favor. The defense bent far too often, but Aaron Glenns postgame attention kept landing on a more specific issue than the raw yardage total, the kind of detail coaches tend to circle when a game gets away from them.
For Glenn, the bigger problem was how often the Bears were allowed to extend possessions and avoid handing the ball back. New York was flagged 12 times for 76 yards, and those mistakes repeatedly undercut whatever the defense managed to do on a given snap, turning stops into fresh chances for Chicago and leaving the Jets chasing the game with little margin anywhere else. [Read more 🡒]