The Colts’ mess might have put Quenton Nelson back on the radar for the Jets.
With the Nov. 10 trade deadline closing in, Indianapolis is suddenly looking like a team that could do business. The Colts are 2-4 after handing the Tennessee Titans their first win of the season last week, and they also fired Chris Ballard this week after nearly 10 years as general manager. That kind of turbulence usually sends veteran names into the rumor mill, and Nelson is already in it.
According to NFL insider Tom Pelissero, the Colts have received “strong trade interest” in Nelson, and “no player is expected to be off limits if they decide to sell before the deadline.”
That puts a familiar question in play for New York: should the Jets jump in?
Nelson would certainly qualify as the kind of player who can change an offense in a hurry. He’s 30, but he’s still performing like one of the league’s best interior linemen.
Through six games, he owns an 89.2 overall grade from Pro Football Focus, which ranks first among 74 qualified guards. He’s third in run-blocking at 88.3 and fifth in pass protection at 79.6.
The production backs it up. On 248 pass-blocking snaps this season, Nelson has given up just six pressures and no sacks, and he’s been flagged only once. That kind of clean, steady work is exactly why his résumé already includes eight Pro Bowl nods and six combined All-Pro selections since the Colts made him the sixth overall pick in 2018.
He’s also been remarkably dependable. Nelson has started 135 of 139 possible games in his career, missing only four in 2021, and he has started every game since entering the league.
For the Jets, the football case is easy to see. Their offensive line has been uneven this season, with Dylan Parham’s absence not helping and the group struggling to protect Geno Smith in key moments. The run game has also been inconsistent from week to week.
Adding Nelson would force some reshuffling, but it would be a worthwhile one. The cleanest setup would be moving Joe Tippmann back to center, where he’s had his most success since being drafted in 2022, sliding Parham to right guard, where he has NFL experience, and shifting Josh Myers into the backup role that best suits him.
That would give New York a much better front. In fact, Nelson is the kind of player who can raise the level of the whole unit.
The harder part is deciding whether the price makes sense.
The Jets are sitting on five first-round picks over the next two years, including two that originally belonged to Indianapolis in the Sauce Gardner deal. But that doesn’t mean they should start spending draft capital freely. They still need to keep building through the draft, and at some point one of those picks has to go toward a top-tier quarterback.
Then there’s Nelson’s contract. He’s in the final season of the four-year, $80 million extension he signed with the Colts in 2022, and he’s set to become an unrestricted free agent after the season. So this wouldn’t be a simple rental chase.
That’s why the asking price matters so much. A second-round pick could be justified, but even that would be a hefty investment for a Jets team that is not one guard away from turning into a playoff club. They have other needs, and holding onto that second-rounder this year feels important.
If Indianapolis settles for a third-round pick, though, the equation changes. That’s the range where Nelson starts to look like a much more appealing target for New York: an immediate upgrade who could also fit into a longer-term plan.
In Other News...
Jets Face A Three-Game Stretch That Could Reshape Their Deadline Plans
A three-game stretch is now looming over the Jets deadline thinking, and it has pushed Will McDonald back into the conversation even after the team exercised his fifth-year option. Daniel Popper of The Athletic placed the edge rusher at No. 20 on his 2026 NFL trade deadline big board, a reminder that the Jets could have a meaningful asset on their hands if the season starts to tilt in one direction or another.
What happens before Nov. 10 may matter as much as McDonalds own value. If the Jets are sitting at 2-7, the logic could shift toward selling, while a 4-5 mark would make it far easier to justify keeping him in the fold, and that makes the next few weeks feel like more than just another midseason run of games. [Read more 🡒]
Jets Pass Rush Problems Make One Darren Mougey Move Hurt Again
The Jets pass rush has become one of the sharper reminders of how thin the margin is between a bold roster move and a decision that lingers all season. A year after Darren Mougey sent defensive tackle Quinnen Williams to Dallas in November 2025, the interior pressure issue that Williams once helped stabilize is still part of the conversation around New Yorks 2026 defense, even as the deal brought back meaningful draft capital for the future.
Williams play in Dallas has not looked as disruptive as it did in previous seasons, according to Pro Football Focus, which adds another layer to how the Jets evaluate the move now. New York used the second-rounder from that trade to land cornerback DAngelo Ponds, a reminder that the return was always going to be measured over time rather than by one immediate fix, and the pass rush problems only make that balancing act look more complicated. [Read more 🡒]